Why don't Cantonese and Guangxi people fight for Hong Xiuquan of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom?

In Lingnan area, many historical celebrities and even modern celebrities are competing for each other. For example, is the singer Liu Sanjie from Yizhou or Guilin, the national hero Yuan Chonghuan from Shijie, Guangdong or tengxian, Wuzhou, Guangxi, and the founding father Dr. Sun Yat-sen from Guangfu or Hakka. But why is Hong Xiuquan, the king of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, the only one, but no one is fighting for it?

One? Hong Xiuquan's native place is obviously Cantonese, but Cantonese people despise him.

1. Hong Xiuquan is from Guangdong:

(1) has a very funny phenomenon. Whenever I hear that Hong Xiuquan is from Guangdong, many mainlanders will say that Hong Xiuquan is not from Guangxi. Even a considerable number of Cantonese people will say, when did Hong Xiuquan become a Cantonese, and he came to visit relatives.

(2) In fact, Hong Xiuquan's native place is really Guangdong, and he is an out-and-out Cantonese. 18 14, Hong Xiuquan was born in Huaxian County, Guangzhou City, Guangdong Province (now Huadu District, Guangzhou City). It can be seen that Hong Xiuquan is not only a native of Guangdong, but also the capital of Guangdong today.

2. Cantonese people look down on Hong Xiuquan;

(1) But whether Hong Xiuquan is regarded as a native of Guangxi or an out-and-out Cantonese, most Cantonese people don't like him. This can be seen from the denial of Cantonese when Hong Xiuquan is mentioned as a Cantonese. And there are indeed many Cantonese people. I didn't know Hong Xiuquan was from Guangdong.

(2) Cantonese people have a sense of justice, and every Cantonese is full of noble sentiments of pursuing and upholding justice. At the same time, Cantonese people are full of patriotic feelings and have sincere love and deep feelings for their motherland. Hong Xiuquan, on the other hand, is a fanatical religious figure, spreading God-worshipping religion to establish the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, inducing people to revolt and misleading people to take the road of no return. Therefore, although Hong Xiuquan's Cantonese identity is undeniable and inescapable, Hong Xiuquan, who is full of religious fanatics, cultists and rebels, is not liked by Cantonese.

Two? Hong Xiuquan has a deep brand of Guangxi, but Guangxi people don't like him either:

1. Hong Xiuquan has a deep brand of Guangxi:

(1) There is another funny phenomenon here. Whenever I hear that Hong Xiuquan is from Guangdong, many people in Guangxi will react: What, Hong Xiuquan is not from Guangxi, I told you so; Fortunately, Hong Xiuquan is not from Guangxi; It turns out that Hong Xiuquan is from Guangdong, and Guangxi has been scolded for so long. Fortunately, Hong Xiuquan is not from Guangxi, and so on. It can be seen that Guangxi people don't like Hong Xiuquan either, and the degree of dislike is still relatively large.

(2) Throughout Hong Xiuquan's life, he was born in Hua County, Guangzhou, Guangdong Province, and succeeded in starting a business in Guiping, Guangxi. He started with 30,000 soldiers in Guangxi, and gradually developed into the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom with millions of mercenaries, countless famous soldiers and ten Yu Sheng influences. In Hong Xiuquan's career, soldiers and generals in Guangxi contributed the most, so both Hong Xiuquan and the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom were deeply branded with Guangxi.

2. Guangxi people don't like Hong Xiuquan either:

( 1)? Disputes between locals and tourists? ：

Before Hong Xiuquan established the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, the dispute between the Turks and the Turks, also known as the clash and fight between the Turks and the Turks, occurred from time to time, and the scale was not small, and the gap between the two sides was very large. Disputes between Guangxi people and tourists in Qing Dynasty. Earth? Fang is mainly a minority living in Guangxi. Guest? Fang is mainly a Hakka of Han nationality who moved to Guangxi. Hong Xiuquan's family background in Guiping Uprising is mainly Hakkas of Han nationality. For example, the generals in the early days of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom were mostly Han Hakkas in Guangxi, and the initial 30,000 soldiers in Guangxi were mostly Han Hakkas. It is precisely because most of Hong Xiuquan's troops are Hakkas of Han nationality that they are not tolerated and disliked by ethnic minorities living in Guangxi. Therefore, after the successful uprising in Guiping, Guangxi, Hong Xiuquan had to temporarily avoid the border and lead the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom to Hunan.

(2) Guangxi soldiers followed Hong Xiuquan in large numbers, and all their glory was lost;

Hong Xiuquan's Taiping Heavenly Kingdom was successfully established in Guangxi, developed and expanded in Jiangnan, and successfully listed in Nanjing. It can be said that soldiers from Guangxi are the core and elite of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, and they have helped Hong Xiuquan and the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom a lot, which is both glory and loss. But this is where the problem arises. It would be great if the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom finally won, but the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom finally failed. As the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom finally failed, the Guangxi soldiers who followed Hong Xiuquan naturally lost everything. Losers will never get tolerance and pity. Not only others will not pity you, but even our own people will be ashamed of you.

Three? The Taiping Heavenly Kingdom founded by Hong Xiuquan has a bad reputation;

1. After Hong Xiuquan made Tianjing his capital, the feudal privilege thought of the leadership of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom began to expand rapidly, striving for power and profit and seeking pleasure. The internal division of the leadership was serious and the struggle was sharp, which led to the failure of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom. The vigorous Taiping Heavenly Kingdom Movement not only caused numerous deaths and injuries to Guangxi soldiers who followed Hong Xiuquan, but also destroyed the land in the south of the Yangtze River and exhausted the spirit of the Qing Dynasty, which indirectly led to the failure of a series of wars between the Qing Dynasty and the eastern and western powers.

2. The laws of the kingdom of heaven are quite strict and even abnormal, and the criminal law is cruel and heartless. Anyone who violates the doctrine of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom will be sentenced to death. This not only violates Hong Xiuquan's original intention of advocating revolutionary salvation and humanity, but also runs counter to the original intention of establishing the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom. Moreover, the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom under the leadership of Hong Xiuquan also practiced abstinence orders, and even couples were asexual and free. For example, in the official document Tian Liqingshu published in 1854, the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom particularly emphasized abstinence, which violated the harmony, human relations and humanity among people and was condemned by thousands of people.

3. It can be seen that both Hong Xiuquan himself and the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom founded by Hong Xiuquan have a bad reputation, low evaluation and even a little notoriety, which makes people avoid it. Therefore, Hong Xiuquan is invincible in creating such a Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, and Cantonese and Guangxi people naturally don't like him.