How is Chinese medicine marginalized?

Medical. If a patient dies under Western medicine treatment, the patient deserves to die; if a patient dies under TCM treatment, it is a medical malpractice. If

the patient gets better under the treatment of Western medicine, this is the scientific and inevitable result of Western medicine; if the patient gets better under the treatment of traditional Chinese medicine, it is accidental

A miracle that has no scientific basis and cannot be repeated.

What is even more serious is that even if Chinese medicine can treat diseases reproducibly according to the statistical standards of Western medicine, Western medicine still arrogantly refuses to admit it.

When the 2003

SARS

epidemic broke out in Guangzhou, Guangzhou generally used integrated traditional Chinese and Western medicine treatment, and the effect was very obvious. By

2003

May

mid-month

, the First Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou University of Traditional Chinese Medicine After treating

50

more than 50 patients, no one died, the average fever reduction time was

3

days, and none of the medical staff

Infection. The Western Medicine Hospital where Academician Zhong Nanshan worked treated 117

patients, 10 of which died; among them

/p>

71

patients received interventional treatment with traditional Chinese medicine

and only one died. In other words, in the hospital led by Zhong Nanshan, who is known as "the number one hero in the fight against SARS", 46 patients were treated with pure Western medicine.

9

people died. It is also worth mentioning that patients treated with traditional Chinese medicine have no sequelae, while patients treated with Western medicine develop pulmonary fibrosis and femoral head necrosis in large numbers. The comparison of treatment costs is also extremely obvious. Beijing Xiaotangshan Hospital's western medicine treatment mobilizes ventilators from various countries in Asia. Each ventilator is burned and destroyed after use. This cost per person alone is up to

10,000 yuan. Originally, Guangzhou's traditional Chinese medicine treatment

SARS

was effective and should be promoted in Beijing. However, since

SARS

was later classified as an infectious disease,

according to regulations, patients could only be admitted to infectious diseases hospitals, so the traditional Chinese medicine hospitals in Beijing did not dare to admit them. patient. Because no leader of a traditional Chinese medicine hospital dares to guarantee that traditional Chinese medicine treatment will not kill anyone. Western medicine is allowed to treat any number of people to death, but Chinese medicine treating one person to death is a medical malpractice. According to Western medicine theory, to treat

SARS

, specific antibiotics need to be developed. However, despite the fact that there are still no effective antibiotics, some leading authorities still only allow Western medicine to treat SARS

. This is very disappointing. Something strange happened.

From this, I even thought angrily that *** Gong does not allow believers to go to the hospital for treatment when they are sick, and Western medicine does not allow patients to receive Western medicine treatment

when it is not good. Traditional Chinese medicine treatment; *** can use the name of faith to declare the death of believers as the upper level, and Western medicine can use the name of science to declare the patient's death as destiny; why are the logics of the two so similar? Are we all believers in Western medicine? Are we all hostages of Western medicine?

Who gave our right to life to Western medicine? ＊＊＊Gong believers still have a choice, but the vast majority of us have no choice since we were born, so we naturally become believers in Western medicine?

Yesterday, I recommended a Chinese medicine doctor to a friend on the phone. This friend's father had pneumonia and was also receiving treatment at Peking University Hospital. Although the pneumonia has improved, there are problems with other organs. Towards the end of the call, I suddenly realized that superstition about Western medicine is indeed common in society. If, as children, parents are allowed to receive TCM treatment, parents, relatives and friends will privately think that the children are unfilial.

But

Sad! What a pity!

What is the reason why Chinese medicine has fallen to this point?

Looking at the direct reason, there are few good doctors and many quacks in Chinese medicine. One dose

Dozens of flavors of Chinese medicine are like shooting sparrows with a shotgun. If the aim is not accurate, there will always be one that is right for the patient.

Some patients also believe in traditional Chinese medicine, especially in small and medium-sized cities

Cities, towns and rural areas. Due to the low medical cost of traditional Chinese medicine and the less pollution from the supremacy of Western medicine in big cities, they seek medical treatment from traditional Chinese medicine. , but what we often look for are quacks. Although the disease cannot be cured for a while, it cannot be cured. Over time, the patient lost confidence in traditional Chinese medicine, and still sought Western medicine for surgery

to engage in "violent revolution."

However, why are there so many quacks? This is also related to the training of Western medicine in traditional Chinese medicine. Traditional Chinese medicine needs to be taught by teachers. Because Chinese medicine faces

a complex complex of contradictions, in which there are countless layers of contradictions at work, some are primary (system level) and some are secondary (organ

Official level), secondary level (organization level), and tertiary level (cell level). In each level of contradictions, there are multiple levels from primary contradictions to secondary contradictions

. Each pair of contradictions is relatively easy to resolve individually, and there are certain rules and regulations to follow. But when different contradictions at different levels interact with each other, how can we treat them based on syndrome differentiation? A single principle is not enough. If multiple principles fight against each other, is there still a principle? Therefore, it is necessary to balance and coordinate the principles, to find the main principles and secondary principles, and to clarify the relationship between yang and yin. Each patient's condition is different, that is, the organization of the contradictory relationship is different. The same disease may have completely different causes; the same cause may have completely different manifestation locations and modes.

Therefore, training traditional Chinese medicine is like training a country’s prime minister. It requires both clinical practice and teacher-teacher teaching. This is why there is a saying that "if you don't have a good appearance, you will be a good doctor". The use of Chinese medicine pays attention to the compatibility of monarch, minister and auxiliary agents. The monarch medicine attacks the main contradiction, the minister medicine strengthens the power of the monarch medicine. The auxiliary medicine attacks the secondary contradictions and restrains the toxic and side effects of the monarch medicine, so that the medicine can harmonize the properties of the medicine. This is like rectifying a company with chaotic management. It not only needs to replace the main leaders, rectify morale, adjust market strategies, develop new products, and strengthen quality control, but also needs to proceed step by step to prevent mistakes during the rectification period.

Procedure, resulting in the loss of funds, customers, and technology, that is, we must know how to appease people's hearts, pay attention to cracking down on a small group, and protecting the majority. Therefore, pure academic training of traditional Chinese medicine can only train department-level cadres who can solve a single type of problem, but cannot train prime ministers. This kind of department-level cadres are the traditional Chinese medicine doctors who stick to one or two prescriptions for their entire lives. This kind of traditional Chinese medicine doctor waits and waits. When he finds the right prescription for his condition, he becomes a "miraculous doctor". If he doesn't get it right, he becomes a quack doctor. From an external statistical perspective, the patient concluded that this was a quackery. Really good medicine

medicine can adapt to changing circumstances and achieve extraordinary results. For example,

in 1957

, Japanese encephalitis was prevalent in Beijing. The famous doctor Pu Fuzhou cured

167

cases of encephalitis.

98

different prescriptions were used. However, the Ministry of Health led by Western medicine actually believes that just because each prescription solves less than

2

personal problems,

Mr. Pu’s medical skills are No statistical significance! Using the mechanistic approach of Western medicine to lead and evaluate the holism of Chinese medicine is like asking a child to evaluate adult behavior, which is ridiculous and lamentable.

The result of using the Western medicine model to transform traditional Chinese medicine is that,

according to estimates,

at the beginning of liberation, there were about 5,000 good doctors in the country

There are about

only 500

names left.

What is even more puzzling is that according to the "Law on Practicing Physicians" promulgated by the Ministry of Health, those traditional Chinese medicine practitioners who have no academic qualifications and do not understand foreign languages, but have practiced medicine for a long time and have a good reputation will not be qualified to practice medicine. . Dr. Wang Wenkui mentioned many times in this article, strictly speaking, does not have the medical qualifications recognized by the Ministry of Health. Isn’t it said that practice is the only criterion for testing truth? How come when it comes to medical issues, Western medicine has become the embodiment of science and truth and has the right to deny other medicines?

In fact, Western medicine only recognizes the science of atomic theory and mechanics, which is the science of the Newtonian mechanics era. Unfortunately, although Newton's mechanics ushered in a new era of mechanics, its influence was overextended. The truth one step forward is a fallacy. Since the birth of Newtonian mechanics,

Western ideological and medical circles have been obsessed with Newtonian mechanics. In the ideological world, Locke and Smith, including Hegel and Marx to a certain extent, were deeply influenced by Newtonian mechanics.

However, Newtonian mechanics is only suitable for a macroscopic physical world that is deterministic, reversible, mechanical, divisible and isolable

(atomic theory). The development of Western natural science actually quickly surpassed the world of Newtonian mechanics. The discoveries of thermodynamics, chemistry, biological evolution, quantum mechanics and relativity broke this deterministic and reversible world and brought us a highly complex, irreversible and accidental world. world. However, the Western medical community is completely isolated from the changes in natural science and remains stuck in the era of Newtonian mechanics.

So

Qian Xuesen, a great scientist engaged in systems theory and cybernetics, once said (to the effect): Western medicine is in its infancy, and there will be another four to five hundred years

It takes years to enter systems theory, and it takes another four to five hundred years to reach the holism of traditional Chinese medicine.

However, although traditional Chinese medicine and traditional Chinese culture may be far ahead of the West in their understanding of the human body and society, modern China was

a strong ship armed with Newtonian mechanics. Li Pao was defeated. Originally, learning the skills of the foreigners to control them, "Chinese learning as the body and Western learning as the application", was completely possible to solve China's scientific and technological problems. However, because Chinese society at that time was dominated by "Chinese people like Cixi" Ruled by "quack doctors" and lacking in "middle school physique", it failed again in the Sino-Japanese War of 1894-1894. The national public opinion does not distinguish between "quack doctors" and "good doctors", abandoning "middle school" and setting off a wave of total westernization

After the Revolution of 1911, the Beiyang government "decided to abandon traditional Chinese medicine and use traditional Chinese medicine" on the grounds that "it is difficult to use both Chinese and Western medicine".

In 1929

In 1929, the Nanjing government stated that "if the old medicine is not eliminated, the people's thinking will not change, the new medical industry will not be able to make progress, and the health administration will not be able to do so

On the grounds of "carrying out", the "abolition of old medical records" was adopted. Although these measures were strongly opposed by the public and had to be discontinued, they still dealt a huge blow to traditional Chinese medicine. After liberation, although Mao Zedong advocated the integration of traditional Chinese and Western medicine, because the Ministry of Health was basically dominated by Western medicine, the result of the integration of traditional Chinese and Western medicine was that Western medicine was mainly combined with traditional Chinese medicine, making traditional Chinese medicine a second-class citizen. .

After the 1980s

After the 1980s, the theory of total westernization became more and more popular again

Chinese medicine retreated from second-class citizens to third-class citizens, and even faced being dismissed. danger of extinction.

In fact, the true integration of Chinese and Western medicine can only be "Chinese medicine as the mainstay, Western medicine as the supplement." Traditional Chinese medicine can prevent the slightest signs of disease and nip most diseases in their budding or growing state. When the disease develops to a completely irreversible stage, the "violent revolution" of Western medicine can be used.

As for which condition

is completely irreversible, it depends on the level of treatment of traditional Chinese medicine. For doctors like Wang Wenkui, late-stage lung cancer can still be reversed. For less skilled traditional Chinese medicine doctors (who are also good doctors, but with slightly lower medical skills), early and mid-stage lung cancer can be reversed.

In this way, it is possible to form a traditional Chinese medicine network composed of a few outstanding doctors and a majority of ordinary doctors, covering both urban and rural areas of the country at a cost far lower than that of western medicine.

Those who share the same disease cherish each other, orangutans cherish each other. In the medical field, traditional Chinese medicine is not mainstream. In the field of economics, I am also outside the mainstream. The non-mainstream experience is

similar. In the field of economics, a Ph.D. in economics with a background in mathematics, even though he knows nothing about economic history, even though he has no understanding of the complexity of the economy and society, he can play with statistical data to make models, and he can write When articles are published in international academic journals, one can rely on the reputation of publishing papers in international journals to influence economic policies, just like a doctor of medicine who studies molecular biology can influence a disease.

It’s the same as people disposing of it at will. The economy was ruined and patients were killed, but they were the embodiment of science and could not bear any responsibility. They blamed the patients for not being their typical patients.

Woohoo! It is better to go back and study Chinese medicine.

Source: "Tianya"

2005

Fourth issue

Netizen

Publication time

p>

: 2006-05-12 10:40 IP

Address:

61.186.152.*

My classmate has been married for many years,

I had a miscarriage in 2001

I was pregnant with a child, and then I couldn’t get pregnant. I went to a so-called specialist hospital and spent a lot of money

and also had surgery. No, after the Spring Festival this year, I went to a traditional Chinese medicine shop that bought herbal medicine in my hometown town and bought 3 pieces of traditional Chinese medicine. Now I am pregnant.

3

More than a month

111

Published time

: 2006-05-12 10:37 IP

Address:

220.185.253.*

May I ask my friends downstairs,

Chronic colitis is in It was cured there. My mother also has this disease. Thank you in advance. Please send me an email

EMAIL

to chat

Mine is

PHP-JACK@SOHU.COM

Netizen

Published time

: 2006-05-12 10:17 IP

Address:

202.96.189.*

It is difficult for science today to explain the theory of traditional Chinese medicine in many aspects, but it cannot be said to be pseudoscience. After all, it has been proven in practice for thousands of years. .

Chinese people, let’s take action to save traditional Chinese medicine!

21CN

Netizen

Published time

: 2006-05-12 09:45 IP

Address ：

222.222.1.*

In general, the breadth and depth of Chinese medicine cannot be compared with Western medicine, but the current academic system of Chinese medicine has not made Chinese medicine more promising

The development of the theoretical system of science. Rather, it relies more on the summary of practical experience. That's why so many quacks have been created. So everyone

If you believe in Chinese medicine, you must find a doctor who has treated the disease you have suffered from, otherwise you will encounter a quack doctor again.

21CN

Netizen

Published time

: 2006-05-12 09:45 IP

Address :

222.222.1.*

There are

2

examples:

1

In the past, because I was driving a motorcycle, I was often exposed to the wind, so I was prone to respiratory infections, usually once every two weeks.

Seeing a Western doctor just prescribes antibiotics for you. The price is very expensive, usually about 200 yuan a time

, and it needs to be continued

2

Refund will take more than 2 weeks. I even doubted whether

it had nothing to do with western medicine. In the end, recovery relied on one's own immunity. Later, by chance, I got an upper respiratory tract infection again. I saw a traditional Chinese medicine doctor and took 3 doses of medicine

After 1

dose, the patient was noticeably better.

3

doses solved the problem and he fully recovered within a week.

21CN

Netizen

Published time

: 2006-05-12 09:35 IP

Address ：

59.35.202.*

Traditional Chinese medicine requires hard practice

10 years

before it can really produce results

~~~

Western medicine does not require it

,

short-term effects are good

,

make money quickly

!!

In addition

,

Western medicine treats foot pain

,

Headache doctor is the head doctor

,

TCM is not the case

,

Chinese medicine has to find out the source of the disease before it can be cured, such as Reflux gastritis

,

Also known as bile reflux gastritis

,

Traditional Chinese medicine

The treatment method is to focus on the liver and spleen, while Western medicine blindly takes anti-inflammatory drugs to achieve the purpose.

2

Compared with those who take Western medicine, the situation under the medicine

Next,

10 years

won’t be better, and the monthly medical expenses will reach more than a thousand yuan! Taking traditional Chinese medicine, if the medicine is taken correctly, it can cost less than

100

yuan per month, and the disease will be mild

2

It can be cured in a few months, but if the disease is severe, it will take

3

,

5

months Until about

1

year!

21CN

Netizen

Published time

: 2006-05-12 09:28 IP

Address :

210.75.39.*

I admire Chinese medicine, but I think everyone should not go to extremes and say that Western medicine is so ineffective. When the day comes when traditional Chinese medicine takes a dominant position in our country and even in the world, Western medicine should also have a place, just like today, when Western medicine has an absolute advantage, sufficient space should be left for traditional Chinese medicine.

The same room for development. I think this society is diverse. No matter in the field of ideology or technology, we should not engage in unidimensionalization. It does not mean that if A is good, B will not be able to do it. B will be beaten to death with a stick. I think we Chinese people are indeed not perfect in this regard

In fact, don’t think this is a small problem. Under the guidance of this way of thinking, it is not only reflected in daily life, but also in many aspects

There are few historical tragedies because of the influence of this way of thinking, such as the burning of books and the imprisonment of scholars, including some problems in modern times.

If you think about it carefully, will this way of thinking hinder the progress of social civilization and technology?

21CN

Netizen

Published time

: 2006-05-12 09:16 IP

Address :

219.135.239.

My opinion on Chinese medicine and Western medicine:

Traditional Chinese medicine is cheap and effective (real Chinese medicine)

, but there are very few real TCM doctors, mainly because of system problems. If TCM doctors want to pursue profits, they can only use more Western medicine methods. Therefore, the TCM doctors trained by TCM colleges are not as good as Western medicine. It is not as good as Western doctors, but the level of Chinese medicine

is far worse than that of our ancestors. It is recommended to reform the system. There are three types of practicing doctors: one is Western medicine (cannot use Chinese medicine)

, one

is pure Chinese medicine (no Western medicine can be used)

, and one is combined Chinese and Western medicine (both Chinese and Western medicine can be used)

, and the other is When cultivating pure Chinese medicine, it is necessary to train Western medicine in cardiopulmonary resuscitation, because this trick is where Chinese medicine falls short.

In the era of seclusion, China’s population has reached hundreds of millions, which shows the power of traditional Chinese medicine. However, Western medicine also has its own magical effects and deserves our respect.

This article is of high quality in its vertical and horizontal integration, but its critical point of view on statistics seems to be questionable.

I guess there was no shortage of quacks in ancient China. Moreover, today’s medical environment is more complex than in ancient times, so the traditional Chinese medicine training system also needs reform.

Strengthening investment is a necessary condition for traditional Chinese medicine to flourish. The former sought TCM treatment for back problems and was deeply aware of the difficulties and hardships of TCM medicine.

I still believe in traditional Chinese medicine, because I have been seeing traditional Chinese medicine since childhood for headaches and fever. Nowadays, traditional Chinese medicine is indeed getting worse day by day. In Hua Tuo’s

era, who would dare to say that Is Chinese medicine useless? The current situation is that many traditional Chinese medicine hospitals in Guangzhou are eager for quick success and instant benefits, and traditional Chinese medicine uses Western medicine methods to treat patients.

It is really sad. Now it is not a question of whether Chinese medicine works, but whether it is a good doctor. However, because of the serious air pollution now, herbal medicine

is not as good as before. In the past, herbal medicines were purely natural, but now artificially grown herbs are still as effective as before. Therefore, the regression of traditional Chinese medicine is also caused by the general environment. Only when the state vigorously supports and promotes traditional Chinese medicine can traditional Chinese medicine succeed. But looking at the current Ministry of Health under the leadership of Western medicine, it is difficult.

I believe in Chinese medicine. Only experienced Chinese medicine doctors can treat the disease effectively. Western medicine says that antibacterial and antibiotic surgeries are effective but harmful to the body. Once the antibacterial medicine is used, it will not work the next time. Patients who are declared incurable by Western medicine are often favored by experienced Chinese medicine

!

The reason why Chinese medicine is favored by everyone is that it is exactly the opposite of Western medicine and pursues the root cause rather than simply treating the symptoms. Traditional Chinese medicine does not require instruments.

You can find the cause of the disease by just looking, smelling, asking, and inquiring. Isn’t it amazing? This is thousands of years of experience from our predecessors! Western medicines are all chemical drugs.

It is undeniable that they will have some side effects. As the saying

“

medicines are three parts poisonous

”

Besides, people are not mice. The mice did not have any problems, but there is no guarantee that people will have no problems after taking or using them. Traditional Chinese medicine is bark and grass roots. It can be used as medicine. Pay attention to authentic medicines and advocate nature.

Rather than synthetic chemicals. Although some Chinese medicines also contain toxins, there are detoxification ingredients in every Chinese medicine, so that these can be treated

Toxins are digested. In addition, the valuable experience gained by the ancients who tried it at the cost of their lives is enough to eliminate doubts.

Finally, let me talk about my opinion: Western medicine focuses on the focus of the disease. It is necessary to see where there is a problem, and then treat this place, regardless of what

causes the problem. Discuss the matter.

It is undeniable that Western medicine has a relatively obvious therapeutic effect on general lesions; but slightly

slightly more serious lesions are called Western medicine

"

Inflammation

"

What Western medicine cannot solve is called

"

Cancer

”

Either surgery to remove it,

or

just wait to be buried! Oh, by the way, now that the country does not allow burial, then just wait until you enter Gaoyan Cave! Don't believe in any examination, it's just for your examination fee. Many people feel uncomfortable, and only after spending a lot of money will the doctor tell you: There is no problem!

The money has already flowed into the hospital at this time, why don’t you come back!

My father was originally in good health, but because he was blackmailed by gangsters, he became sulky and his liver was a little stagnant. He was accidentally seriously injured, but my family insisted on sending him to the hospital for treatment. Passed away in half a month. I am definitely not vilifying Western medicine, because my wife is also a Western medicine doctor, but when my father was dying and had too much phlegm to breathe, no one in the hospital knew how to make atomized milk! My wife was so furious that the doctors from the hospital came to find a mist breast pumping device! I am still condemned by my conscience. If my family had not sent my father to the hospital, he might not have died so quickly!

It is a pity that I did not inherit my father’s career, and I still regret it very much. Under the influence of my ears and eyes, especially after witnessing many cases with my own eyes, I

I don’t like Western medicine from the bottom of my heart. In my eyes, Western medicine is just a tool used to attract wealth. If you don’t see it, which hospital The building

is not towering into the sky! This is all accumulated from the patients’ hard-earned money! I never believe in Western medicine, even though my wife is a Western medicine doctor.

Isn’t the experience of traditional Chinese medicine accumulated over thousands of years inferior to Western medicine, which has just emerged over a hundred years ago? It is true that the yin and yang luck theory of traditional Chinese medicine

has a certain superstitious color, but this does not affect the outstanding clinical achievements of traditional Chinese medicine, because traditional Chinese medicine comes from practice barefoot

A doctor, not a white coat in a laboratory who only looks at bacteria without asking about the common people!

My father is a self-taught Chinese medicine doctor, and there are many examples of treating living people from coffins, not to mention that the patients he receives are all from so-and-so Grade A hospitals

, and a certain hospital in Beijing. Patients from a certain hospital and other famous brand hospitals were sentenced to death by Western medicine!

My father has been practicing medicine for more than 40 years and has never made any mistakes. Before he died, he once told me that there were only three cases of patients he encountered in his life.

There is no way, because when taking the pulse, the pulse has already been extinguished, and there is really no way to save the day. He didn't believe in Western medicine all his life.

Even if he had a headache or brain fever, he would use Chinese medicine to treat it. In addition, he had an upright personality and refused to increase the price. Therefore, he lived in poverty all his life and left with a breeze.

High profits have led hospitals and doctors to pursue Western medicine