In Captain America 3, who is right and who is wrong between Iron Man and Captain America?

There is no right or wrong between Captain America and Iron Man on the "Registration Act" because their positions are different. Cap doesn't understand Iron Man, and Iron Man doesn't understand Cap.

Captain America: Captain America insists on "freedom" and "justice." If the Avengers take orders from the ZF, then the Avengers will become a weapon. The weapon in the hands of the ZF, "the bullet in the gun will not fire by itself, it depends entirely on the person holding it." If that person is righteous, that's fine. What if that person is evil? In Captain America 2, Captain America has already seen this kind of battle, including the Hydra undercover infiltration of S.H.I.E.L.D. He didn’t believe in the ZF, so he firmly opposed it and even left the alliance. Defending freedom is the bottom line of Captain America, but Iron Man doesn't know it (Captain America tried to explain, but after the intervention of the widowed sister and Rhodes, Iron Man couldn't listen at all).

Iron Man: Iron Man is not wrong in the direction, for the sake of "safety". But the specific things I did were wrong, and I was too naive. Because of the New York incident and the Ultron incident, especially Ultron, it was Tony who messed up, and he felt guilty. So I hope to pass this on to ZF and let ZF wipe its ass. However, Iron Man's approach was too cruel, and he even built a prison to hold superheroes who opposed registration. Of course, later Iron Man realized that he was wrong and rushed to meet the captain, which was the last scene of the movie. In fact, the only person who really stood behind Iron Man in the registered faction was Iron Man himself. Then he realized that he was wrong and rushed to Siberia to help Captain America.

Black Widow let Captain America and the Winter Soldier go at the airport. The two had a life-long friendship. She trusted Captain America and believed he was right. She later followed him into exile until he was reunited. Beginning with couplet 3.

War Machine Rhodes blatantly disobeyed Rose's orders in Avengers 3 and continued to follow the US team.

Spider-Man, he is still a child, such a dangerous thing, why did Iron Man take him with him? In the comics, Spider-Man also rebelled and followed Captain America. This aspect was not covered in the movie.

Vision: He ran away with the witch, hahaha, he was actually in love. They were attacked by a sneak attack at the beginning of Avengers 3, and Captain America rescued them. Vision understood that the captain was not lying, he would definitely appear when you need him. The Witch returns to the team, and Vision follows Captain America.

At this point in Avengers 3, it is actually Captain America who has reorganized the broken Avengers, but unfortunately there is no Iron Man. Because Iron Man and Juan Fu went to fight monsters. So look, the Superhero Registration Act is actually a big joke. The Avengers even threatened the government for a time.

Secondly, Captain America and Iron Man are on the issue of Ba Chi. I personally think that both sides can be understood.

Captain America: His other bottom line is "baji". For him, he will fight to the death with anyone who dares to touch "freedom" and "baji". Although it is full of gay feelings, it is true that the US team should not be biased... knowing that Tony is out of control, and they should not be biased. Baji was controlled by Hydra and became the Winter Soldier. He himself was actually right, because he had no thoughts at that time. But the Winter Soldier was stubborn, and Iron Man asked him, "Do you remember the people you killed?" The Winter Soldier actually said, "Remember everyone." This was a living fire. Even if the Winter Soldier said that he was controlled at the time and that he had no memory of it, Iron Man would not be so anxious. Regarding the things that Captain America concealed, the ending of Captain America 3 is the consequences if Captain America tells Iron Man the truth. It would be inappropriate for Captain America not to tell Iron Man as friends. For the sake of the overall situation, it is appropriate. Captain America didn't want to hurt Tony, he just destroyed the power source of the mecha.

Iron Man: It’s true that he went to the top. He wanted to avenge his father. It’s not difficult to understand. It would be the same for anyone else. Tony knew that Baji was the captain's gay friend, and the two of them had a life-long friendship. Captain America is actually very sad that his gay friend killed his old friend. Howard has a very good relationship with Cap. He personally makes costumes and shields for Cap. Furthermore, Howard admires this war hero very much and often mentions Cap in front of little Tony. Tony lost his parents, but Cap also lost his old friend. It's past time that his old friend died, and now Captain America is left with nothing but a sigh. In that case, if you give Ba Chi to Iron Man, Ba Chi will only die.

Iron Man wanted to use Ba Chi as a bargaining chip to deal with the ZF, but the captain did not trust the ZF at all. During Captain's final shield attack, Iron Man felt that he was going to die for a time, but Captain just destroyed the power source. At that moment, Tony sighed (shown in the movie) and asked for the shield very childishly. The captain also understood that the shield was made by Howard, so which one do you want, shield or Baji? The captain finally chose gay love and gave up the shield, and Iron Man sighed again. In Avengers 4, Iron Man returned the shield to the captain. The two had understood each other, so they were relieved. In fact, it is even more powerful in the comics. Iron Man indirectly killed Captain in the big event. I still remember the scene of Iron Man sitting in front of Captain's body. This part in the comics was impossible to film in the movie.

But actually, I support the American team. Not much to say about the first contradiction, defending freedom, is proven by facts. The second contradiction is very simple. The Winter Soldier is just a weapon, and the one who controls the weapon is Hydra. This is also the secondary reason why the captain protects Baji. Iron Man actually understood everything, he was just blinded by Zemo and hatred.