Is the bright moon in The Ming Dynasty too high for Sun Chengzong?

Yes It is said that Sun Chengzong is the only minister to save the world. This is mainly because the history of Ming written by the Qing people raised him and his disciple Yuan Chonghuan infinitely. (During the Anti-Japanese War, Japan also highly praised Wang Jingwei. If the Japanese win (the Qing Dynasty wins), Wang Zong may be the national hero of our nation. )

The author also talks about things with history books. . But let's see how Sun Chengzong did it.

1, bring down Wang Zaijin, and build Ningjin defense line (China version of Ma Qilang defense line).

I feel that the future role of Ningjin defense line is very limited, and the materials that the empire already lacks are constantly consumed here. Despite this line of defense, Huang taiji has repeatedly entered the customs. Coupled with the siege of Daling River and Jinzhou, it was repeatedly assisted by the encirclement of Manchu, which consumed the imperial army in the land outside the customs. This is the battle of Jinsong. The imperial mobile forces were swept away, leaving only Ningyuan in Ningjin defense and being forced to give up. . The Ningjin defense line was the machimura defense line from the beginning. In the end, it exists in name only.

2. Ning Guan Tieqi (a git who only eats military pay)

Sun Chengzong single-handedly built the Ning Guan fighters. It costs 23 million taels of silver every year (accounting for more than half of fiscal revenue). Do you think about the salaries of other soldiers on the Nine Sides? It's strange to defend slaves and invade! ), but this unit is completely a force that can only defend the city (how to recover Liaoning by guarding the city). The only active attack was Yaozhou fiasco (I don't know if I can search for "Ma Shilong"). . Tens of thousands of troops were defeated by Jiannu and Lu Niu 100 soldiers! This army had no fighting capacity in the early stage. . Later, I gained practical experience by suppressing the peasant uprising!

Sun Chengzong gave me the feeling that the only record was Yuan Chonghuan's cleaning up after he went to prison. . Judging from what he has done, I think his view of the country is wrong. Daming is poor. Too poor to help people in arid areas. . A large amount of grain and a large amount of silver were continuously sent to the Ningjin defense line. .

Some people say I'm talking nonsense. Excerpt from Baidu Encyclopedia (about Yaozhou fiasco) (excerpted from Ming History: Biography 158);

At that time, Chengzong had more than 100,000 soldiers and horses, used hundreds of people to allocate schools, and spent millions of dollars on military reserves. Those who want to inherit the Sect will lead the world, and those who don't will be great. But the world dragon looks great, but it is really timid, so it is forbidden for inheritors to beat the world dragon more to shake it. Chengzong pleaded with the court and said, "People say they are greedy for sex, but I dare to protect a hundred mouths." The emperor inherited the reason and didn't ask.

Lu Zhijia, deputy general of Ningyuan China Association, was the main general, and Li Chengxian, a soldier in the war, led seven thousand soldiers to attack Yaozhou in four battalions (Chepao Camp I, Tieqi Camp I and Shui Ying Camp II). It took Guan Ningjun three days to build the pontoon bridge because they were all recruits who had never been to the battlefield. At that time, in Yaozhou, there was a Lu Niu with no armor, no women and children in Houjin, and the soldiers with Lu Niu had 100. After learning the news of the Ming army, Tunlu and the soldiers ambushed on both sides of the road overnight. At night, the Ming army let the women and children in the city raise their torches and play drums. After the Ming army was exhausted, Tunlu suddenly fought on both sides. Because the enemy's situation was unknown in the dark, the army collapsed in panic and fled first. After this war, 400 men, including Jin Jian and others, captured 700 armored men and 600 war horses, which is called "the defeat of Liuhe" in history. After the war, Ma Shilong was disintegrated and resigned.

Please pay attention to what is marked in bold. During Sun Chengzong's overall planning of the Liao army, the Liao army spent millions of years. But they can only defend Houjin, and those who dare not attack only have 6w mouths. The only active attack (Liuhe fiasco) was that 7000 Liao troops were defeated by 100 nomads!

This is the army? You told me this is "the strongest army in the world"? In this way, the commander-in-chief of the army told me that he was the "savior". Is it the "salvation minister" of the Qing Dynasty? Why do we have to advocate such a "minister of salvation" without thinking about the reasons (Ming history was written by the Qing Dynasty)?

About the loss of Ming Dynasty in Daling River area (from Baidu Encyclopedia)

Participate in various forces

There were about 50,000 people in the late Jin Dynasty and about13,800 people in the Ming Dynasty.

About 54,000 people were reinforced before and after the Ming Dynasty reinforcements.

And Kim won.

That is to say, for Jin Song defense. 60,000 Ming troops went thousands of miles to die outside the customs (the Battle of Daling River), and then another wave130,000 Ming troops went to the Battle of Jinsong (the Battle of Jinsong). Why do you want to die? Because Daling River and Jinzhou are isolated cities, they can be besieged to death! If we don't save it, the 20 thousand Ming army guarding the city will starve to death! The field ability of the Ming army was actually very bad at that time! ! Forced to travel thousands of miles to attack the strong with the weak!

And if you keep Shanhaiguan (Wang Zaijin's idea). Because you can rely on shipping, the other party can't be completely besieged! Advocating active defense is "minister of national salvation" Sun Chengzong.

Many people say that Sun Chengzong's failure to win the rights led to the defeat of the Ming army. . In fact, Sun Chengzong won more defeats when he was in power. Sun Chengzong directed the humiliating loss of Liuhe. The battle of Daling River, which was besieged and rescued fifty thousand soldiers, was also commanded by Sun Chengzong. During this period, there was a joke that 6000 Ning Guan soldiers (indeed the strongest army in the world) were killed by 200 Qing troops.

In the fourth year of Chongzhen (163 1), Sun Chengzong toured Songshan and Jinzhou, and wrote a letter to discuss internal and external affairs, which was adopted. Sun Chengzong was added as a teacher, and Shang Shu was also led to close the road. His descendants inherited Shangbao and gave python coins. [39]?

In July of the same year, because Gaudi had withdrawn the Ningjin defense line, Youtun, Daling River and other cities were destroyed, and Sun Chengzong sent people to rebuild, but soon the Qing army suddenly came to besiege. Sun Chengzong rushed to Jinzhou and sent Wu Xiang and Wei Song to the rescue, but Qiu Hejia, the governor of Liaodong, changed the departure date many times, which led to Wu Xiang and Wei Song being defeated by the Qing army in Changshan. In October, Zu Dashou surrendered, and the Daling River was destroyed as soon as it was repaired. The DPRK minister then accused Sun Chengzong of failing to repair the old city and humiliating the country. Sun Chengzong resigned due to illness. Then Sun Chengzong returned to his hometown in Gaoyangcheng. [40]

Several wars before entering the customs in Ming and Qing Dynasties. . There is a so-called second victory. However, Daming's loss data is zero! The loss of the Qing army is nothing! Daming's beheading number is also zero (in ancient times, beheading was used to discuss military merits)! Just held Ningyuan and other cities ~ ~ What, is this a triumph? Mongolia attacked Daikin, plundering all the way, avoiding the city when it was heavily guarded, and breaking the city when it was weak ~ ~ ~ yeah. . It seems that Mongolia has been "triumphed" by Daikin many times.

In fact, the same is true of Ningjin victory or Ningyuan victory. Only two or three cities were held, and many of them were taken away by the Qing Dynasty. Even the Daling River was demolished several times in the second victory!

After the "Battle of Ningjin", General Yuan also specifically appealed for Mao Shuai: "Who knows that Mao attacked Liaoyang and rotated his troops accordingly, so that it was not Mao Shuai who attacked the enemy, and Jinning was attacked again! Although Mao Shuai was defeated by a soldier, he restrained himself for several years. This is the strongest! " ("Three Dynasties Liao Shi Lu" Volume 18