If there were no foreigners' invasion, would the Qing Dynasty last forever?

Personally, if there were no foreigners' invasion, the Qing Dynasty would not last long. The following specific analysis:

The Qing Dynasty was a prosperous dynasty. Although there were many criticisms of the Qing Dynasty, in the history of China, as a centralized regime, there was no resistance for 300 years.

During the Qianlong period, the small-scale peasant economy reached its peak. At the same time, the shadow of its decline also followed. There were many uprisings in China at that time. Facing the prosperous times, there is a faint decadent atmosphere.

For China people, the only thing people want to believe is that the invasion of the West destroyed the Qing Dynasty. But in fact, if we straighten out our historical thinking, we will find that even without western intervention, the Qing Dynasty will not last long.

Many people think that the exterminators are westerners, that is, white people. Because of the crazy intervention of white people, the Qing Dynasty collapsed. If the white people did not invade, the Qing Dynasty would still exist even today, if not in its heyday.

No? Foreigners? How many years can you live after the Qing Dynasty invaded China? The answer is chilling.

How many years can the Qing Dynasty live without foreign invasion?

When we talk about the decline of the most prosperous dynasty, one word comes to mind? Corruption. No dynasty can completely put an end to corruption, no matter how strict the law is, because you are not facing a corrupt official, but the overall humanity behind them.

Human greed is endless. If you want more, as long as it is profitable, you will take risks. Hotan was the biggest corrupt criminal in Qianlong period, but he was not executed by Qianlong, but was left to Jiaqing emperor to be executed. First of all, this is the subtle relationship between officialdom. If the minister can hold the handle in the hands of the emperor, then being a slave and a dog is his best choice. The second is to give it to Emperor Jiaqing, which is also a bargaining chip to enhance his prestige.

This is a big chip. This is the whole Qing Dynasty. Because Emperor Qianlong condoned corruption, court officials took greed as the fashion. They are like a big moth, devouring half of the Qing Dynasty.

Was the Qing Dynasty just destroyed by corruption? For the Qing dynasty, there were more problems. Corruption is just one of them.

The ruler of the Qing Dynasty was the Jurchen nationality. They are not only hostile to the Han people, but also wary. Even if he finally appointed an official of the Han Dynasty, he could not let go of his inner estrangement. Similarly, he could not let go of the gap with the Qing Dynasty. If they are wary of each other, it is difficult to cooperate. If the court can't treat them equally, then rebellion will happen. Joining political parties and engaging in private activities has become a common practice, and civil uprisings are also proliferating.

No? Foreigners? How many years can you live after the Qing Dynasty invaded China? The answer is chilling.

Religion is a problem that harms the foundation of a dynasty, because those who win the hearts of the people win the world, and religion often wins the hearts of the people. When the imperial court aroused more and more antipathy among the people, religion also attracted more and more people's expectations. Emperor Jiajing was once sent into the palace by Heaven. That sounds shocking. At that time, it was a shame. This is a sign of the emperor's incompetence.

In such a chaotic world, how long can the Qing Dynasty last? No more than 200 years.

First, in order to suppress the Bailian uprising, the Qing Dynasty spent a whole 16 province to suppress it for 9 years! 200 million taels of silver are spent like water. For the Qing dynasty, neither the army of 16 province nor the treasury of 200 million taels of silver was a small sum. As the two pillars supporting the Qing Dynasty building were hollowed out by half, the building must be about to collapse.

In fact, the rebels of Bailian Sect are very backward. It has no decent weapons, no formal institutions and no training. Compared with the White Lotus Sect, the Qing army was almost more popular than the White Lotus Sect. I haven't seen you for a long time. Soldiers are weak in legs and feet. Riding a horse is difficult, let alone fighting. Those masters can't even carry weapons. As soon as they started fighting, they immediately thought that their fighting capacity was very weak. The people were disappointed with the Qing army and made up many jokes.

Second, the economic problems in the late Qing Dynasty. In the late Qing Dynasty, the national treasury was vacant and officials were plundered. Finally, the pressure of the empty warehouse was lifted. Besides, the bureaucracy of the Qing Dynasty was bloated, and many officials were in the upper position, with only one purpose? Make money. Those rice bowls try their best to make money from government officials. They set up all kinds of exorbitant taxes and miscellaneous fees, and the people were in dire straits. People can't even eat a mouthful of ordinary food. Under pressure, people will only resist.

Jiangnan region is economically developed, and businessmen have money, but they have no power and there is no way to expand their capital. They can only worry about money. If the economy can't run, the bloated state machine will work hard.

Rich people don't have enough to eat, people often starve to death, land annexation and expansion become more and more serious, and wealth will soon gather in the hands of a few people.

The Qing dynasty spent countless money to build the Yuanmingyuan, and the national treasury was always empty.

The resentment of the people is the biggest reason for the collapse of the dynasty. So the reform began in the Qing Dynasty. The Westernization Movement tried to reverse the trend to some extent, but for various reasons, it finally gave up halfway. Government agencies are officials who want to live on their own wages. There are no competent officials, and there are no practical officials. When they encounter problems, they pass the buck to each other, and the future of the Qing Dynasty is almost hopeless.

An important problem in Manchu society is inner inferiority. They occupied the land of the Han people, but in fact they have no confidence in conquering the Han people, which is also a sense of inferiority in culture and ideology. This sense of inferiority will lead to high-handed policies, which will lead to resistance. Under the vicious circle, the power of the Qing dynasty was no longer strong and could not withstand repeated consumption.

Without foreigners, how many years can Qing resist? 200 years at most. Foreigners only cause problems, not the root cause. It's like a building with moths on its pillars. A gust of wind blew and the building collapsed.