Six people were killed in the fire in Chongqing, and the family members' claim for property fire protection of RMB 6,543,800+0,630 was rejected. What do you think of this?

Six people were killed in the fire in Chongqing, and the family members' claim for property fire protection of RMB 6,543,800+0,630 was rejected. What do you think of this? Let's discuss this problem below, hoping that these contents can help friends in need.

More than two years ago, a family in a resettlement community in Ma 'an Street, Fuling District, Chongqing suddenly caught fire. Six people in the room died in the fire. People involved in the rescue said that there was no water in the fire hydrant of the building where the house was located when the accident happened.

Liu Ming (pen name), a relative of the deceased, felt that the property management company failed to fulfill its management responsibilities, resulting in no water supply to the fire hydrant during emergency rescue, which delayed the best treatment opportunity. The people's court said that they filed a lawsuit with the property management company and the fire safety unit, and agreed that the other party's loss compensation and spiritual comfort amounted to 6.5438+0.63 million yuan.

Although more than three years have passed since the fire broke out, Liu Ming, 54, still recalls the scene with great sadness. Because of this fire, only he and his mother with cancer were left in a happy family of eight.

At the time of the accident, except for his 80-year-old mother who was hospitalized due to illness, he was working in Guizhou, and his father, wife, children, daughter-in-law, grandson and granddaughter were all at home. A family of six failed to escape from the fire.

Later, Liu Ming learned from relatives and friends and a number of community residents who participated in the rescue that after the fire broke out, several next-door neighbors immediately rushed to the scene to prepare for the rescue in advance. However, the neighbors next door found that there was no water in the fire hydrant on the first floor of the building and the building where their home belonged, so it was impossible to carry out reasonable rescue. On the way to the community, the fire truck was blocked by a small truck at the gate of the community, which delayed the time; When the firemen turned on the fire-fighting equipment in the community, the fire hydrant ran out of water at first, and it took a while to get out of the water.

65438+1October 12, Liu Ming's cousin Zeng, who had arrived at the scene during the fire, told the reporter that at 7: 20 in the morning, he rushed to the downstairs of Liu Ming's building and saw Liu Ming's children shouting at the window: "Help! Help! " When he ran to the 1 1 building, he saw that the firemen had arrived. The hose brought by the firemen from 1 building is ready, but there is no water in the hose. After waiting for a few minutes, the hose gradually emerged.

Mr. Lin lives on the fifth floor of the building to which Liu Ming belongs. He heard someone shouting and went downstairs to check the situation. He found that the 12 building was on fire. He immediately ran to the 12 floor to help put out the fire in advance. At this time, there were five or six next-door neighbors present, and everyone was ready to help in advance. Mr. Lin opened a fire hydrant on the stairs of 12 floor, ready to put out the fire in advance, but found that there was no water in the fire hydrant. He ran to the fire hydrant in 1 1 building and found that there was no water after opening it.

Just when Mr. Lin and other next-door neighbors were at a loss at the scene, firefighters rushed to the scene and took a hose from the 1 floor to the 12 floor. Mr. Lin demonstrated that there was no water in the hose at first, and it took several minutes to get out.

On February 12, 2020, the fire safety agency made a fire accident confirmation, and assessed that the fire safety accident was caused by the failure of the automatic mahjong machine circuit in Liu Mingjia's living room.

Liu Ming thinks that although the fire was caused by mahjong machine's fault, as a property service company in the community, it is its basic contractual obligation to keep the fire hydrants in the community in a state of water storage at all times. The depressed personal behavior of the property company has caused the expansion of its own damage. However, after the fire safety unit arrived, the fire truck could not work normally, causing great losses.

Subsequently, Liu Ming held talks with property management companies and fire safety units, expecting to get a view on the above issues, but he was eagerly awaiting.

In April 2020, Liu Ming and his relatives filed a lawsuit in the Fuling District People's Court in Chongqing, demanding that the property management company Chongqing Yashi Property Service Co., Ltd. and Fuling District Fire Rescue Detachment compensate themselves for damages, spiritual comfort and litigation costs totaling 6,543,800 yuan.

20211On 30 February, the People's Court of Fuling District, Chongqing issued a verdict on this case, rejecting Liu Ming and his relatives' petition. According to the ruling, the people's court found that someone rushed to 12 building to use the water from the fire fighting equipment in the building for rescue, but could not take out the water for rescue. According to the evidence provided by the appellant, there is no water in the fire hydrant on the second floor of the residential community/KLOC-0. Because the personnel involved in the rescue are not fire professionals, the appellant's witness testimony can't prove that the defendant failed to perform the responsibility of maintaining the fire-fighting equipment in the residential area as agreed in the contract, so it doesn't apply to the appellant's opinion.