An old man walking in Chongqing was frightened by the sound of car horns, and his family demanded compensation of 340 thousand. What did the court decide?

According to the actual situation and the physical condition of the elderly, the court finally ruled that the cause of death of the elderly and the sound of the car horn constituted a causal relationship, so the driver was responsible, including the insurance company and the driver's unit, and compensated 6.5438+0.5 million yuan.

Of the 654.38+0.5 million yuan, the driver bears 654.38+0.5% of the money within the insurance company's responsibility, and the unit where he works bears 5%, which is why this matter ends here.

Obviously, this is just a simple whistle. Why did it cause such a big tragedy?

It happened in Lichuan, Hubei. An old man was walking in the morning when a garbage truck honked its horn. Because the decibel was particularly high, the old man was suddenly frightened by the sound and directly hit the ground with his head. Although I dialed 120 in time, it didn't help, and the old man finally left.

His family believed that it was the whistle that made the old man suddenly fall to the ground, and the garbage truck driver should be responsible, so the two sides went to court.

Court: It is illegal to whistle in the no-singing area.

After investigation, the place where the old man had an accident belongs to the no-honking area, which means that the place itself is not allowed to honk. Once honking is illegal, it is illegal for the driver to honk in this area in disregard of the law.

Moreover, after blowing the horn, it has caused such serious consequences.

That's not enough. According to witnesses, the decibel of the car horn was very high at that time. It was because of this whistle that the old man fell to the ground.

This incident also tells us that in life, a small gesture that may be casual is illegal, and its consequences are immeasurable. Take this case as an example. Who would have thought that a whistle could make the old man fall to the ground? For the old man's family, the news was sudden.

Of course, the court not only considered the whistling factor, but also considered the physical condition of the elderly, so it did not allow the family to pay 340,000 yuan, but 1.5 million yuan. It can be seen that it is fair before the law.

An action can save lives or hurt people.

I believe that in the eyes of many people, it is incredible. It is estimated that even TV dramas dare not act like this, but life will always teach us a lesson.

For drivers, whistling is to remind passers-by to pay attention to safety, but whistling in the no-whistling area seems to have changed its nature and become an illegal act with serious consequences. Therefore, in daily life, we should strictly abide by traffic laws and regulations, be familiar with all kinds of road signs, and don't cause great disasters because of our negligence.

For passers-by, it is also necessary to abide by relevant laws and regulations, and it is forbidden to run red lights, cross railings and fight on the road. I think this requires the concerted efforts of Qi Xin to reduce this situation.

Tell me my opinion.

In this case, the driver made a mistake first. Without that loud whistle, the old man might not fall to the ground, and there would be no subsequent tragedy. On the other hand, as the court said, the elderly are weak. If whistling is the cause, then physical factors are also part of the reason.

Therefore, I think the court's decision is reasonable and legal, and there is no favoritism to any party. I also hope that each of us can learn a lesson from this incident, and we must figure out where we can whistle and where we can't.

Write to the end

There is no doubt that things are painful, I think they are both, but fortunately, things have finally come to an end, so the old man can rest in peace.

What is left to us is more thinking, and some details that are easily overlooked may often cause tragedy. Come on, what do you think of this matter? Welcome to leave a message