Why is Liangshan hero Huang Xin's nickname "Zhen Sanshan" the most criticized?

Huang Xin is one of the one hundred and eighty generals in "Water Margin". Every Liangshan hero has a nickname. So what is Huang Xin's nickname? Why is his nickname the most popular among modern writers? The one you complained about? Huang Xin was nicknamed "Zhen Sanshan". It was originally the military supervisor under the command of Murong Yanda, the prefect of Qingzhou. There were three evil mountains within its jurisdiction, all of which were haunted by bandits and bandits. Huang Xin was proud of his good martial arts skills, so he boasted about the three bandit mountains in Haikou that would shock Qingzhou. Therefore, he was called "Zhen Sanshan". This nickname is the most complained by modern literary scholars after Li Zhong's "Tiger Fighter". Let’s talk about the three major gangs. The first is Qingfeng Mountain, the second is Erlong Mountain, and the third is Peach Blossom Mountain. Among them, the three masters of Erlong Mountain are Lu Zhishen, Yang Zhi, and Wu Song. Their strength is quite strong. Not to mention a small Huang Xin, even with the addition of Thunderbolt and Qin Ming, they cannot suppress the three super heroes. . When modern scholars comment on the character of Huang Xin, one of the most common points is that they think his nickname "Zhen Sanshan" is a big joke. First, Huang Xin is not the opponent of the three masters of Erlong Mountain at all. He was a little guy who was defeated after dozens of rounds of fighting. Compared with Huang Xin's ability and the nickname of "Three Mountains", it was really an exaggeration. Secondly, he was later persuaded by his master Qin Ming to surrender to Songjiang and later served with the Sanshan bandits in Songjiang. Therefore, this nickname naturally caused a lot of embarrassment in Liangshan. But after Huang Xin invested in Liangshan, why did the author still retain the nickname Huang Xin? The editor believes that there is a reason why the author retained the nickname Zhensanshan. Huang Xin was originally the city defense commander. His duty was to ensure the safety of Qingzhou Prefecture, not to go out to encircle and suppress bandits like guerrillas. In other words, there is still a certain difference in status between him and the robber. "Water Margin" Huang Xin, the evil star in Sanshan Town, what are Huang Xin's character traits? Huang Xin is a man who is both wise and courageous, bold and cautious. In Water Margin, Huang Xin designed to capture Hua Rong alive, which was his biggest highlight in Water Margin. From the section of capturing Hua Rong, he held a "Hongmen Banquet" to entertain Hua Rong and treated Hua Rong with courtesy. In terms of force alone, although Huang Xin was Qin Ming's apprentice, he would still be defeated if he fought against Hua Rong forty or fifty. Huang Xin knew that he could not defeat Hua Rong, so he hosted a banquet for Hua Rong, causing Hua Rong to relax his vigilance. The second thing is that he has a plan in mind and finalizes his strategy. The original book on the strategy makes it very clear that a banquet was arranged in the public hall of the camp, but thirty or fifty people were ambushed outside the camp tent. He personally went to Hua Rong's house to invite Hua Rong to the banquet. It was because Magistrate Murong knew about the discord between civil and military officials and sent him to buy wine and admonish him. When Hua Rong comes to the banquet, he takes the opportunity to capture Hua Rong alive by throwing a cup. From the above two points, Huang Xin is worthy of being a wise general.