What is there about Han Han’s scolding war?

As soon as the scolding war started, many literati and critics joined the battle circle, which was very lively.

For these two articles, the full text can be found on Baidu in one click, so I won’t repeat them here. Summarize some of these arguments. Among them, Bai Ye said that those "post-80s" writers are: "'post-80s' refers to student writers born between 1980 and 1989", "entered the market, but not the literary world", "have not gone through the step-by-step process" literary exercises, so that the literary world knows little or nothing about them,” and so on.

Han Han responded: "Every outstanding author is a person with a distinctive personality, how can they be classified. People born in the same year are of the same type, selling piglets. Could it be that people born between 1966 and 1976 Are they all called "Cultural Revolution types"? If the Cultural Revolution failed, are those people called "Cultural Revolution scum"? It is obviously unscientific to divide people into eras. , How do you want to enter the literary world? It sounds like a child playing house. It seems that when Mr. Bai nods, you have entered the literary world." "The literary world is nothing, the Contradictory Literature Award is nothing, pure literature. Journals are nothing, that is, one hundred people masturbate and one hundred people watch. I have been doing it in full swing, and the positions have changed a lot. You are still saying, "Come, watch how I masturbate, learn from it." At this point, if the frequency of your movements is the same as mine, you will be considered to have entered the realm of obscenity." And so on. However, Han Han's article is very exciting, with clear views and vivid sentences, and is worth collecting.

Bai Ye's counterattack focused on the fact that Han Han should not use foul language. Han Han retorted: "You talk to me about morality, I will talk to you about morality, and question his professional ethics in matters such as 'Planning Bella' and 'Praising Cai Xiaofei'." After that, Bai Ye closed his blog. (Reported by "Nandu")

Other comments in the battle circle include Chen Cun, Xie Xizhang, Wang Xiaoyu, Li Jingze, Lu Tianming, etc. in the white circle. The Korean circle (actually the Korean circle was not initiated by Han Han, but some critics joined the circle themselves) includes Gu Qingsheng, Wu Liang, He Liwei, Han Dong, etc.

Xie Xizhang said, "If I were Han Han's parent, I would definitely slap him with a loud mouth. He is raised but not taught." Wang Xiaoyu said: "How can he be like the little red soldier during the Cultural Revolution? This This is a very bad practice! Bai Ye just criticized your writing of Han Han, but you just collected the evidence and listed it out one by one." Li Jingze said: "Guo Jingming, Zhang Yueran, and Han Han are not literary phenomena, they can only be counted. As a cultural phenomenon, they have not injected anything into the literary world. To be honest, the writing is not good." Lu Tianming said: "This child is spoiled! It's no wonder that Han Han is only 17 or 8 years old and has not read many books. "I know what happens in school." Chen Cun said: "Literature is becoming more and more entertainment-oriented, and it is getting further and further away from academics." "Bai Ye's Identity" said: "The dispute between Han Han and Bai Ye has caused the public to think about another aspect, that is, faculty and public scholars like Bai Ye who have grasped important critical resources have long been engaged in the planning and promotion of booksellers. Is this a disastrous academic corruption? Bai Ye uses the public resources in his hands to spare no effort to promote the books he plans. Does this obvious unfair competition bring consequences to most writers? Is it one of the consequences of the extreme depression in Chinese literature? "Wu Liang said: "It doesn't matter whether Bai Ye puts on a show or not. The key is that he basically doesn't understand literature."