Where is Mudanjiang Dong Shi Clinic? Any skills?

An encrypted prescription almost killed Li, who was only 30 years old. Li Sinian's road to safeguarding rights has recently achieved results.

On June 5438+1October 65438+February, 2006, the Intermediate People's Court of Mudanjiang City, Heilongjiang Province made a final judgment, and decided that Mudanjiang Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine, which issued the password, compensated Li Yin for the personal injury caused by taking the password prescription drug for more than 6,543,800 yuan.

Damn password prescription

In July 2002, Li, a citizen of Mudanjiang, went to Dongshi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine for medical treatment because of tonsillitis, pelvic inflammatory disease and upper respiratory tract infection. After seeing a doctor, Dr. Dong diagnosed Li as a drug-induced reaction, fever and rash.

Liu Xiuqin, the mother who accompanied Li to see a doctor at that time, said in an interview with reporters, "Dr. Dong only prescribed a pair of Chinese medicine and ordered him to prescribe it once a day."

To Li and his family's surprise, all the prescriptions prescribed by Dr. Dong are written in Arabic numerals, and there are no names of medicinal materials. It is impossible to know what the ingredients of traditional Chinese medicine are. And the prescription was taken back when I took it away, and there was no receipt for the purchase. Only after asking did I know that the hospital prescribed a password, which was done to prevent others from stealing secrets.

After taking it for a week according to the doctor's advice, Li's symptoms did not improve, but he developed liver injury symptoms such as jaundice, collapse and fatigue. Dr. Dong insisted that Li continue to take the Chinese medicine he prescribed. After that, Li's condition became more and more serious, with severe jaundice, nausea and constipation, until symptoms such as listlessness, hearing loss and convulsions appeared.

On August 29th, 2002, Li Yin was sent to the First Affiliated Hospital of Harbin Medical University with trembling arms and hearing loss. After admission, experts immediately diagnosed as "severe hepatitis due to drug toxicity". After three days of emergency rescue, Li's condition has not improved significantly.

On September 2, 2002, the First Hospital of Harbin Medical University sent a critical notice to Li's family. The diagnosis conclusion is that Li's persistent fever is caused by various inflammations caused by fungal infection, which is not severe; Its severe hepatitis is caused by drug poisoning. Because of its deep poisoning and serious condition, it is necessary to implement symptomatic treatment such as liver protection, yellowing and antibacterial immediately.

After 2 1 day of intense rescue, Li finally escaped from death.

265438+20021October 265438+June 5, 2002, he was forced to leave the hospital because he could not afford huge medical expenses. Li was still unable to take care of himself when he left the hospital.

Now, Li's life is taken care of by her 67-year-old mother Liu Xiuqin. Liu Xiuqin said that Li's constitution is too weak. She has to rest three times when she goes up to the third floor with five pounds of eggs. She often has hallucinations and always says that someone is talking to her. Sometimes the liquefied gas stove is turned on aimlessly, burning out seven rice cookers and kettles. Symptoms such as headache, drowsiness, insomnia, irregular menstruation and sudden palpitation often occur.

Bring a lawsuit for compensation

"My daughter didn't have liver disease before going to Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine for medical treatment. How did she get drug-induced severe hepatitis after seeing a doctor? " Li's family believes that this is caused by taking Chinese medicine prescribed by Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine. This is a serious medical accident.

The Li family applied to Mudanjiang City and Heilongjiang Medical Association for technical appraisal of medical malpractice. On June/KOOC-0/65438+/KOOC-0/October/KOOC-0/day, 2003, Heilongjiang Medical Association made an appraisal conclusion, which constituted a third-class medical accident. Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine is responsible for 50% of the accident.

The Heilongjiang Medical Association identified the illegal facts of Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine in this accident as follows: insufficient diagnosis basis and no relevant auxiliary examination; The writing of medical documents is not standardized; Use code prescription; Failing to grasp the change of illness in time and take corresponding measures.

Li and his family refused to accept the above appraisal conclusion. They think, "My daughter is not at fault, and Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine should take full responsibility." So I applied to the Chinese Medical Association for re-appraisal. The Chinese Medical Association refused to accept the case on the grounds that it was not a difficult and complicated case.

Later, Li's family took Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine to court. Claims for hospitalization expenses, transportation expenses and other expenses totaled more than 330,000 yuan.

On July 6, 2005, the People's Court of Xi 'an District, Mudanjiang City ruled that Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine was at fault in this medical accident and assumed certain liability for compensation. 50% of Li's reasonable expenses of 320,450 yuan, namely160,200 yuan.

Awkward password prescription

Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine refused to accept the judgment, and appealed on the grounds that Li was a special physique. It is required to appraise the specific physique of Li Fan's representative works, and make a new judgment according to the appraisal conclusion.

Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine asked the court to preside over the allergy test of the drugs used by Li one by one according to the prescription. If Li has an allergic reaction to one or more of them, it means that Li has a specific constitution.

In this regard, Li's family thought: "You have prescribed a password prescription. Who knows if the drug you provided for testing has been replaced. "

"According to the law, according to the principle of inversion of burden of proof, the medical party bears the burden of proof. Then, how can we prove that the drug provided by Dongshi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine for testing is the same drug that was originally used for Li? " The lawyer said that Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine could not provide evidence, so it should bear the responsibility.

On June 5438+065438+1October 18, 2005, Mudanjiang Intermediate People's Court accepted the case and sent a letter to the Provincial Medical Association, asking the Provincial Medical Association to give a clear written reply to the question of Li's physical abnormality raised by Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine.

Three days later, the Provincial Medical Association replied to Mudanjiang Intermediate People's Court: "Li's definite diagnosis was' severe hepatitis caused by drug poisoning', in other words,' severe hepatitis was caused by drug poisoning, and the experts in the appraisal team confirmed that severe hepatitis was related to the drugs used by Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine, not caused by specific physique. "

On June 65438+1October 65438+February 2006, Mudanjiang Intermediate People's Court made a judgment: the appeal was rejected and the original judgment was upheld.

Another Chinese medicine clinic

Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine, is it a Chinese medicine clinic? When the reporter went to Mudanjiang to interview the case, he went to Dongshi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine as a patient. There is a notice posted at the entrance of the institute, which reads: According to recent rumors and discussions about the business situation of the institute, we solemnly declare the following. Dong Shi Institute of Traditional Chinese Medicine and the attending physician have legal qualifications; This firm has been operating in the local area for 80 years, and no one dares to close or ban this firm, only this firm has to strike on its own; Our firm does not violate the law and discipline, and whoever interferes with my medical practice will be ruined; According to relevant laws, those who interfere with the normal work of professional doctors, slander or insult doctors will be punished by law. ...

After reading this statement, the reporter pushed the door and went in. The reporter said hypocritically, "Wrong door. Are you from the institute? " A staff member quickly replied: "It is a clinic."

The reporter said to let Dr. Dong see insomnia. A doctor said that Dr. Dong was not in the clinic. After taking the reporter's pulse, he prescribed a prescription for the reporter. The Chinese medicine in the prescription is Arabic numeral code. The reporter asked: "What medicine is this?" The other party didn't give a positive answer, just said, "Go get it!"

After paying the medicine at the medicine collection office, the prescription was returned, and the other party did not give any evidence to the reporter. So the reporter asked: "Without receipt and prescription, what should I do next time?"

So the other party gave the reporter a piece of paper and asked him to write his name on it, saying, "Next time you come to prescribe medicine and get this list, we will know what medicine you used, and the computer has a record."

Relevant experts believe that writing a password prescription may be harmful to both patients and hospitals, because the ingredients of the drug are not specified in the prescription. If there are mistakes, you can't tell the truth, which is not good for patients and doctors.

Come on, my friend, don't be hard on yourself.