What do you think of the Chinese remake of the Korean drama "Reply 1988"?

There is no doubt that "Reply 1988" will be ruined.

"Reply 1988" is the memory of many of us. It is not about worshiping foreigners, but the intention of loving this show. Every character, every line, every day, every story... I believe everyone Everyone cried.

"Reply 1988" is full of laughter and tears. Every character plays his true character, and each person's personality is deeply painted in the hearts of the audience. Deok-sun should be Lee Hye-ri, Jung-hwan should be Ryu Jun-yeol, Ah-taek should be Park Bo-gum... Every character actor in it is irreplaceable, and they cannot be replaced by some popular little actor in a remake. (Or maybe people don’t mind the effect of the remake at all, as long as the traffic is there). I thought that Deshan’s optimistic and lively character would be played as a fool, Aze, the naturally stupid Go genius, would be played as an idiot, and the wild dog group would be played as a market lady...

This is An impeccable crew, from the overall situation to the details, I couldn't praise them enough for three days and three nights... As a newcomer in the entertainment industry, Ryu Junyeol does not have his own agency agent, so he drags his luggage to the interview alone. I was also super surprised that such a novice with no background actually got the lead role of Gou Huan. Why are you making remakes?

Take the domestic "Our Adolescence" as an example.

I don’t comment on the acting skills. Friends who have watched the two dramas should be able to distinguish between what is a natural acting life and what is a hysterical and self-righteous acting life. I want to talk about the logic of the two dramas.

The protagonists of "Reply" are five families. The main line is the small conflicts and stories that occur in each of these five families. A hidden line is the emotional entanglement of the children in the five families. In the first episode, almost all the protagonists appear. Although the emotional story between them is not narrated in the first episode, it will not make people feel abrupt. As for the drama "Our Adolescence", the four men and one woman in "Please" were replaced by four women. If they want to portray their emotional lines in the future, new characters must be introduced, and the resulting dramatic conflicts should be It won't be as big as in "Please" because the emotional drama in "Please" takes place between friends, but this possibility does not exist in the drama "I".

Each episode of "Reply" is an independent story with a beginning, end and climax. "I" usually cannot tell a complete story in one episode. This is of course related to the length and capacity of the episode, but the price is that the entire episode will be stretched and lengthy. The first episode of "Reply" tells the story of the conflict between the Deshan family. As the second daughter, Deshan had to take care of her eldest sister Paula and her third brother Yuhui. It was not until her birthday that she couldn't bear it anymore and a big explosion occurred. Then Deshan's explosion Is the real reason because I want to celebrate her birthday with my eldest sister? The real reason is that Deshan, who was originally going to be the Miss Olympic medalist, lost this opportunity because Madagascar withdrew from the competition. In this way, the progression of the plot appears natural and layered. But looking back at the conflict between one of the heroines in "I" (forgive me, I can't remember their names) and her mother, it seems too blunt.

The heroine tied for tenth in the class and went to her mother to ask for the travel shoes she had promised her, but her mother refused because she was not among the top ten. Why is the drama "I" so difficult to watch due to the same conflict? The reason is the lack of echo from the previous plot. There are three major premises for why Deshan wants to celebrate his birthday with his sister. First, Deshan’s family is not wealthy; second, Deshan and Paula’s birthdays are only three days apart; third, Deshan is the irritated elder in the family. two. If there hadn't been the turmoil at the Olympics, Deshan would probably have endured it for another year. But under the catalysis of this incident, Deshan's explosion was inevitable and beyond the control of the screenwriter. The audience will also be very comfortable because it meets their psychological expectations.

Furthermore, a very gripping point of the drama "Reply" is that both parents and children have the ability to reflect on themselves. Deshan's parents know that their actions are not harmful to their second daughter. Fair enough; Zhengfeng apologized to his mother before the operation that he was in poor health and not as strong as her mother; after Zhenghuan lost the opportunity to confess to Deshan, he finally realized that it was his hesitation and timidity that led to the loss of true love.

Watching a drama like this, the audience will grow with the characters and care about human nature together. The treatment in "I" is very lazy. The mother finally gave the money to her daughter, which actually created a wronged mother and an ignorant daughter. The screenwriters naturally let the parents grow into: I am very busy and very hard. But still have to fulfill your wishes. When conflict reaches a certain level, the thing or thing that caused the conflict no longer matters. For Deshan, does the birthday cake matter in the end? The cake in Dongri's father's hand is just a signal, expressing the parents' apology and reconciliation with their daughter; but for the heroine in "I", the pair of travel shoes is too important, so important that it connects the next two The plot of the episode.

The reason why domestic dramas are not good to watch is largely because the screenwriters do not have the ability to tell the story clearly and clearly. If the preparation at the beginning is not in place, it will become a big bug as the plot develops later. In "Reply 1988", almost all the main actors (even some characters from the chess club) appear in episodes one and two, and the rest of the story will be easy to tell. On the other hand, in some domestic dramas, almost halfway through the acting, suddenly there is another A new character has appeared, but what does he have to do with the previous plot? What’s the relationship with previous characters? Nothing was explained. This is a logic problem.