Is there a contradiction between Daiyu's death and the verdict? Some people say that Daiyu should have died by sinking into the lake. Is there any discrepancy between Gao E's A Dream of Red Mansions s

Is there a contradiction between Daiyu's death and the verdict? Some people say that Daiyu should have died by sinking into the lake. Is there any discrepancy between Gao E's A Dream of Red Mansions sequel and the previous article? "Daiyu should sink into the lake and die," Liu speculated. He looked for foreshadowing from the first eighty chapters written by Cao Xueqin as reasoning evidence.

Evidence 1

Daiyu and Mid-Autumn Poems of Xiangyun Lake

■ Source: Seventy-sixth time

Liu said, two people together, together out of the two thrilling. Xiangyun said: crossing the crane shadow in the cold pond. Daiyu received a sentence: Leng Yue buried the flower soul. The popular version is the soul of poetry, and the ancient version is the soul of flowers. )

"Flower Soul" is not a word that suddenly appears. There are many times in Lin Daiyu's funeral words. Seventy-six back here is a symbol of Lin Daiyu. "

Liu explained that "Leng Yue buries the flower soul" means that on the bleak Mid-Autumn Festival night, the Mid-Autumn Festival moon is reflected on the lake, and the flower soul sinks step by step. This couplet poem implies that Lin Daiyu sank into the lake.

Evidence 2

Daiyu of Haitang Society was named Princess Xiaoxiang.

■ Source: the 37th time

"Princess Xiaoxiang, what do you mean?" Liu said, referring to the ancient legend of Shun's two concubines and. When the two concubines learned of Shun's death, they both shed tears on the bamboo, and spots appeared, so they were named Spotted Bamboo and Xiaoxiang Bamboo.

"When they couldn't find Shun, their tears dried up, and they died in the water, between rivers and lakes," Liu said. Both of them ended in tears. So the nickname "Princess Xiaoxiang" itself implies that Daiyu sank into the lake.

Evidence 3

Baoyu visited Daiyu and prophesied.

■ Source: Forty-fourth

Liu mentioned that it was Feng's birthday, but Jia Baoyu suddenly sneaked to the well in buddhist nun, because it was also Jinchuan's birthday, and he knew that his misconduct had caused Jinchuan to jump into the well and die.

No one cares, only Daiyu and Baoyu know what they are doing. She said: "The water in the world always comes from the same source. We can accept a bowl of water from Guo Rong Building and Grand View Garden and express our condolences to this bowl of water. Isn't that it? " You have to run out on purpose. "

Liu thinks it is a foolish thing for Daiyu to say such a thing, which is an early hint of her future fate. "If Cao Xueqin writes about the death of Daiyu, it is likely that Jia Baoyu will scoop up a bowl of water and pay homage to her in the bowl." Refutation: Playing broadsword in front of the author of the Red Chamber.

According to the New Red School, Liu found the so-called water-related clues from a few words, but he always felt that the evidence was far-fetched and the arguments were insufficient.

Hao Ge thinks that Daiyu's death is a logical development. The first 80 times were all sick and weak, and it is reasonable to get worse later. Suicide by jumping into the lake is a heroic act, which is different from Daiyu's temperament and personality. Because Daiyu's character is sentimental, violent character and bold suicide are not her practices. Hao Ge pointed out in Liu's New Dream of Red Mansions that we should take care of the common sense of Dream of Red Mansions. Liu Xian said that Lin Daiyu is a practitioner of performance art, and burying flowers is a typical performance art. What's the use of describing Daiyu's burying flowers in fashionable words? It was originally intended to pave the way for a romantic and poetic ending. "It's really playing a big knife in front of the author of the Red Chamber."

Reminder: Don't fall into Liu's quagmire.

Known as the "first person in the new dream of red mansions", Liu Hongxue's illness lies in his arbitrary speculation and arbitrary interpretation of the last forty chapters, which not only made Hu Shi school angry from embarrassment, but also made all kinds of red mansions in the opposition smile. In fact, there is no essential difference between Zhou's theory of jumping into the lake and Liu's theory of sinking into the lake, both of which are harmful to the text of the Red Chamber, because they are all self-righteous subjective assumptions and are all against the last forty chapters. But Lu Xun, Lin Yutang, Qian Zhongshu and others all think that the last forty chapters are very good. Gao E's 40-page sequel has been recognized by scholars and readers. It is wise to draw a clear line between director Hu Mei and The Story of the Red Chamber. However, if he falls into the forty-odd times of Liu School's Creation, he will fall into a quagmire. Ms. Hu Mei is sober. "Try to respect the original work and copy 120 times."

Response: Gao E and Cao Xueqin can't draw an equal sign.

Yesterday, Liu calmly expressed his refutation of the new, new and red schools. It would be good to have an argument and study the "red school".

Liu said: "Daiyu should die by sinking into the lake", which is a speculation. He looked for foreshadowing from the first eighty chapters written by Cao Xueqin as reasoning evidence. "My exploration and views are just a family statement and are for reference only. The conclusion that 120 times is irrefutable is wrong. Academics are not subordinate to the majority. They use celebrities to oppress others. What do they mean? There are many people who are dissatisfied with the last forty chapters, not just one on Monday. Qian Zhongshu, a clever scientist, doesn't touch the' red chamber', so today's people can't surpass Qian Zhongshu? " Liu retorted that none of us had actually read the last twenty-eight chapters of Cao Xueqin. When Gao E continued to write forty times, Cao Xueqin had been dead for thirty years and they didn't know each other at all. You can like Gao E, but you can't equate them.