Joke Collection Website - Joke collection - What if manstein commanded the North African army and guderian commanded the whole Barbarossa to plan Rommel's attack on Moscow?

What if manstein commanded the North African army and guderian commanded the whole Barbarossa to plan Rommel's attack on Moscow?

It shows that history is not a hypothetical big butterfly effect composed of inevitability and contingency.

What we assume is only inevitability .. Manstein's attack on North Africa will certainly progress quickly, because the British mainland will be occupied and the British colony will be surrendered by the British high command. In addition, he is a master tactician, adventurer and strategist. Even if the British colonial army did not vote, it would be unorganized. The Egyptian army can basically not mention {probably} letting Germany occupy the whole of Africa, while Stalin's arrogance and the Soviet Union's purges made the death of the Kipp army basically inevitable. The Germans will continue until Moscow, and the United States will go to war with Germany more quickly, because Germany has occupied the whole of Europe. Because from the economic and political point of view, the United States will never let Germany dominate Europe, and Germany will face the situation of fighting on the third line. Rommel and guderian were not the saviors of the Eastern Front, not even Stan. Historically, guderian has never been the commander of a large army group for a long time, and I don't know how he can fight. Stalingrad will become inevitable, and there may not be a Kharkov counterattack. Without Kharkov, there would be no Battle of Kursk. On the other hand, Rommel never held the post of a large army. He is not as good as paulus, because Hitler's stubbornness will inevitably lead to the failure of the German army in the Eastern Front, but Germany has dominated Europe and has strategic depth. Because of passive combat and the fall of Britain, the Germans will inevitably have a huge naval fleet, and Britain itself is a naval power, so the Normandy landing will inevitably fail. The United States may temporarily retreat because of huge losses. They will wait and see whether the Soviet Union and Stalin will make peace with Germany because of the failure of the United States. Don't say that the American atomic bomb was dropped on Germany, only to make them surrender, not to occupy the head of state. Once the Fuehrer dies, the radical Nazis in Germany will take over Germany, and the war will drag on for decades. I wonder how guderian, Rommel and Manstein would behave if they changed their fronts. As I have said, they are just commanders, not saviors. War is based on politics, economy, people, prestige and international environment. It doesn't mean that if you win, Rommel and they are not as handsome as others. There are so many excellent commanders above the corps level on the Eastern Front that you can't learn. In other words, in 20 18, Europe will become a country, and Nazi-style rule will still be considered evil, but Hitler has accomplished Napoleon's unfinished feat of unifying Europe.