Is the English name Amy too impersonal?

No, this name has personality.

The English name Amy means the most beloved person.

Amy

English [?e?m?] American [?em?]?

n. Amy (female name, meaning: the most beloved People)

People who use the English name Amy:

(1) Amy Carter Amy Carter: (1967~), the daughter of Carter, the 39th President of the United States.

(2) Amy Van Dyken Amy Van Dyken: (1973~), American swimmer, won six Olympic gold medals.

(3) Amy Farrah Fowler, Sheldon’s girlfriend in the American TV series The Big Bang Theory

(4) Amy Winehouse Amy Winehouse (1983) September 14, 2011 - July 23, 2011), born in London, England, British female singer.

(5) Amy Yao Qinlei is the daughter of famous basketball stars Yao Ming and Ye Li. Born in Houston in the early morning of May 22, 2010.