Questioning the result of electrocution by aliens

The police punished "making a mountain out of a molehill"

On June 8th, a post titled "Binzhou Public Opinion Killed an Alien and Frozen It in His Freezer" began to go viral on the Internet. This post describes in detail the process of Binzhou citizen Li electrocuting aliens, with photos of aliens attached. 10, Binzhou police reported that Li had admitted to fabricating false information. 1 1, the police announced that Li was given five days' administrative detention according to law for fabricating facts, disturbing social order and causing great influence in society.

Regarding the police's decision, some netizens said that they could understand Li's "fictional facts", but they thought that it did not disturb the social order, and the local police were suspected of "making a mountain out of a molehill".

& gt& gt react.

This post caused some panic.

Yesterday, Liu, Propaganda Section of Bincheng Public Security Bureau of Binzhou City, was interviewed by Jinghua Times reporter, explaining that Li was suspected of "disturbing the normal social order".

Liu said that Li posted that he electrocuted an alien, which caused dissatisfaction among some local people who didn't know the truth. "The public security organs also received reports from Li's neighbors and landlords in the later period. This man has been at home. He said there were aliens in his freezer. "

He said that Li left contact information when posting, and was interviewed by the media, which provided some false information. After online hype and media reports, in June 10, a large number of media reporters and UFO enthusiasts rushed to Li's village from all over the country to watch, which caused people to gather. At the same time, some reporters rushed to the police station and public security bureau, which had a certain impact on the normal office order. "This is not a normal social order."

Regarding Liu's query, he said that the police's punishment for Li will not change. "This incident will definitely cause two disputes." "No one can avoid it." "We have absolutely not violated laws and regulations. We all act according to the law. No problem. "

& gt& gt perspective

A little reaction is not disturbing the order.

Zhu Xiaoding, a lawyer of Beijing Cai Liang Law Firm, thinks that "the police make a mountain out of a molehill". He believes that it is obviously inappropriate for public power to intervene in this matter. "If he lied that there were bombs or radioactive things at home, it would be easy for people to immediately feel that their safety was threatened by reality and instant. However, he said that he electrocuted an alien and put it at home, which should not cause panic among ordinary people. This is just a curious and fun news, and public power should be tolerated. "

Lawyer Wang Fu of Beijing Zhenbang Law Firm said that Li's publication of false information "is a personal moral issue"; If Li disturbs the normal life order of the landlord, the landlord can claim his rights and interests according to the lease contract or bring a lawsuit. "But no matter which one you choose, it is only a civil dispute and does not fall within the jurisdiction of the Regulations on Administrative Penalties for Public Security."

He Bing, deputy dean of the Law School of China University of Political Science and Law, believes that Li's behavior has not changed the normal social order. "If there is a little reaction in society, how can it be called disturbing the normal social order? Some people make a mountain out of a molehill. In doing so, they disrupted people's life order and changed his life track. Five days of detention has made him a tainted person. "

Police punishment must prove the degree of injury.

Lawyer Yin of Beijing Longan Law Firm believes that Binzhou police's statement also has some truth, "because Li does cheat", which is subjective and intentional. Yin said that China's laws do not clearly stipulate that the degree of disturbing social order constitutes a public security punishment. "Flexible but harmful behaviors that disrupt normal social order are more suitable for public security punishment."

He said that if, as the police said, some local residents have caused some panic because they have heard about aliens, "this is definitely harmful", but "we should also clearly understand whether people are watching jokes or really causing panic". If the police have transcripts and other evidence to prove that there is indeed panic, it is appropriate to make this administrative punishment measure. "Otherwise, this punishment is problematic."