What do singers in the industry think of Joker Xue's composition and singing skills?

① Vocal level

It’s not bad, but Xue’s vocal level is indeed at the passerby level.

First of all, let’s talk about the most important point: the male voice is the first to change Vocal area, this area is the golden area of ??male vocal music and has the most research value. The representative of this area in the Chinese music scene is, yes, JJ Lin, one of the four groups of basically invincible Chinese players who has begun to catch up with the rest of the world.

Joker Xue’s high notes start to be weak when he reaches about F4. By G4, he has been forced to change the way he sounds, and the sound quality also begins to decline, exposing serious shortcomings in the voice changing area, and a slightly trained person Male singers generally perform better than Xue in this area of ??voice changing. In other words, I personally think that Xue Guang’s basic skills in this area are not even enough to reach the level of a singer, so he is on the same level as a passerby

Secondly, let’s talk about some basic deficiencies in Xue’s singing skills:

Xue’s breath is very unstable and his ability to control his breath is weak. Live leakage can often be heard due to insufficient ventilation and lack of breath. Angry.

Xue's voice is not good, mainly chest voice, and the throat is squeezed to make the sound, so the voice is very flat and not thick, while Xue Zhiqian's voice is naturally clearer than JJ Lin's. The shape is slightly thicker, so now. . . emmmmm, you can compare the thickness of the two sounds. JJ Lin can still maintain abnormal quality and thickness at a certain height, as for Xue. . . .

That’s it, I can do it, I’ll do it.

② Creation level

I generally put the composition, arrangement, lyrics, and even the post-production together.

First of all, I don’t know if Xue participated in the post-production. This piece of information will be included in the physical CD, but I’m sorry, I never buy Xue’s physical CD. So I don’t know, so let’s put it aside for now.

Secondly, as far as I know so far, Xue has not participated in the arrangement of his own songs, so arrangement = 0

Then, when composing, the chord trend is centered on 4536251, It accounts for more than 80% of Xue's current published works, so it can be said that Xue's compositions tend to be fixed in terms of chords. On the contrary, outstanding creators such as Zhou Wang Taolin have many dazzling works besides 4536251 (personal comparison I like the main chords of "Shouldn't", 124m1 and the subsequent major and minor transitions); the genre tends to be fixed, mainly guava love songs, and the quality has declined in recent years; the melody is smooth and listenable The score is acceptable, with Zhou Wang Tao Lin giving a perfect score of about 90. Xue barely hovers around the passing line because Xue's melody line does not form a good dynamic feedback with the chord trend during development. There is a big gap between the main and chorus, with the second and third degrees The speed is mainly gradual, just like driving a car, first driving on the plains and then swooping up to the plateau and then driving steadily.

This composition model has formed a model similar to that of an industrial assembly line. The number one answer, that video also well illustrates the level of Xue's current industrial-style mass-produced music.

③ Instrumental Music Level Teacher Xue’s singing skills are quite good from the perspective of ordinary people, but they are far behind from the perspective of those in the music industry. It's the kind of feeling that if it were a final vocal exam at a conservatory, you would basically be in a state of failing, with a score of 60 or 70. It’s not so out-of-tune that I can’t find the north, but it doesn’t mean that my vocal skills are very good.

The composer above has pretty much said it, so I’ll add one more thing. In fact, the blind humming composition method used by Teacher Xue is generally used as an introductory exercise in academic classes. So...