Some people say that the Ming dynasty was completely confused and the Qing dynasty was completely enlightened. Why did the Ming Dynasty last for more than 270 years, but the Qing Dynasty perished?

The Ming and Qing Dynasties existed almost simultaneously. Ming dynasty enjoyed the country for 276 years from 1368 to 1644, and Qing dynasty enjoyed the country for 296 years from 16 16 to 12. How did the Qing Dynasty perish?

The replacement of dynasties is the general trend. Many wise kings do not mean that they can exist for a long time, but many dynasties with bad kings will certainly not last long. Therefore, not all the Ming dynasties can enjoy the country for 276 years. The Ming dynasty was all bad, and the Qing dynasty was all bright? This statement is invalid.

How can we distinguish a wise king from a fatuous king? In fact, it mainly depends on two points, one is the emperor's character, and the other is the emperor's ruling achievements;

It is a joke to say that there was no monarch in the Ming Dynasty. It can even be considered that the Qing Dynasty deliberately discredited it, not to mention the Ming Taizu Zhu Yuanzhang. How can you be a bad monarch? Zhu Yuanzhang sat on the throne from a farmer, and the only thing that made people criticize was killing the hero. If this is true, then Liu Bang is also a bad king? Emperor Xuanzong of Ming Dynasty initiated the flourishing age of Ren Xuan, because he liked playing cricket and was discredited.

Zhu Yunwen made great efforts to govern and was said to be a bad king because of usurpation;

Judy's great talent is considered a bad king because he usurped the throne.

Emperor Chongzhen hanged himself in Jingshan Park, and the worried Daming people were also said to be bad kings.

If they are all bad kings, why have they existed for nearly 300 years? In fact, any dynasty can last for a long time, not all because of the emperor. Although there were few good emperors in the Ming Dynasty, they were not very confused. The reason why they enjoyed the country for 276 years was related to the system of the Ming Dynasty.

After Zhu Yuanzhang ascended the throne, in order to consolidate the imperial power and abolish the prime minister system, however, the power of the cabinet has gradually surpassed that of previous prime ministers, and even the emperor's behavior can be restrained. Therefore, it doesn't matter if there are a few disgraceful emperors occasionally in the Ming Dynasty. As long as the cabinet ministers do their duty, it doesn't matter to the country.

It is said that Zhu Houzhao, the emperor of the Ming Dynasty, can do sth over and over again, but the power of state affairs is mainly in Yang Tinghe's hands, so it's nothing serious. A bad king is afraid that someone with ability will do it. This is the sorrow of a dynasty.

Let's look at the Qing dynasty again. What do you mean? Quan Mingjun of the Qing Dynasty? It only existed for 296 years. Why do you think there were so many emperors in Qing Dynasty? Mainly because Huang taiji began to fight for his country, and later Kangxi pacified San Francisco, Yongzheng was diligent, and Qianlong claimed to be? Old man Shiquan? After Daoguang, emperors such as Xianfeng, Tongzhi, Guangxu and Xuan Tong were also called wise kings, because they didn't make too many mistakes, but in fact they didn't achieve much.

In fact, strictly speaking, the more incompetent the emperor, Cixi has been in power since Tongzhi. The Qing Dynasty was the dynasty that had the deepest influence on China when all dynasties perished, but he was the luckiest. With the change of dynasties, most of the royal families were destroyed, and only the Aisinggioro family survived, but it also shows that the level of human civilization is getting higher and higher.

The demise of the Qing Dynasty seems to be caused by Cixi, but it was doomed from the beginning of Qianlong. The Qing dynasty closed its doors to the outside world, did not strive for progress, and thought it was a big country. However, when they were complacent, Japan had already started to rise, Russia had a successful revolution, the United States and Britain were desperately developing, and industrial revolutions began all over the world, except the Qing Dynasty.

Because of this, in 1900, Eight-Nation Alliance invaded China and Cixi fled with Guangxu. Later, the Revolution of 1911 broke out and the Qing Dynasty was declared extinct, which was the general trend.

To sum up, not all emperors in the Qing Dynasty were wise, and the Ming Dynasty was not a bad emperor. The demise of the Qing dynasty had little to do with the Ming dynasty, but was caused by the shortcomings of the system.