A controversial topic in Lin Pingzhi.

Regarding Lin Pingzhi, the mainstream debate focuses on two places:

1. Did Lin Pingzhi love Yue Lingshan?

Second, why did Lin Pingzhi kill Yue Lingshan? Look at Lin Pingzhi's revenge, from Xiaobai, who has no independent life experience, to a rookie who can't even beat street gangsters, to the Qingcheng School, a century-old brand in Wulin, which exaggerates the country. It's really the fate of ants. It's hard to say. But Lin Pingzhi has a clear goal, firm belief, perseverance and humiliation, and finally succeeded! Compared with Xia Xueyi's killing innocent people, Yuan Chengzhi's anticlimactic and Xiao Yuanshan's puzzling, Lin Pingzhi is definitely the most qualified avenger in the Golden Book. If his family martial arts is not a sword to ward off evil spirits, but a set of ecstasy palms that need to cut off his right hand, then no one can praise him. A good man and hero is willing to sacrifice for revenge, not sexism.

From the moment he started to struggle, people like Lin Pingzhi didn't belong to him. His sense of responsibility became his first motivation and first criterion. To practice martial arts well, revenge is the first goal, and anyone and anything should make way for it. To this end, he is not afraid of hardship at all costs. He can practice sword crazily without any entertainment. Not afraid of death, he can risk dying carelessly and climb the cliff every day; Not afraid of boredom, he can turn dozens of gobbledygook-like Buddhist scriptures over hundreds of times in every detail; Even self-mutilation, physical and mental distortion, madness, childlessness, he is not afraid. Lin Pingzhi can be so cruel to himself. Of course, he didn't have the psychological burden of killing Yue Lingshan. But he's really not a killer. Except for some children in Qingcheng Mountain, Mu and Yueling Mountain, he never killed any innocent people again.

I don't think Lin Pingzhi would kill Yue Lingshan if Yue Lingshan wasn't the daughter of his enemy and if he didn't want to kill Yue Lingshan as a bargaining chip in exchange for Zuo Lengchan's trust. If he is really crazy and kills Lingshan to get back at Yue Buqun, then I think there are obviously more vicious ways to deal with her. He can tell her ... ten thousand times first, and then ... no matter what, she will die and Yue Buqun will be humiliated. But he didn't. I think he has true feelings for her, but the feelings he once had have become fragile in the face of Yue Buqun's plot, the ruined life and the first choice of revenge. When Lin Pingzhi found himself having to choose between killing Yue Buqun with Zuo Lengchan and desperate revenge, he did not hesitate to choose the former, fighting Lingshan in exchange for the left's trust.

The cruelty of fate lies not only in turning the idealistic teenager Lin Pingzhi into a revenge machine Lin Pingzhi, but also in Yue Lingshan's sense of responsibility for Lin Pingzhi's love, Lin Pingzhi's persistence and Lin Pingzhi's tenacity, which are precisely the root causes of her death and misfortune. Yue Lingshan was ordered by his father to ambush in Fuzhou to find out about the Lins; Pretending to be a housewife caused a life dispute between Lin family and Qingcheng school; Seeing the Lin Pingzhi family killed and watching, there was no intercession; Although he rescued Lin Pingzhi, he deliberately introduced Lin Pingzhi to Huashan School, and went to Lin Pingzhi on orders from his father to know how to ward off evil spirits. Follow Lin Pingzhi into Fujian's former residence and Xiangyang's former residence to help find swordsmanship. After her wedding, she played the role of spying on Lin Pingzhi (she took the burden herself). She may be unintentional, but she can't be ignorant of her father's thoughts. But in the whole process, she played a role in cooperating with Yue Buqun's surveillance, guiding Lin Pingzhi into the trap of Huashan School and trapping Lin Pingzhi in Huashan School. At the same time, she played a fuse role in the event of the collapse of the Lin Pingzhi family.

For Lin Pingzhi, she is no longer an innocent and kind teacher elder sister, but on the day when the Huashan plot was discovered, she was a part of the enemy, and Yue Lingshan was a part of this surveillance network (whether intentionally or unintentionally). Although many people think she is completely innocent because of her infatuation, ladies and gentlemen, our army is surrounded by enemies, and the only female spy is by my side, with unknown intentions and suspicious behavior. Are you moved by her infatuation? Think about your father, mother, friends and colleagues who died inexplicably because of her, and give your enemy an excuse to destroy the family. Will you still love her?

As revenge for the murder, his family was killed by more than 100 people, without killing innocent people or taking revenge on society. Compared with some people who were killed by five people and vowed to take revenge ten times, the means of poisoning, rape and selling women into prostitutes are much more noble. But Jin Yong's evaluation of his retribution is different from that of readers, just because some characters fell in love with their enemies' daughters and gave up their hatred. He insisted that revenge should not be confused by his enemy's daughter and discredited by the most rampant and boring so-called justice in modern times. No matter how some characters bully ordinary people without martial arts, they can still be forgiven by male and female readers under the banner of love. Those actions were also regarded as the beauty of evil spirits, while Lin Pingzhi insisted on family first and bottom line, but was vilified as a black flower by modern people. Lin Pingzhi just got revenge, lost his eyes, ecstasy and extreme sadness intertwined (not only because he was blind, but also because he paid too much for this moment, recalling the death of one hundred people in his family, the kind of sadness that was mixed with despair for everyone around him), which had a great impact. He was moody in the carriage, which also showed that his psychology was extremely fragile at that time, and his mental state might be abnormal.

Originally, Yue Lingshan expressed his sincerity to Lin Pingzhi, but Lin Pingzhi's attitude has softened. As a result, Yue Lingshan proposed the bridal chamber, and he became grumpy. Later, he said that he had been in the palace. Yue Lingshan said to follow him. His attitude softened a little. As a result, Yue Lingshan said, "Poor Pindi, you are so poor." He's angry again. I think if Yue Lingshan is smart enough, she can persuade her to go back to Lin Pingzhi. It's a pity that Yue Lingshan is obviously not a smart man, and he doesn't know much about Lin Pingzhi. Otherwise, he won't repeatedly mention Lin Pingzhi's taboo. Yue Lingshan may have something to say, but Lin Pingzhi is very sensitive and extreme. If Yue Lingshan keeps negotiating like this, it may collapse, but there will be no murder. If you don't go, I will. If Yue Lingshan can realize this and avoid talking about some pain points in Lin Pingzhi, it is not impossible to convince Lin Pingzhi.

Originally, the negotiations could go smoothly, but Lao Denuo came ... Yue Lingshan's last sentence "If my dad hadn't saved you, you would have died!" I am not sorry for you in Yueling Mountain! " The lethality is really too great, and it is simply impossible to open the pot. For Lin Pingzhi, Yue Buqun's so-called rescue is extremely disgusting, and Yue Lingshan once helped himself with a kung fu in Lin Pingzhi. From destruction to life-threatening death, he even participated in Yue Buqun's plot against himself (this can't be said that he is suspicious, after all, he is suspicious, and Yue Lingshan can't prove himself), so this sentence angered Lin Pingzhi. So in a trance, under the catalysis of the evil nature of fencing to ward off evil spirits, Lin Pingzhi, whose psychological defense is fragile, drew his sword angrily. When it comes to the sunflower collection, it gives people an impression that it is not only extremely fast, but also has undergone great changes since it entered the palace, becoming more feminine and deeply rooted in the hearts of the people. In fact, Dong Fangbubai is the only truly feminine person in the book, because her aura is so strong that people mistakenly think that she is the representative of sunflower. From Jin Yong's point of view, the reason why she is feminine is because she has gender identity disorder, which has nothing to do with her own palace.

What about Lin Pingzhi? Jin Yong emphasized his costume. First, Ying Ying mentioned it, and then described it in depth. When Lin Pingzhi took revenge, his clothes became more and more gorgeous. And his audience is mainly a group of nuns, in addition to the Qingcheng school, there is danger in itself. Lin Pingzhi likes hunting horses, eagles and dogs, calling himself a man. If a man looks at himself one more time, he will be slapped. In addition to personal preferences, but also to prove their masculinity. Even so, at the beginning, he was favored by all the men and was nicknamed Hua Dan, girl and daughter-in-law for many times. There are many handsome guys in Jin Yong's works. Yang Guo, Mu Rongfu, Duan Yu, Chen Jialuo ... However, Lin Pingzhi is the only one who is called a girl because she is good-looking and more beautiful than a woman.

On the Lin Pingzhi, all kinds of strange settings in the early days, as well as palaces and changes in the later period, seem to imply something.

So there is a person who cares about other people's eyes and hates his own same-sex love, but deep down, it is a gender identity obstacle. This is a typical cognitive dissonance. This was not a problem at first, but as the wedding approached, he was forced to face it. It is a very reasonable psychological phenomenon that constant tension leads to anxiety and irritability when contradictions cannot be eliminated. In the book, he claimed that no one could resist the temptation of Jianpu, but in fact, Master Hongye obviously resisted, and Lin Yuantu was afraid to wait for a while. Lin Pingzhi knew that practice would be fatal, but he kept practicing for several days. After the massacre, will it really be so cold?

Maybe what he can't resist is not martial arts, but eliminating contradictions so that he doesn't have to face his real alienation. Because of the inconsistency between thought and nature, Lin Pingzhi entered a state of emotional disorder and became more and more violent, irritable and irrational. Such internal emotions, once combined with various external stimuli, are easy to make irrational behaviors in a rage. Lin Pingzhi doesn't love Yue Lingshan, otherwise, who would rather be in the palace than touch his new wife when they are about to get married? Lin Pingzhi's entering the palace without touching Yue Lingshan has two meanings: First, Lin Pingzhi's spiritual belief has always been revenge. How can these things bind him? On the second floor, Lin Pingzhi is actually trying to keep Yue Lingshan innocent.

Lin Pingzhi is not completely ignorant of Yue Lingshan's feelings for himself. At the funeral, he kept asking Yue Lingshan to leave. If he doesn't take Yue Lingshan seriously, he can torture Yue Lingshan in another way. After all, he is the daughter of the enemy and an accomplice. (Don't say that Yue Buqun is not Lin Pingzhi's enemy, just covet his sword score. What does Ruins say about Fuzhou Inn? What do you mean you didn't save Mr. and Mrs. Lin Zhennan on purpose? I have to mention that Yue Buqun arrived at the ruined temple at the right time, and Lin Zhennan and his wife were still angry when they arrived early. Yue Buqun tricked Lin Pingzhi into going to Huashan. Stab him in the back when you get the sword score. Yue Buqun's behavior is more despicable than Yu Canghai's! ) But he didn't. Even if he hated Yue Buqun again, he didn't take it out on Yue Lingshan. Even if Yue Lingshan was one of the accomplices, he didn't. Some people say why Lin Pingzhi didn't save Yue Lingshan when he took revenge. Is Lin Pingzhi obligated to save her? Lin Pingzhi didn't force her to come, but she insisted on coming. Revenge is his most important thing at present. He enjoyed the process. Why should he be distracted by the enemy's daughter? )。

Let's focus on Lin Pingzhi's sword. Throughout the novel, the plot of Lin Pingzhi's killing Yue Lingshan is very abrupt, because Lin Pingzhi seems to have believed in Yue Lingshan and kept telling Yue Lingshan to leave himself. If Yue Lingshan had left decisively, she wouldn't have died, because Lin Pingzhi really didn't want to kill her. Later, Yue Lingshan also said that no matter what Lin Pingzhi became, he would take care of him all his life. Lin Pingzhi also said that Yue Lingshan is very much like her mother, unlike her father, which makes him even less motivated to kill. But! But the plan couldn't keep up with the change, and the sudden appearance of Lao Denuo changed the direction of things. Lao Denuo wants Lin Pingzhi to take refuge in Zuo Lengchan. Lin Pingzhi knows very well that this is the only way out. He can also plot to kill his enemy Yue Buqun when he goes to Songshan. Of course, he won't refuse. But at this time, Yue Lingshan has become an urgent problem, and Yue Lingshan is in a very dangerous situation (Lin Pingzhi can't see it, and he doesn't know that Ling Huchong is hiding nearby). She can't follow her to Songshan. Isn't it a joke that Yue Buqun's daughter took refuge in Zuo Lengchan? But let Yue Lingshan go. Mu once tied Yue Lingshan and threatened him. Therefore, it is difficult to guarantee that Yue Lingshan will not be abducted by others after leaving alone.

When Lin Pingzhi killed Yue Lingshan, he said: Show your heart to the left leader! This sentence is very strange. There is a better way to show boss Zuo's mind, that is, tie Yueling Mountain to Songshan and give it to Zuo Lengchan, let him get rid of it, threaten Yue Buqun or play with Zuo Lengchan, so as to show his mind better. What's more, isn't it a pleasure for Lin Pingzhi to bother Ling Huchong and torture his sweetheart? But instead of doing so, Lin Pingzhi was eager to kill her before she left. Why? Lin Pingzhi knew very well that Yue Lingshan would be tortured to death if he didn't die in his own hands. Yue Buqun's enemies, Qingcheng School and Songshan School, are eyeing it. It's better to give her a ride yourself than to watch her being tortured and threatened by others later. The reason why he killed Yue Lingshan was really good, but he chose to end her at such a time and give her a good time, which was really unbearable. You didn't love her at first because the blood on your shoulders made you less concerned about foreign things. But after all, you are a hot-blooded teenager, not a clay sculpture, and the feelings between people will always increase day by day in one move and one style. Her cleverness and liveliness, her innocence and unrequited love for you make you irresistible. You finally start practicing sword play with her every day, singing tea-picking folk songs and enjoying the sweetness of youth and love. Floating for a long time hates less pleasure, and there are many changes on Huashan. After many twists and turns, you go back to your hometown in Fujian to find the sword spectrum to ward off evil spirits, which is the only way for you to take revenge. I also hoped that everything would go well with you, that you would get revenge and marry a beautiful wife and live a peaceful and happy life with her forever.

After all, it backfired. When you discover the true face of Yue Buqun, your faith in justice and fairness suddenly collapses. A famous gentleman's sword in the Jianghu can be a sinister and despicable villain. Who else in this world can be trusted? What about Yue Lingshan? Besides your mother, your favorite woman, does she also collude with her father and always seduce you with beauty? Maybe she doesn't love you, but she still loves her brother Ling Huchong?

Hatred blinded you, and you began to doubt her. In order to save your life by Yue Buqun's sword, you used her again and never left her side, so that Yue Buqun couldn't find a chance to do so. You doubt her, but you can't help loving her. Her natural tenderness often makes you feel that you are wrong about her, but you put it out cruelly. On the snowman, you and she carved "The seas run dry and the rocks crumble, and the two of them parted in discord". Is your heart sour, sweet or bitter? You know that the days without bad feelings are gone forever, but you can't relive the old feelings when you go back to Huashan.

You got back the sword score you dreamed of, at the cost of eavesdropping on the conversation of Mr. and Mrs. Yue Buqun every night, and almost fell off the cliff, only to find that revenge was more expensive. You later told Yue Lingshan that you wanted to be husband and wife with her again and again before you started practicing swordsmanship, but because you couldn't resist the temptation of swordsmanship, you entered the palace in advance. You say this in the hope that she will hate you, but you do it because you love her. Can't a person like you who can swallow his pride resist the temptation of just a few strokes of fencing? What have you never endured from the beatings of the enemy and the abuse of the peasant woman? You don't want her to marry Duke Zhou and let her live as a widow all her life. You want her to have a chance to go back to another person who loves her, because you are doomed not to give her happiness. That sentence is your real intention: "You are still a virgin, go back to Ling Huchong." Only God knows the sadness and pain when you spit out this sentence.

Just, why did you kill her in the end?

You are still too persistent, and love can't melt your steely hatred. Yu Canghai and Mu Gao Feng are dead, and all your hatred is concentrated on Yue Buqun alone. After all, she is Yue Buqun's daughter, and you hate her because of Yue Buqun. If you still love her, if she is still with you, you will be afraid that you can't take revenge on Yue Buqun yourself. When you stabbed her in the chest, did it ever occur to you that you had lost the last person in the world who really loved you? If she would listen to you and go back to Ling Huchong, maybe you wouldn't kill her? But she is also so persistent. If she falls in love with you, she will never leave you. "Pingdi didn't mean to kill me, just missed it for a while."

This is what Yue Lingshan said. Ling Huchong was very angry and thought it was her blind defense of Lin Pingzhi. But is it really impossible? We insist on not dreaming, and everything is analyzed from the original text.

Lin Pingzhi sighed, as if his heart had softened, and said, "Well, I'll trust you again. But I have become like this. What's the point of you following me? You and I are just husband and wife, not husband and wife. You are still a virgin, so turn around ... go back to Ling Huchong! " Although Lin Pingzhi is almost crazy at this time, he still feels very cordial. Then Lin Pingzhi sighed and said, "I don't hate you." Lin Pingzhi said, "You are a little different from your father. You ... you are more like your mother. " Tone to soft, obviously to Yue Lingshan's true feelings, the heart is also very touched.

Even in the end, seeing that Yue Lingshan didn't change his mind, he had to tell a secret that a man would feel ashamed of. Why? It is the heart to kill Yueling Mountain. Lin Pingzhi said, "Since you are not insincere to me, I will tell you clearly, so that you can die from now on. He said so much just to make Yue Lingshan give up. It seems that he is kicking her out, but it is also for her own good.

Later, old Deno appeared and revealed many secrets that seemed to be true. Lin Pingzhi catered to everything he said without thinking, because he had no choice but to go. He thinks that if he doesn't promise, Old Deno will kill himself by force, and the covenant between Yue Lingshan, Lin Pingzhi and Zuo Lengchan is largely coercion. He had no choice but to say yes or die. At that time, at the suggestion of old Deno, he decided to go with him. At this time, he also considered the safety of Yue Lingshan. He said, with a good wife like me, how can Alin live to this day? Before, he was obviously moved by Yue Lingshan and believed her, but this time he changed his mind and told Lao Denuo that he was not with her and didn't want her to be with him. Old Deno ignored him, turned a deaf ear, and continued to force Yue Lingshan to help her husband or father. The purpose was obviously to force Yue Lingshan to mount Songshan. It can be said that with Yue Lingshan, they have another bargaining chip against Yue Buqun, and Zuo Lengchan can use her to better manipulate and use Lin Pingzhi/threaten Ling Huchong, killing two birds with one stone. So at this time, Lin Pingzhi, who always wanted Yue Lingshan to live, said coldly, "It is right for you to become a monk in Hengshan." Then what do you mean? I want to show my heart to the leftist leader. So as a living sword spectrum that Zuo Leng desperately wants (not that he ran to take refuge in), is it necessary for Lin Pingzhi to show his mind by killing Yue Lingshan? Obviously there is no need (as can be seen in the following chapters, Zuo Lengchan lowers himself and seniority to please him, and Pingzhi obviously didn't completely hand over the sword spectrum, nor did he show any gesture of fawning on loyalty in his speech). Besides, the performance in front of him clearly shows that he doesn't hate Yue Lingshan, but has some feelings. Convinced that old Deno wouldn't let Yue Lingshan leave, he decided to stab her.

He stabbed this sword with mixed feelings, not for killing. He stabbed her, mostly to get rid of her and avoid her being tied to Songshan. This can not only avoid being subject to others, but also avoid her being subject to others, and the two have nothing to do from now on.