In a debate, what do you think if one person makes a mistake and everyone is punished? I am on the opposing side.

The school is not an army. Children have the right to disobey orders. They can judge whether the class teacher's words are persuasive. If it is just to cultivate the spirit of cooperation among students, I think this may not be the most appropriate method. When a child makes a mistake, he should be the first to experience the consequences of his wrong behavior. If he has the physical condition to do morning exercises, you can disqualify him from his favorite group activities and tell him that it is because of his laziness that the group has been shamed and he has to pay the price. . You can also temporarily confiscate his favorite cream cake and let him experience the pain that he cannot get. In other words, you want him to understand the mistakes he made, not just for punishment, or to say "He will not force you to take Severe measures are regarded as a kind of punishment." This may be better than simply "sitting together", at least it will not cause public outrage. Because the purpose of education is not to punish, but to make him understand that his willful behavior must pay a price.

After reading Rousseau's "Emile", I think our education must be benign and not make children feel too violent. I highly admire his statement "A child who has received a bad education is far less intelligent than a child who has not received any education." At least, we can't distort the minds of all the children in the dormitory because one child made a mistake.