The old man suspected that his daughter-in-law was cheating and hacked his son to death after being drunk. Is the crime of drunkenness a reason for mitigating punishment?

Suspecting that his daughter-in-law was cheating, the 70-year-old man complained that his son was incompetent and then killed his heart. He was sentenced to life imprisonment. Only when he drinks as incapacitated as a mental illness can his punishment be mitigated on the grounds of drinking. In this case, the parties will certainly not be intentional. Deliberately drinking and then hurting people shows that your mind is clear and drinking is not in place. In practice? Really? There are few reasons. Of course, it is very likely that the court will use this as an excuse to reduce the punishment because of behind-the-scenes operation. In that case, this reason is just an excuse, not a real reason.

77-year-old Li raised his axe after drinking and hacked his son to death. This is the true story that happened in Xining City, Qinghai Province on May 29th, 2020.

The story behind it is embarrassing. Li borrowed money everywhere to help hundreds of thousands of sons get married. He doubted whether his daughter-in-law and relatives had proper relationship, and blamed his son for being incompetent and unable to control his daughter-in-law. Take it out on your son by drinking.

Recently, the Intermediate People's Court of Xining City, Qinghai Province published criminal judgment, the first trial of the case, on China Judgment Document Network. My daughter-in-law was wronged by her father-in-law's suspicion. No way, I don't even have that person's phone number. ?

0 1

The son is addicted to gambling, and the relationship between father and son is rigid.

Li is almost 80 years old. He likes drinking. When he was young, he often beat his wife and scolded his children after drinking. In the eyes of neighbors? Li especially likes drinking, and the drinking style is not good, because he has had several fights with his family and villagers, either fighting or swearing. ? Little Zuowei Liu's daughter-in-law, interested in this? Yelling at home when you're drunk. Drunk? My father-in-law is also very helpless.

Xiao Li is Li's? Lao laizi? And the only son. Once upon a time, Li was always used to this precious son.

Xiao Li is not only an alcoholic, but also addicted to gambling. He once lost hundreds of thousands of dollars at home. In the eyes of Xiao Li's cousin, he used to love gambling and didn't make money. He often asks Li for money, playing mahjong and losing his family's hundreds of thousands of pieces of land. The relationship between father and son has always been bad. ?

It was not until Xiao Li got married that this situation eased. Li said that in order for Xiao Li to get married, he looked for someone to borrow money everywhere and finally got together100000.

02

Suspicion of daughter-in-law's infidelity

In 20 18, Xiao Li married his wife and soon gave birth to a daughter.

Li is dissatisfied with this daughter-in-law, because she and her son won't let them have grandchildren, and because he firmly believes that her daughter-in-law is unfaithful to Xiao Li's cousin.

According to Li, his daughter-in-law doesn't allow him to have a granddaughter. Why? Will it infect your granddaughter? . In contrast, Xiao Li's cousin is very? Popular? .

Li doesn't understand. Why can't grandpa coax his granddaughter? My daughter-in-law is still very happy when outsiders hug her granddaughter. I feel that my son can't even manage his wife well. ?

Although both sides say? Can't have that kind of relationship? But Li is convinced of this. He told his son Xiao Li about it, but he didn't expect to be scolded by his son.

When I scolded my daughter-in-law, Xiao Li defended her daughter-in-law and scolded us, even beating me to a semi-disability. ? The more he thinks about it, the angrier he gets, and the more he thinks about it, the more aggrieved he becomes. He believes that his son not only ignores his daughter-in-law's infidelity, but also associates with the derailed object.

Li has a murderous heart. I just want to hack my son to death and get this evil spirit out. ?

After hacking his son to death, Li also shouted: Now that my son is dead, you (daughter-in-law Xiao Liu) go with his cousin. ?

03

Chop to death a sleeping son who has been complaining for a long time

On May 29th, 2020 14: 30, drunken Li stood in the alley in front of his house, his hands covered with blood. He told passers-by about his son? Killed? The murderer is my son's cousin, let people beat him? 1 10? Call the police.

Actually, he started killing himself. In his later confession, Li said frankly: I regret it very much. It's all my fault when I get drunk. ?

At noon that day, Li went to a relative's house to drink, during which? Do you look happy? I left my bike with my relatives because I was drunk when I left. When I got home, I saw my son who had finished the night shift on the kang. Li's good mood disappeared and was replaced by a long backlog of resentment and anger.

Lee cut his son's head with an axe. The other party didn't struggle or resist, and he died in his sleep. By the time the deceased relatives opened the quilt, Xiao Li's body was already cold.

Li's crime tools were ready a month ago. Before he retired, he was a coal miner, and his axe made of coarse hemp steel was always hidden under a cabinet in his workshop. Lee sharpened the prepared axe one month in advance. The original purpose was to hack to death the nephew who had an affair with his daughter-in-law, that is, his son's cousin. After drinking, I came back to see this disappointing son who couldn't control his daughter-in-law. Lee's anger shifted. He killed his son.

After forensic identification, the deceased Xiao Li was injured in the head and face by others with sharp instruments, resulting in open craniocerebral injury and death. No ethanol was detected in Xiao Li's blood sample that day, and the ethanol content in Li Gui's blood reached131mg/100 ml.

The Intermediate People's Court of Xining City, Qinghai Province found in the first instance that Li deliberately deprived others of their lives illegally, resulting in one death, and his behavior constituted the crime of intentional homicide. After Li arrived at the case, in order to avoid the legal responsibility of the first interrogation, he wanted to plant the criminal act on others and confessed after investigation and inquiry by the procuratorate. Combined with the fact that he was 75 years old at the time of the crime, he can be given a lighter punishment, sentenced to life imprisonment and deprived of political rights for life.