Lao Luo said what Wang Ziru said was fresh and refined.

At 7 o'clock last night, Luo Yonghao and Wang Ziru "battled for the top of Youku" and launched a heated debate in the live video broadcast on a series of issues raised by Zealer's review of Smartisan mobile phones.

In the eyes of many people, this is not a debate, but a "question." However, both the aggressive Lao Luo and the submissive Wang Ziru were beaten wildly by supporters or fans of the other camp. The biggest winner in the end is Youku! According to TMTpost's observation, the entire Youku video is divided into 9 parts, and each part has a 40-second pre-roll ad before the official start. These three hours are really profitable! big! Got it!

However, in addition to Youku, there is no winner in the mobile phone industry. This winner is Apple! Throughout the debate, Lao Luo was proving: Apple is the best, but I can’t do it with my big hammer.

The following are the core points of the three-hour debate between the two sides:

In response to various details in Wang Ziru’s Smartisan mobile phone review video, Luo Yonghao pointed out or questioned Wang Ziru’s Smartisan mobile phone review video. "Factual errors":

1. The foam function between the screen and the motherboard: In the video, Wang Ziru believed that it affected the heat dissipation of the SoC on the motherboard; Luo Yonghao explained that it was for heat insulation to protect the screen. Wang Ziru said that he did not say that there was a problem with the heat dissipation design, but was just describing the facts.

2. The function of the metal cover seen after opening the back cover: Luo Yonghao believes that Wang Ziru’s decorative function is wrong, but to reinforce the middle frame; Wang Ziru said that he did not deny that this metal cover has Other functions.

3. The internal metal cover and the back shell are not tightly fitted: Wang Ziru believes that there is an air layer and the heat dissipation is not good; Luo Yonghao explained that if they are tight, it will cause heat concentration.

4. The function of the small switch: Luo Yonghao said it was used to identify the battery on the back clip, not to protect data as Wang Ziru said. (Wang Ziru admitted that the technical level is insufficient and will clarify later) 5. Difficulty of placing the sensor in the earpiece: Wang Ziru believes that the process is difficult. Luo Yonghao said that because of the professional tools, the assembly is difficult. Not complicated.

6. Exposed cables (copper foil added): Wang Ziru said in the video that static electricity may break the exposed copper wires; Luo Yonghao said that anti-static treatment has been carried out. Wang Ziru admitted that it was a slip of the tongue, but believed that the anti-static treatment of Smartisan mobile phones was improper. In the 8000v test of Moore Laboratory, 4 of the 5 Smartisan mobile phones failed.

7. JDI screen noise: Wang Ziru believes that in-cell technology is easy to produce noise, so many manufacturers are cautious in using it; Luo Yonghao said that in-cell is less likely to produce noise, and took out technical documents The address: t.tt/JDI.

8. The camera problem is the deliberate misleading of the reviewers: Luo Yonghao said that the camera white balance will be greatly affected by the shooting environment and shooting methods, and the reviewers can easily mislead the audience; a few Smartphones cannot explain the problem. , dozens of units need to be tested. Wang Ziru said that the evaluation of two mobile phones is enough. They have a complete evaluation system and can obtain relatively objective results.

9. Screen light leakage problem: Luo Yonghao said that it is extremely rare for mobile phones to perfectly control screen light leakage problem, and Smartisan mobile phones have reached the middle level in the industry.

10. Screen color accuracy issue: Luo Yonghao said that mobile phone manufacturers do not adjust the screen. This is the screen provider’s business.

The above Luo Yonghao used powerful eloquence to prove that what he said in the past about "making the best mobile phone" was actually empty talk. What he wanted to prove even more eloquently was that Smartisan mobile phones have reached the middle level in the industry, and the world The best mobile phone on the Internet is still Apple, which he once criticized. All right.

If the above core questions still revolve around Smartisan mobile phones, then the following questions raised by Luo Yonghao about Wang Ziru really fully demonstrate Lao Luo's eloquence in changing topics.

1. Lao Luo said that Wang Ziru does mobile phone evaluation, but there is no public standard. Luo Yonghao said that professional evaluations in the world will disclose the evaluation methods, but Wang Ziru does not disclose the evaluation methods; Wang Ziru said that the evaluation method is applying for a patent and will make it public after the application is successful.

2. Lao Luo said that Wang Ziru was being taken care of by the manufacturer. Wang Ziru once admitted that his team had received a total investment of 6 million yuan from Xiaomi, vivo and other manufacturers, but he also said on the spot that these investments had no impact on the independent evaluation and the team still held the controlling stake.

Luo Yonghao finally came up with a classic saying: You can be taken care of, but don’t say you are independent anymore.

3. Lao Luo said that Wang Ziru not only works as a paid consultant for manufacturers, but also conducts mobile phone evaluation, which is against professional ethics. At this time, Luo Yonghao also revealed that he had a private conversation with Wang Ziru, and what Wang Ziru said became "evidence in court."

4. Lao Luo said that Wang Ziru’s purchase channel for mobile phone repair was illegal. Wang Ziru said that the accessories came from Huaqiangbei, and Luo Yonghao said that the sources of Huaqiangbei's accessories were completely illegal. Wang Ziru said that the quality of accessories is high, and it doesn’t matter where they come from. Lao Luo said that genuine Apple products will not flow to Huaqiangbei, and it is not idealistic to continue to make them even though they know they are fake.

Well, poor Wang Ziru was basically at a disadvantage in being criticized in the end, and even said sorry at the venue, I was wrong. Provoking a cry of pity.