How are beggars formed? Can we sympathize?

In a few words, he didn't deliberately deceive anyone. It's your business to pay or not. Giving some money to beggars is also a way for us to remain sympathetic. Yang Tongguang In my hometown town, an old man with amputated legs repaired bicycle tires for more than 30 years, and a disabled couple set up a fruit stand for their two daughters to go to college, rain or shine. Although they are poor, they live with dignity. Xiao Yong

For himself and his family, a disabled person chose to live on the street 10 years and crawl on the street 10 years. Is it easy for him? If there is only one beggar left in the world, I will not hesitate to vote for the king. In case of trouble, it is suggested that the management department remind passers-by with signs in places frequented by beggars: "The government has set up a relief agency, so don't invest money in beggars." "Deteriorating" the beggar's begging environment, forcing them to go to the rescue station for help, and at the same time breaking the financial path of professional beggars. It is not easy for Wu Mao to beg for some money. As a disabled person, it is by no means easy to wander the streets every day. Especially in Shenzhen, the heat is so long that we can't sit in an air-conditioned room, not to mention how hard it is for a beggar who is over half a year old to run around begging in the hot sun. Moreover, not everyone is sympathetic. Many people turn a deaf ear to beggars' pitiful entreaties, and even reprimand and insult beggars. It's not easy for beggars to beg for some money. Who would give up their dignity if they were not forced by life? Those who love leisure and hate work may choose to sell their conscience, do evil, or sell their dignity and engage in physical transactions in exchange for money, but it is difficult to embark on this road of begging. After all, it takes more courage and effort to be a beggar. Is it enviable for Wang to earn one or two thousand yuan a month? Imagine letting wage earners who sell cheap labor in factories and construction sites become beggars. How many people can get the following response? Moreover, if a young man with good hands and feet begs, he may not even be able to eat three meals a day. Therefore, not everyone can become a beggar. It is beyond reproach that beggars can make a lot of money by taking advantage of people's sympathy as long as they don't steal, rob or sell their souls and bodies. Let's be tolerant of them, even if some people take begging as their profession, there is no need to make irresponsible remarks. Readers had better not give money after oranges, just help beggars eat and wear warm clothes. The high income of "professional beggars" really surprised me, which also shows that our citizens are very compassionate. The citizens sympathize with the beggars and hope that they can survive, strive for self-improvement and stand on their own feet as soon as possible. However, beggars take money to support their families and even buy mobile phones, which actually makes the whole family live a middle life in the village, which greatly violates the original intention of the citizens. And this will form a bad atmosphere in society-let others feel that it is feasible to get something for nothing, and someone may learn from him. I suggest that in the future, citizens should help beggars, not give them money, but give them food and clothing, as long as they can solve the problem of food and clothing. I once met an old woman in Central Park. I happened to have no change on me, only a can of eight-treasure porridge, so I gave it to her. She ate with relish. In fact, qualified beggars can go to the rescue station. For those beggars who don't want to go to the rescue station, the government can set up some charity points in various communities and stations to facilitate the citizens to provide beggars with food that they can't eat and clothes that they can't wear. Beggars can go to charity shops to solve their food and clothing needs. He Yi, a reader in Shahe, said that in the past, a tolerant society could accommodate "fake beggars", but now the society tends to be more tolerant. For example, people's attitudes towards homosexuals and AIDS patients are changing from previous discrimination to rational treatment. But I'm afraid our attitude towards beggars is a little less tolerant, especially for those who have the ability to work. I know that the values advocated by the whole society are glorious labor and despise those who get something for nothing. But I know more clearly that even in the law, there is no provision that people who have the ability to work should not be beggars. In fact, the freedom to be a beggar should also be regarded as our own freedom. In fact, I think some people's contempt for professional beggars still stems from the awareness of "equality". In some people's subconscious, no matter what they do, they should pay equally, even to the point where they don't want to see a beggar get something for nothing. In fact, everyone must be very clear that beggars are true or false, that is, other businesses. Why not? As far as Wang is concerned, we only see his appearance, and who goes deep into his heart? Does he like being a beggar so much? All we talk about is how much money he has and where he spends it. Forgive a beggar! This is also tolerance for yourself. A society that cannot tolerate "fake beggars" will never be a caring society. Media worker Zhu Qixi, if he lights up his mobile phone, will someone give him money? Imagine if Wang would make himself naked and miserable when begging (this is also a language). Only in this way can someone give him money with the idea of not letting him starve. If he expresses the real situation of his life and his family, such as brushing his mobile phone, will someone give him money? It is a kind of deception to gain sympathy from others with false information. Rainbow people are good at winning sympathy from others, which shows that they are flexible and should be able to support themselves. Even if you beg for a few years at first, you should use the remaining money as capital later and try to get rid of the beggar's life, instead of installing a phone or buying a mobile phone and continuing to live on the sympathy of others. His example has brought bad social influence, indulged lazy people's thoughts and reduced some people's confidence in helping beggars who really lost their ability to live. This behavior is reprehensible. Xiao Zhang, a resident of Shekou, issued a "begging card" to beggars. Every time I meet a beggar, I give a little change. Once, my friend dissuaded me and said, These people are very rich. They beg during the day, use their mobile phones at night and stay in hotels. Helping them is tantamount to conniving at laziness. My friend's words made me feel sad: maybe many people who have been begging for a long time are not poor, but they must have a last resort when they enter the business, otherwise how can they let go of the dignity of ordinary people? Even if they have money now, if they don't continue begging, they will soon fall back into poverty. In fact, beggars don't do much harm to society except that they hinder the appearance of the city, but few people think about their contribution to society. When they get money and goods, they also purify the hearts of the givers and make them feel satisfied and noble. A community in America once invited beggars back. I admire Mr. Wang for not only not giving up on himself when he lost his ability to work, but also bravely shouldering the burden of supporting his family. At present, the level of social welfare in China is not high. I think the government should establish a censorship system, issue begging permits to those who really need help and are willing to be beggars, protect their rights and interests, and protect the alms givers from being cheated. Teacher Wang Jiandao will make the children hold their heads up. Don't think that Wang can really be happy by begging for money to send two children to college, one child to graduate from technical secondary school and the whole family to live a "well-off life". In fact, what he has done has made his children bear a heavy "cross" and become their lifelong shame. Wang's children are ashamed to talk about their father, while others talk about their father proudly. His father is "eternal pain" in their hearts. No child wants his father to be a beggar. People can be poor, but they can't be spineless and ambitious. As a professional beggar, Wang's "weariness of learning" will make his children hold their heads up forever. And it will have a great negative impact on their future work and life. Who wants to be a beggar's daughter-in-law or son-in-law? Father is an example for children to learn, and he should set an example for children under any circumstances and be a "capitalized person". Wang really shouldn't "lie down", which makes his children unable to stand up straight all their lives. This is the price his children paid for his choice, and the price is really too heavy. Readers Xiao Lu's children become talents, which is the best return to society. Wang is a disabled person. As we all know, in this city where it is difficult for normal people to find jobs, it is even more difficult for disabled people to find jobs. What can he do? There is really no way, he chose begging-one of the most helpless demands for society. People complain about him because his income is higher than many places in the mainland, even higher than the workers on the assembly line in Shenzhen. Do you have to beg for food, and the children are sallow and emaciated to give a little sympathy? Because of his physical limitations, he could not pursue his ideal path, so he pinned his hopes on the expectation of the next generation. He deeply understood the importance of knowledge, so he put all the money he begged into his children's study. Imagine how many days and nights support the king, it must be a vision for the future of children! How many short-sighted people let their children join the society early and earn money early? As a beggar, he has to face indifference and discrimination every day, but he survived, so that the children can be aboveboard and upright in the future. The child understood his father's painstaking efforts, studied hard, and finally lived up to his father's expectations. Isn't this the best reward for society? Liang Qin, a company employee, gave us spiritual comfort. At all times and in all countries, there is probably no place without beggars. Hating him, expelling him, and even banning his activities by legal provisions have not affected the existence of beggars, which probably shows that beggars have their own reasons. If Wang doesn't become a beggar, can his family have such a life? While accepting alms, beggars also give the giver something that money can't buy, that is, the happiness of the soul. There are three beggars in Fuwa Community, New Mexico, USA. The state government passed a bill to stop issuing their begging cards on the grounds that they were already rich, but this triggered a protest March. There is a slogan in the parade: "Taking time to help others will heal your wounds. A small act of kindness is worth the comfort after an hour of exercise. " Three beggars were invited back by the government. There is also an old saying in our country: "There is nothing more enjoyable than kindness". Doing good makes us feel satisfied and happy, and beggars are often the objects of doing good. We give beggars material things, but beggars give us spiritual comfort. So I said that the existence of beggars is justified, and we might as well regard begging as a legitimate occupation. Teacher Zhao Yaxing received 37 contributions for this discussion. Among them, 22 readers think that it is hard to be a professional beggar, but at the expense of self-esteem, so we should not blame him too much. Some 15 readers think that Wang's actions are not worthy of sympathy.