Hot Internet discussions on urban management law enforcement practices

Use violence to fight violence without leaving any excuse

No matter whether the ghost is injured or not

Yesterday morning, an article titled "Shocking! A post titled "A Practical Manual for Urban Management Law Enforcement" appeared on Tianya Community. Netizen "Yidao" introduced a book called "A Practical Manual for Urban Management Law Enforcement Operations" with pictures and text. The top of the cover of the book states that it is a training material for the Beijing Urban Management Bureau, published by the National Academy of Administration Press, and the author is the "Project Research and Development Group".

The 71 pages of the book mainly talk about "Measurement of Proportion in the Process of Urban Management Law Enforcement", which describes how urban management team members can prevent violence when law enforcement is violated. For example, if you control the target's limbs so that he cannot move in a short period of time; it is best for several urban management officers to act together and control the target's body at once, so as to achieve effective results without giving the target a chance to breathe; it is not possible If you let the target off easily, you should take the target into a law enforcement vehicle and send him to the public security agency, or simply take him back to the team headquarters to ask where he is from, how long he has been here, and why he dares to use violence to resist the law...

< p>The book also "advices" urban management team members not to control the violent law enforcement behavior of opponents in front of the public. If they cannot avoid onlookers, they should do so in a more gentle way.

What is even more shocking is that in the section "Partial Actions to Resist Violence and the Law", the book also teaches urban management team members how to "fight violence with violence" without leaving any clues: Pay attention to ensuring that there is no blood on the opponent's face, no injuries on the body, and no people around. It should also be done in one go with ultra-short and quick chain movements, leaving no tail. Once implemented, the blocking action must be clean and neat, without hesitation, and use all your strength. The book also teaches urban management team members to "have no distracting thoughts" and not to think about whether they will hurt the other person. At this time, they should reach a state of selflessness. I became an urban management officer and beat the people

Treating the people as my enemies

The post immediately aroused a lot of criticism from netizens. Netizen "Tianma Xingkong 4552" was shocked - "It turns out that this is how gangsters are trained", and someone exclaimed: "They already regard the common people as enemies!" Netizen "New Herzog" pointed out that "you should reach a state of selflessness at this time" He said jokingly: "You are practicing the Sunflower Manual?" Some netizens even ridiculed it as "the publication of a book", "martial arts secrets", and "gangster training manual".

In addition to criticism, there are also netizens who support the teaching material and there is nothing wrong with it. Netizen "Feiyu Feizi" said: "Why don't you read the premise in the book: when urban management team members are violently violated when enforcing the law. If the police are violently violated when enforcing the law, they will shoot you and kill you." Even so, "Feiyufeizi" The theory of "Yu Feizi" also found no supporters. Netizen "Chamberlain 100" retorted: "The police are facing criminals, while the urban management are facing poor people!"

The post was subsequently forwarded to major forums, and netizens denounced it as "the worst." Could it be that the "bad move" was "translated from the Gestapo's internal readings?" Some netizens ridiculed the real urban management staff as "they can't learn enough! All I see is a bloody mess." Netizen "囍之郎" even responded with a slogan that satirized urban management - "People do urban management for the people, and urban management beats the people if they do it."

The reporter later investigated and found that the book was exposed by netizens as early as August 2007, but it did not attract netizens' attention at that time. The publisher stated that it had indeed published this book

However, some netizens also questioned the authenticity of the book, "Is it internal information? Is it possible to be released publicly?" Some netizens questioned that the pictures were photoshopped, but He was immediately opposed by everyone: "There are more people who know PS better than you, so don't expose your ignorance and stupidity."

Is it a real book or is it a prank by netizens? The reporter then used a search engine and found in the best-seller columns of many websites such as Tuopu.com and China Book Network that "Urban Management Law Enforcement Operations" was published by the National Academy of Administration Press in June 2006. It mainly introduced the urban management law. The basic principles of urban management law enforcement, the four major difficulties in urban management law enforcement, the management counterparts of urban management law enforcement, etc., priced at 29 yuan. But the book was nowhere to be found on the publisher's own website. The reporter then called the editorial and distribution departments of the National Academy of Administration Press, and both parties claimed that they had indeed published the book. The staff of the distribution department told reporters that the book was not distributed by them, but by the author himself. The reporter checked on the China Press and Publication Information Network and found that the book was indeed published officially.

Is such an “excellent” book available for sale in Guangzhou? Yesterday afternoon, the reporter visited the Guangzhou Book Buying Center and the bookstores near Normal University and JNU, but failed to find this book.

Visit immediately

The Beijing Urban Management Bureau will respond to this matter as soon as possible

What is the attitude of the Beijing Urban Management Bureau, which is regarded by netizens as a user of the textbook, towards this book? ? Yesterday afternoon, reporters found the Beijing Urban Management Bureau. After the other party heard that it was a reporter, he immediately guessed whether he wanted to ask about the "Urban Management Law Enforcement Operational Practices". It turned out that many media had called the bureau to learn about the situation. The staff member told reporters that they would respond to the matter.

However, the reporter called the bureau several times last night but did not receive a positive response from the bureau. Staff said they have already written materials to respond to the media, but are awaiting final approval from leaders. At 10 o'clock last night, the reporter called the Beijing Urban Management Bureau again, and the staff told them that they would not be able to respond to the matter today. When the reporter continued to ask whether the book was a textbook for the bureau, the staff member tactfully stated that it was really not convenient for him to express his opinion.

Guangzhou Urban Management

The training materials are too explicit

Yesterday, a reporter asked Guangzhou Urban Management whether they had used the training materials exposed online. Relevant people from Guangzhou Urban Management said they had never heard of this textbook, and Guangzhou had never used this textbook to train urban management team members. "How can you write it like this? It's too explicit!" After learning about the contents of the training materials in detail, the person said he couldn't believe that these things were written in the book.

The person said that Guangzhou urban management will also introduce some technical methods during training, but its purpose is to resolve conflicts rather than aggravate them. He said that these methods are not only considered from the perspective of urban management, but also take into account the restrictions of laws and regulations. "It will definitely not work if law enforcement is still illegal." After extensive research before writing

Yesterday afternoon, the Beijing Municipal Urban Management Law Enforcement Bureau issued a statement saying that this "Urban Management Law Enforcement Operational Practice" was written in 2006 to further improve the overall quality of the team and strengthen the construction of urban management law enforcement capabilities. Completed. Published together with the book are textbooks such as "Case Analysis of Urban Management Law Enforcement" and "Mental Health Reader for Urban Management Law Enforcement Personnel", all of which were compiled by domestic experts. However, after the book was compiled, the Urban Management and Law Enforcement Bureau found that some of the wording and formulations in the article were inappropriate. In order to avoid misunderstanding, it is only used as internal communication materials, and has not been uniformly trained on the front-line law enforcement members of urban management.

Yesterday afternoon, the reporter contacted the author who participated in the writing of this book - Professor Gao Feng of the Beijing Police Academy. Professor Gao said that the content of the post was taken out of context, and that the prerequisite for urban management team members to implement these measures was to encounter violent resistance to the law. Professor Gao said that he conducted a lot of research before writing and found that the operation methods are feasible. “Because the image of urban management is not good now, once this incident was reported, there was an outburst of criticism.” Professor Gao did not agree with the opinion that “some words and formulations are inappropriate.” I also "violate law enforcement"

Yesterday, the reporter contacted the original author of this post, Zhao Yang, who is also an urban management team member and works in the sub-district team under the Urban Management Brigade of Xuanwu District, Nanjing. Zhao Yang is 34 years old and a veteran player who has been in the industry for more than ten years. Although he disagrees with statements such as "no blood on the face and no injuries on the body" in the textbook and opposes "violent law enforcement", he himself will also use "violent law enforcement" in daily law enforcement, otherwise he will not be able to complete the task.