315 Exposure: The profiteering Granny Tian washed out pustules in the moxibustion hall with traditional Chinese medicine bath

This article will not express any opinions on this incident and related medical issues. I believe that the court and authoritative departments will make fair judgments and appraisals. It just raises a few questions about the media reports:

Preface : As a media organization, it has the right and obligation to report and expose social events, but the prerequisite must be rigorous, accurate, objective and fair. However, in the recent two consecutive follow-up reports, as a news media, in the absence of any judgment by the court and an authoritative determination by the provincial Food and Drug Administration, we will not say whether it is true that the Xichang incident is just one case among millions of children. The 30 Minutes Truth column has a strong subjective conjecture and biased tone. The background music, video atmosphere and shooting techniques created do not seem to be reporting a phenomenon, but to expose an industry shady that seems to have been confirmed, and to moxibustion Granny Tian. The traditional medicated baths inherited from Tang Dynasty and the entire Chinese nation have caused irreversible negative effects in the minds of consumers. Many statements in the report are untrue or contrary to common sense. The health club will explain them. We also hope that the media will pursue eyeballs and ratings. When doing so, respect the facts and respect fairness.

Grandma Tian’s simple background: `

History: More than 70 years, more than 400 franchisees, Achievements: Solving worries and bringing health to thousands of children and mothers. There are millions of people who have undergone moxibustion. As of the court’s ruling on this matter, the National 315 Consumer Association has not found a single complaint about adverse reactions after Tian Po’s moxibustion. )

Question 1: Granny Tian’s formula is a nationally patented product and is used in hundreds of franchise stores across the country. In fact, it is a small pack for one child, not a small pack for four washings as reported. For a child or even more, the cost of raw materials alone is between 12 and 15 yuan, excluding fixed costs such as labor, taxes, and storefronts. As for the explanation given by the unannounced visit to the store clerk, let’s not say whether the store clerk knows the cost structure, but in the moxibustion and moxibustion industry. In other words, there are several domestic brands with basically the same decoration style and equipment configuration. It cannot be ruled out that fake undercover visits created by the imitation of Granny Tian

Question 2: Another mother mentioned the exact same phenomenon, but it was corrected immediately. Needless to say, this phone interview was like hearing on the radio that a certain aunt took some kind of medicine and was cured of many years of illness. This kind of strong smear report makes people feel that the media It’s really powerful

Question 3: It can be said that the bath water seems to be used. No one uses the bath water repeatedly. I don’t know where this report or recording comes from. Most of them are after washing. Pour it out on the spot or drain the bath water directly from the bottom of the bucket.

Question 4: The screenshots of recordings and chats are within the scope of justice and are another topic. Who is right and who is wrong? After the court determines, whoever is responsible for perjury will be responsible. The screenshots of recordings and chats are against Xichang. The cause of the child's illness is not directly related, but the media's broadcast undoubtedly makes it easy for consumers to make subjective judgments. If the perjury is true and the screenshots are true, then the child's illness is also caused by moxibustion. This is also a real inertial thinking. The media's The responsibility is to report. If the court has not recognized the matter, let the media determine it. Even if the court finds it to be true, I think it has nothing to do with this case. Belongs to another proposition. It cannot be used as direct evidence of the cause of the child's illness. The chat records are currently only a reference for the public security organs and an aid in the direction of investigation. They cannot be used as direct evidence, not to mention that the chat records are for discussion rather than implementation.

The chat screenshot itself can also be photoshopped

Question 5: Physician qualification is a new term that appeared at 30 minutes in the recent broadcast. Granny Tian is a medicinal bath and health care institution, and has many traditional Chinese medicine foot washes and massages. Similarly, it is a health and fitness project organization, not a medical institution. As long as the employees meet the relevant national health conditions and undergo a certain period of professional training, they can work. However, the media reports undoubtedly convey the message to consumers that medicine is practiced without a license. Illegal operation;

Question 6: The process of wrapping eggs and wrapping medicine in the picture on the night of 315 is almost fabricated. Granny Tian’s Moxibustion Hall has never wrapped egg yolks into the medicine, and then wrapped it There are more large pieces of medicine, but Granny Tian uses fine medicine noodles.

Question 7: The relationship between Liu Jianqiong and Wang has been announced online. We don’t care about this. They are also colleagues. We don’t care about this. In terms of the cause, psoriasis is more likely to appear in rural areas. It is usually used Bezoar, wine and other drugs can cure it, but it only takes a long time. As for Liu Jianqiong's child, why she can't walk even at the age of four is because her child has already had this disease and has been given drugs that can easily cause softening of the body for a long time. , and then he tried it at Granny Tian’s moxibustion hall to see if it had any effect. Instead, he and Granny Tian became so enmity from then on.