How to write expert review opinions?

According to the advantages and disadvantages, the final result or score is given, and perhaps the evaluation opinion can be considered separately. As the name implies, comment-comment-opinion. In other words, we should first point out the advantages and disadvantages of each other, then give the final result or score according to the advantages and disadvantages, and finally give some guidance and suggestions to each other as experts.

The evaluation experts should be highly responsible and realistic, and make an appropriate and fair evaluation according to the actual level of the representatives and the declared professional and technical positions.

If the evaluation opinions in the process of bid evaluation can be led by the team leader, all the judges will discuss and write together. If the work evaluation of bid evaluation experts is issued by the tenderer or agency.

Extended data:

Model essay on the evaluation opinions of the expert group:

With regard to the expert review opinions of Jinan Zhihua Consulting Co., Ltd. entrusted by Jinan Development and Reform Commission on the energy-saving evaluation report form of xx Water Co., Ltd.' s watershed waterworks technical transformation project, according to the requirements of "Decision of the State Council on Strengthening Energy-saving Work" (Guo Fa [20xx] No.28) and "Interim Measures for Energy-saving Evaluation and Review of Fixed Assets Investment Projects" (No.6 in 20xx),

Organize experts in electrical, water supply and drainage, energy management, etc. to review the Energy Conservation Assessment Report of Fenhe Waterworks Technical Renovation Project of Jinan Quancheng Water Co., Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as "Energy Conservation Assessment Report") compiled by Jinan Municipal Engineering Design and Research Institute Co., Ltd..

In the spirit of being scientific, objective, fair and responsible, experts have carefully reviewed this energy-saving assessment report form and formed the following opinions:

I. Evaluation basis

1. It is forbidden to adopt the relevant planning outline of "xx".

2. Update outdated standards, such as GB50335-20xx Code for Design of Wastewater Reuse Engineering. Update the Code for Design of 3- 1 10 kV High Voltage Distribution Equipment to the version of GB50060-20xx.

3. Delete the standards and specifications not covered in this report, such as General Rules for Compilation of Feasibility Study Report of Fixed Assets Investment Projects and Preliminary Design of Energy Saving Articles (Chapters) (Q/CNPC 64-20xx).

Second, the project location energy supply conditions

The specific power distribution station unit, the distance and orientation from the factory should be defined, and its power supply capacity and existing load should be analyzed to explain whether the power supply conditions can meet the energy demand of the later operation of the project.

Three. Process flow and technical scheme

1. For the reconstruction and expansion project, the original process and technical scheme should be explained, but this section is mainly about the impact of the reconstruction and expansion process and technical scheme on energy consumption, and relevant contents should be added;

2. The height difference between east and west of the project site is large. The Energy Saving Report Form should supplement the plan and elevation layout of the original and new water purification facilities of the project, and analyze the measures and effects of how to reduce energy consumption by using natural height difference.

It also explains how to deal with the relationship between the original facilities and the new facilities, so as to achieve the requirements of energy saving and consumption reduction under the premise of maintaining normal operation during the project construction as much as possible.

Four, the main energy-consuming processes, energy-consuming equipment, auxiliary production system:

1. Check the annual running time of the production process and improve the calculation process of annual power consumption of main electrical equipment.

2. Supplement the data of membrane water production, and compare it with the same industry to analyze its advanced nature.

3. For membrane filters with high power consumption, it is suggested to increase monitoring facilities to determine reasonable power consumption conditions.

4. The calculation and statistics of power consumption of the main pump are not perfect, and the missing equipment should be supplemented.

5, supplement the industrial added value and energy consumption index of ten thousand yuan, and compare it with the relevant energy consumption indexes of provinces and cities.

6. Make it clear that the heating mode of the project is central heating or self-designed air conditioning heating, and calculate the actual annual power consumption of air conditioning operation.

7, supplementary water-saving measures, supplementary water reuse rate.

Verb (abbreviation of verb) Analysis and evaluation of energy-saving technical measures and management measures;

1. This project consumes a lot of energy, so an energy management system must be established.

2. Increase the configuration of energy metering devices such as energy statistics and monitoring in this project.

Other intransitive verbs:

1. Please report the corresponding content "Total energy consumption indicators (energy consumption per unit product, energy consumption per main process, energy consumption per unit building area, energy consumption per unit output value or added value, etc.). ) According to the compilation requirements of "Energy Conservation Assessment Report Form" in Interim Measures for Energy Conservation Assessment and Review of Fixed Assets Investment Projects (Order No.6 of the National Development and Reform Commission).

2. In the analysis of energy efficiency index of the project, try to compare the energy consumption index of similar water plants in Shandong Province and Jinan City, and analyze the energy efficiency level of the project.

3. According to the improved and adjusted energy consumption, the report analyzes and evaluates the energy consumption of each unit of the project. The content of the energy-saving assessment report of this project is relatively complete, and the depth basically meets the requirements. After review, we passed the energy-saving review of Energy-saving Assessment Report of Technical Renovation Project of Watershed Waterworks by Jinan Quancheng Water Co., Ltd. in principle.

For the problems existing in the energy-saving assessment report, please report to the preparation unit and the construction unit for further revision and improvement according to the expert review opinions, and report to the review unit for re-review.

Xx consulting limited

2008 1 1 month 1 1 day