Cultural and historical slogans

At present, there is a popular saying in historians: "After the Wuchang Uprising, it was Mr. Zhang Taiyan who first put forward the slogan" Revolutionary Army rises, Revolutionary Party disappears ",which had a very bad influence on the revolution." Or: "Zhang Chun disintegrated the Nanjing government with Zhang Taiyan's slogan" Revolutionary army rises, revolutionary party disappears ",helped Yuan Shikai from the inside and alienated the revolutionary regime." Is that really the case? Look at Huang Xing's son, Huang Yiou, who said in Miscellanies of the Revolution of 1911: "Dr. Sun Yat-sen later said that Zhang Taiyan's words were in line with those of a bureaucrat at that time. 1923, Dr. Sun Yat-sen was the Grand Marshal in Guangzhou, giving a performance to members of China Kuomintang. After Wuchang Uprising, he arrived in Shanghai from Paris, and was welcomed by comrades of our party, gentry, businessmen and even ordinary old bureaucrats from all walks of life. One of the bureaucrats said very solemnly:' Great, now the revolutionary army has risen and the revolutionary party has been eliminated. At that time, the ordinary bureaucrats in Yin were most afraid of revolution, so they invented the words "Revolutionary army rises, revolutionary party disappears" to resist the revolutionary party, but the revolutionaries did not understand their intention and echoed it. Dr. Sun Yat-sen made no mention of this court official in his speech. In fact, he refers to Zhang Chun. "(Selected Works of Hunan Literature and History, series 10, page 33) shows that it was not" Mr. Zhang Taiyan first put forward this slogan "; Can't say "Zhang Hong used Zhang Taiyan to propose this date".