Give it back to my sister-in-law

Of course, he can claim compensation from his sister-in-law At the beginning, he paid the money for his brother out of brotherhood, not a legal obligation. He didn't say that the money was for his brother, so he lent it to his brother and sister-in-law. If they have no money, they can pay it back later, but they must never sayno. This is not only immoral, but also forbidden by law.

The details of this matter.

Li and Wang are legally married. In 2020, Li was admitted to the hospital because of a sudden cerebral hemorrhage. During the hospitalization, Wang took care of her husband for a while, but later Wang not only refused to sign the operation list, but also refused to pay the treatment fee. When Li's younger brother knew about it, he paid part of the medical care expenses, which added up to about 1.7 million. Later, Li wanted to ask his nephew Wang to pay back the money through WeChat or telephone. Wang refused to return them, and Li's younger brother had to take them to court.

How did the court decide this matter?

The court ruled that Wang and Li should jointly repay medical expenses, while the Civil Code stipulates that husband and wife should take care of each other. The expenses incurred during Li's hospitalization belong to the same debt, but considering the personnel relationship when Li's younger brother paid the medical expenses to the other party, Li and Wang finally decided to pay the other party 654.38+0.47 million yuan. After the verdict, neither husband nor wife appealed.

What do I think of this matter?

The person who can come out to help you when you are in trouble, whether it is a relative, a friend or a lover, don't let her down in this life. However, the couple did not show gratitude. Ordinary people saved hundreds of thousands in three or four years or even five or six years, but he took it out first to treat his younger brother, indicating that family affection is very important in his heart. However, people who remarry have independent families to support after marriage. They can't force others to help themselves just because they are in trouble. I hope this couple can reflect on themselves.