Do you need to cut off the dog's tail?

I think the problem of cutting off the dog's tail should be dealt with according to the situation:

The first kind is ordinary dogs, such as normal domestic large dogs, such as big golden retriever, Alaskan sled dog, husky and Samoyed, which basically do not need to cut their tails. These dogs generally have thick tails and are not easy to get hurt or break. In normal outdoor sports, their tails will not get in the way, and Wang's big tail will also show his emotions, which is very beneficial to the communication between the owner and the dog.

The second is breed dogs. Probably including purebred dogs and hunting dogs participating in the competition. For purebred dogs, many will cut their tails for competition and beauty. I remember my neighbor's English Coca-Cola shining, but I didn't know it when I was a child. I always thought that this kind of dog was born without a tail ... I didn't know that the dog had a problem with cutting its tail until I saw the shiny cocker spaniel in the street. In the Middle Ages, European and American hounds were popular, including Rottweiler and Du Binquan, as well as VIPs (generally referring to all Teddy, Teddy is a beauty method for red VIPs, not a dog name, but a VIP is a dog name). In the past, VIP was actually used for hunting, so now many VIPs cut their tails when they play games or keep pets every day.

Finally, the third kind is the working dog. Many jobs in our daily life are done by well-trained dogs, such as drug detection dogs, fire dogs, search dogs, identification dogs, patrol dogs and guide dogs. Most of them are competent by German Shepherd (German Shepherd, commonly known as Black-backed), Su Mu (Scottish Shepherd), Labrador, Rottweiler, Spenger and Kunming. Because the working environment may be poor, or often outdoor activities, as working dogs, several dogs with fragile tails basically cut their tails to ensure their safety in outdoor activities.

Although the tail cutting operation is indeed a bit cruel, I think it is the same as sterilization, both for the dog's better survival (of course, tail cutting and sterilization depend on the dog owner's idea). Everyone has different opinions and different ideas, which is normal, so we can't completely draw the conclusion that the tail break is right or wrong. Whether working dogs and other dogs cut their tails is not mandatory, depending on the actual situation.