Shui Mu Nianhua was ridiculed by the 23-year-old judge. What did Jacky Cheung say back then?

Speaking of Shuimunianhua, many people will remember them and their songs. I haven’t seen them for a long time. When I saw them again, it was in a variety show. Not only were they eliminated, but they were also criticized by the judges. This reminded many people of what Jacky Cheung once said, what is that?

1. Jacky Cheung’s words show the sobriety of the world

Jacky Cheung once said that he admired those singers who participated in "I Am a Singer" and that he had to judge them honestly. He said, those judges don’t know whether they understand it or not. This is so true!

Many judges just sit on the judges’ bench, and they may not necessarily have many masterpieces, and even if they do, they may not be highly popular. How can such a judge judge other people's songs? Is his courage commendable? Is it because of his thick skin? If that's the case, I can also be a judge.

Some variety shows pursue variety show effects, and put aside the strength of the show. Many people participate in such variety shows not for promotion, but to expand their popularity.

Some people have also prepared many stories in order to impress everyone, and this may be just a script. Such a variety show has gained traffic in a short period of time, but what happens next? As the directing team of the show, we may not know whether there will be another season. If the traffic is good, there will be; if not, just switch to other programs.

Not many people care about their original intentions, and some people gradually lose their original intentions. Many people think that once the program is effective, that’s good. As for the original intention, it’s not important, let’s get famous first!

This is the case for the participating players, and the same is true for the participating guests. The purpose is to spark discussion. It doesn't matter whether you understand the song or not. Just like in a variety show, a contestant has finished singing. The judges are very strict when making comments. The contestant said directly, "How about you give me a sample?"

The judges said directly, no. The contestant was unhappy: "Are you teaching me how to do things?" It can be seen from this matter that some judges are not very powerful.

They sit on the judges' bench just to complete the program and complete their tasks. Who are the players? It doesn't matter what song you sing. Because he can comment on it, and commenting is a very subjective thing anyway, as long as he can find the omissions in the song.

Some people say that some judges are good, such as Na Ying, Wang Feng, Jay Chou and others. When they comment, they are very professional and are willing to help the contestants from a professional perspective. The more such mentors the better.

This fact cannot be denied. Some mentors are indeed good, but there are very few such mentors. Some people just come here to check in and then do their own thing. What value can such a mentor have? You don’t know anything about the profession, but you still use sharp language to criticize others. The problem is, they are better than you. Isn’t it a bit embarrassing?

Things that everyone finds embarrassing, these judges do not. They do this just to attract everyone's attention, so that they can increase their popularity. As for who the players are, it doesn't matter at all. Just like the judge who reviewed Shuimunianhua.

2. Shuimunianhua was criticized by the judges for being greasy. Who was hurt by this?

After listening to the song sung by Shuimunianhua, the judge directly said: The greasiness of you middle-aged people cannot impress him at all. This sentence means that Shuimunianhua is a middle-aged greasy uncle. Their songs are no longer suitable for this era. The reason why they cannot impress him is that the generation gap is too big.

Shui Mu Nian Hua, a very popular group back then, sang songs such as "I Will Have You in My Life" and "Youth". Many people would hum along with the melody. This is a memory of our time.

Although the members of this group have changed, Yao Yong left, Li Jian also left, but Chen Qiuhua joined this group. They have been trying to change, not only changing their music style, but also changing their mentality. The addition of Chen Qiuhua shows their desire to connect with this era.

The song "Strawberry Time" tells about a place where girls are filled with the fragrance of strawberries and like this kind of strawberry time.

This is their confrontation with the world and their stubbornness.

Due to the changes of the times, people's appreciation tastes have become more and more diversified, and Shuimunianhua's slow songs have gradually withdrawn from everyone's sight. At that time, I felt that they disappeared because the group disbanded. Who knows, they are still persisting, and the manifestation of persistence is appearing on variety shows.

Even if they are criticized by some low-level judges, they still have to stand on the stage of variety shows in order to promote themselves. Even if it is a round trip, they still have to stand on this stage to let everyone know that they still stick to music.

Even though they lowered their attitude, some judges still didn't let them go, thinking they were greasy. Is "Strawberry Time" very greasy? Is "Thanks for Life" greasy? Or is the latest single too greasy? How to express greasiness? The judge didn't say, so we have no way of knowing.

The word greasy has a derogatory connotation. I wonder what kind of courage this judge has to belittle others? As adults, everyone knows that in public, you need to save face for others. Otherwise, you will lose your dignity.

What this judge said was out of proportion. Shuimunianhua did not reply to them, but chose to leave. But Teacher Zheng Jun couldn't stand it anymore. He said: "When his field is very popular and when he writes excellent works, you still don't know where he is?"

The meaning of this sentence When others are very good, you are not famous at all. As a junior, you should have the most basic respect for your seniors. If not, it's not Shuimunianhua who's rude, but you.

Sometimes, it feels good to hurt others, only to find out in the end that you are a clown. This judge is such a person. He didn't expect, who is this combination? It's also possible that you thought of it and spoke like this consciously to attract attention or increase the topic.

No matter what the situation is, this judge’s approach is not worthy of praise. Also, the program team will be implicated because the judges were not chosen carefully. If this is the case, the program team will be implicated for the sake of temporary topic volume, and the loss will be huge.

As a director, he should know Shuimunianhua, otherwise, he would not invite them to the show. When people come to this show, and the judges comment on them like this, the person hurt should not be Shuimu Nianhua.

This kind of variety show should really reflect on it. If it were like this, who would show up on the show? Everyone just comes with their stories. I have a story, do you have wine? The show turned into a tearjerker to see whose story was more touching and whose story was more bizarre.

Such a program may work for a while, but will eventually fade away. Because the original intention of the show is music, not entertainment. Delivering the power of music through entertainment is the original intention of the program team.

3. The program team can only choose good judges if they stick to their original intentions

Shui Mu Nianhua was criticized by an unknown judge, which caused dissatisfaction among many people. Jacky Cheung is right, some judges pretend to understand and make irresponsible remarks. It doesn't matter if you have useful information, or even if you don't have any, you dare to speak. It's really courageous!

Is the purpose of the program team inviting such people to bring bad luck to their program? Good things don't go out, but bad things spread thousands of miles. The judge's words made many people remember the show and maybe the director as well.

If there is another variety show directed by him and people stop watching it, the director will know his fault. As long as you keep your original intention, traffic will come naturally. The original intention of music programs is to sing beautiful notes and convey social values. If you don’t have this original intention, then you’d better not do the show.

Look at some good music programs, are they all like this? Whether it's "The Voice of China" or "The Masked Singer", what everyone hears is a good voice, not strange remarks.

As a program team, we should carefully consider the positioning of the program before inviting judges and selecting students. If you don't do it well, and in the end, it's your own sign that gets damaged, then the gain outweighs the loss. After all, it’s not easy to build a brand. To destroy it, just one judge can do it.

Written at the end:

What the purpose of this judge is is no longer important, because everyone has seen his remarks and knows about this program. Jacky Cheung admires these singers, their courage, and their courage to stand on stage and be criticized. Jacky Cheung probably wouldn’t do this. If he stood on the stage, who would dare to criticize him?

Although Shuimunianhua’s popularity has declined, they are still capable and can still produce good music. Judge, what is your famous work? How many popular songs do you have? Say it yourself!