From the perspective of urban planning, which is easier to become a big city, Fuzhou or Quanzhou?

I was born in Quanzhou and studied and worked in Fuzhou. Quanzhou is the first hometown and Fuzhou is the second hometown, so I can express my opinions fairly.

Let's start with Quanzhou. Quanzhou's economic center of gravity is relatively scattered, with Shishi in Jinjiang, Nan 'an in the south, Hui 'an in the north, and Quanzhou New District, a new Taiwanese business district. Quanzhou's economy is actually quite weak, unlike Jinan and Fuzhou's Drum Tower, which is not inferior in the central part.

Licheng District is abandoned, the ancient city can't be developed, most scenic spots are free, Fengze District is ok, Luojiang District is still under development, and Quangang relies on petrochemicals, and its contribution is ok. So Quanzhou city can't.

Anxi and Yongchun are relatively poor in development. Every county and city in Quanzhou has its own strong characteristics and advantages and disadvantages. The disadvantage is that it is difficult to form a unified plan.

Let me talk about Fuzhou again. The development of Fuzhou in the past five years can be said to be rapid. After all, as a provincial capital city, it is related to the face of the province, so the policy is tilted a lot. The whole city is well planned in terms of infrastructure, transportation and people's livelihood.

Spreading from the center to the periphery should be the correct idea of urban development planning. Fuzhou is along this line of thinking, Cangshan, Minhou, Mawei and Changle are all expanding. Only when the center is strong can it dominate the surrounding areas and radiate out.

To sum up, from the perspective of urban planning, I think Fuzhou has greater potential. However, Quanzhou can still adhere to the characteristics of private development, but also can break a path.

The state should give Quanzhou more policy support.

Imported bacteria.

Thank you for trusting me and inviting me to answer. I will answer questions in depth from my personal point of view. First of all, let's learn about Fuzhou and Quanzhou. The former is the capital of Fujian, and the latter is the first economically strong city in the province. Maybe many people don't understand what is going on! Anyone who has read history knows that Quanzhou has developed into the largest coastal city in the world in the Yuan Dynasty, and it continues this glory today, but the pattern has been "downgraded" from the world's first to Fujian's first.

On the maps of provincial capitals and major cities in China, we can see that there are two cities in Fujian Province, namely Fuzhou and Xiamen.

. Why is there no Quanzhou? Because Xiamen is a city under separate state planning and the only special zone in Fujian Province.

Then the answer to the question basically surfaced. The so-called provincial capitals and major cities do not have Quanzhou, which is unscientific in theory.

So we can see a problem, that is, no matter how slow the provincial capital develops, it will still be an important part of the national strategic layout, which matches its identity.

It is also a symbol of status. In urban planning, Fuzhou is ahead of Quanzhou. This is the most basic logic, and it is the comprehensive embodiment of the central government of Fujian Province and the rights of resource distribution and overall planning.

However, regarding which is easier to develop into a big city, I want to clarify that both of them are already big cities, and the next goal is to build a megacity, even a megacity!

Fuzhou and Quanzhou have their own advantages. When analyzing these two cities first, we should know something about Fujian culture. Fujian people are homesick, which is a rare marine civilization province in China. Whether in southern Fujian or northeastern Fujian, they are actually more willing to go out and build a mansion in their hometown after hard work. In fact, this has created the urban pattern of Fujian now. There is no central big city, but there is not much difference in the development balance between cities. This is also the reason why Fujian is among the best in per capita indicators, although there is no big city in central China.

The situation of Fujian cities can be compared with Guangdong, Fuzhou and Guangzhou, Quanzhou and Foshan in Dongguan, Xiamen and Shenzhen. In fact, in this case, there will be a preliminary prediction about who will have a better chance to become a big city in the future. Fuzhou and Quanzhou are completely two development models. Quanzhou's industries are mainly concentrated in manufacturing, and Fuzhou is now vigorously developing service industries and high-tech industries. But there are differences between Fujian and Guangdong after all. Due to Fujian culture, these two cities are generally not cohesive. It is estimated that few people are willing to let these places withdraw from the city and set up districts. If we combine Fujian culture to further judge the future. These two cities are likely to go hand in hand in Fujian for a long time, and it is really difficult to have a big city like Shanghai. Quanzhou has been enlarged, and the population and topography of southern Fujian are relatively dominant. The integration of Xiamen, Zhangzhou and Quanzhou will form a relatively developed economic zone. But Fuzhou is more promising to develop into a big city than Quanzhou.

With the same culture, the attraction to the surrounding talents is a great consideration. Fuzhou is more attractive to Ningde, Nanping, Putian and Sanming than Quanzhou is to Sanming, Longyan, Xiamen and Zhangzhou. Except for manufacturing talents who prefer Quanzhou, talents from other places are more willing to come to Fuzhou. Now the terrain is no longer an important factor restricting development. And if you count Minhou in Lianjiang, Fuqing and Changle, the terrain in Fuzhou is actually not bad. Moreover, Fujian Province has also experienced the failure of the Southern Fujian Economic Golden Triangle in previous decades. At present, the focus has been on the construction of provincial capitals. In the past decades, the economic backwardness in northeast Fujian has been restricted not only by population and topography, but also by policies. Minnan should be a model of developed economy for the other side to see, and northeastern Fujian is naturally preparing for the other side. Now that the rise of the mainland has an overwhelming advantage over the other side, there is no need to think too much about this factor. At present, the biggest problem in Fuzhou is housing prices, which seriously affects the inflow of talents from outside and even within the province. To solve the problem of high housing prices, the future of Fuzhou can be expected. Personally, Fuzhou is more inclined to develop into a central city in northeast Fujian, and Quanzhou will be integrated into an important city in southern Fujian economic circle with developed manufacturing industry like Dongguan.

Fuzhou, the capital city of Fujian Province, has the largest political and educational resources in Fujian Province. Among them, universities are supported by high-quality schools such as Fuzhou University and Fujian Normal University, which can play a very good role in the development of Fuzhou, but every big city has pain points. First of all, the current housing price in Fuzhou is as high as 20,000-30,000 yuan per square meter, which will have a certain impact on many talents who want to take root in Fuzhou, leading to the recent phenomenon of student outflow. Secondly, the overall urban planning of Fuzhou is ok, but the construction of municipal roads in the main city is really criticized, as long as everyone who has been to Fuzhou knows it.

Quanzhou is currently the largest economy in Fujian Province and the GPD supported by the private economy. The overall political support of urban planning is far less than that of Fuzhou. For example, Quanzhou claimed that the subway was wiped twice and finally changed to urban light rail. In addition to political factors, there is also a fact that the government's investment in education in the early stage is far less than that in Fuzhou. Huaqiao University is a landmark university in Quanzhou, but who knows that its branch is in Xiamen? Without the self-export of senior talents, the incentive policy for introducing talents is very weak. Most private enterprises in Quanzhou are light industries, and the transformation of enterprises such as Heng 'an and Anta needs a large number of professionals. At present, the construction of the project around Quanzhou Bay is expected, but we also look forward to the strong support of the country, which was once the largest port in the world and the cultural capital of East Asia!

In 2006, I went to Quanzhou to go to college and work! Until 14! Quanzhou's Mingying economy is really developed! However, Quanzhou has been going downhill! Today's big Quanzhou has lost its original scenery and customs! Quanzhou's real heyday should be from 2004 to 10, with many brands, many factory workers and high output value. At that time, Jinjiang and Shishi could occupy more than half of China sports and half of men's wear! ! Nowadays, a large number of big brands in Quanzhou have closed down, but there are no new ones! Relying on Taobao, some small factories that should have been eliminated have developed, while those large factories with strong processing capacity, advanced equipment and excellent workmanship have basically closed down or few workers! Even the richest bird, the biggest enterprise of Shishi, can't escape the fate of bankruptcy! Today's Jinjiang Shishi, more than half of the factories are vacant! ! Quanzhou has a rich industrial chain, including clothing, shoes, food, stone, stone carving, bathroom, ceramic tile, tea and ceramics. But these industries can easily be replaced by other places! In the long run, there is no new high-tech or internet industry in Quanzhou, and the development momentum is insufficient! I feel that Quanzhou will not only be surpassed by Fuzhou, but even decline without new big moves! ! !

Hui 'an, Nan 'an, Shishi and Jinjiang, the urban areas of several counties and cities have obviously been contiguous with the central city of Quanzhou, and now they are only renamed administratively. So Quanzhou is a megacity, but it is not a megacity. (including GDP, and Quanzhou is rich in the people, because the economy mainly comes from the private economy, and the people are really rich, not just numbers. )

The development of a city can not become the first strong city by blindly expanding the urban area. It depends on what industrial chain there is in the region. I am more optimistic about Quanzhou. After all, Quanzhou's manufacturing base is so good that the transformation and introduction of new industrial chains can take off again. At present, Quanzhou can be said to be the city with the most potential and characteristics among cities of the same magnitude of GDP.

It's obviously Fuzhou. How can an ordinary prefecture-level city compete for the provincial capital in the future? Even if Quanzhou's GDP is slightly ahead of Fuzhou now, it is hard to say whether it can remain the first in 2020.

Fuzhou and Quanzhou are the top two cities in Fujian's GDP, while Quanzhou ranks first and Fuzhou ranks second. Which city is easier to develop into a big city, Fuzhou or Quanzhou? I think it must be Fuzhou. Quanzhou is inferior to Fuzhou in three aspects.

Fuzhou is a city with a strong humanistic atmosphere and a long history. It is not only a national historical and cultural city, but also an excellent tourist city in China. In the future, Fuzhou will become a comprehensive hub for exchanges with Taiwan, a national-level independent innovation demonstration zone, an important base for advanced manufacturing in the southeast coast, a modern financial center, a cultural and creative capital, a convention and exhibition capital in the Straits, a headquarters economic highland, a strong marine economy city and an important tourist destination in China. In short, if all the cities in the urban agglomeration on the west side of the Taiwan Strait are grouped together, Fuzhou is the "group owner".

Quanzhou is the city with the highest GDP in Fujian Province, one of the central cities of the urban agglomeration on the west side of the Taiwan Strait, and an important modern industrial and trade port city in China. In addition, Quanzhou is also a national historical and cultural city, and it is also the pioneer and starting point of the 2 1 century Maritime Silk Road. However, if the urban agglomeration on the west side of the Taiwan Strait is compared to a group, Quanzhou can only be a "group member" or a "manager", which is why Quanzhou's political status is slightly lower than that of Fuzhou.

With the development of China's economy in all aspects, it is the general trend for China provinces to become strong provinces and provincial capitals, and the role of provincial capitals will become more and more prominent in the future, and they will strive to become the political, economic and cultural centers of a province. As the capital of Fujian Province, Fuzhou's strategic positioning is becoming more and more obvious.

In Fujian province, except Xiamen, Fuzhou has the strongest position and comprehensive strength, and even Xiamen is not as good as Fuzhou in many aspects. Although Quanzhou is a sub-central city in the province, its comprehensive strength is still lower than that of Fuzhou and Xiamen. Under the strategy of strengthening the province, Fuzhou will only be stronger than Quanzhou and Xiamen in the future.

Many people only look at the total GDP of a city, but ignore the distribution of GDP in a region. In 2020, the GDP distribution of major cities in Fujian Province will be the first in Xiamen and the second in Fuzhou. It can be seen that the economic strength of the two main cities is not much different.

We can also see that although Quanzhou's GDP ranks first in Fujian Province, its main city lags behind Zhangzhou and Putian. Therefore, the biggest disadvantage of Quanzhou is that, like Suzhou, the main city is not strong, but the county economy is ridiculously strong. Therefore, for the future development, the city must be dominated by the main city, so the potential of Quanzhou is slightly lower than that of Fuzhou.

This is my personal opinion. what do you think?

Quanzhou is much worse than Fuzhou. Fuzhou is far ahead in education, culture and medical care. The grade of Quanzhou is much worse than that of Fuzhou. Quanzhou's industries are basically low-end industries, easy to be replaced, and the recent situation is not good.

Funny, shouldn't provincial capitals be compared with provincial capitals? Policy, welfare, education, medical care, which is not centered on the provincial capital? Try these policies in Quanzhou? Whose economy has Fuzhou driven? No matter which city in Fujian is seriously ill, everyone will go to Fuzhou, so pay attention to other cities.