Which is the safest, the Ming Dynasty forbade Wang Ye to enter Beijing or the Qing Dynasty forbade him to leave Beijing?

First of all, let's talk about the Ming Dynasty. After Zhu Yuanzhang proclaimed himself emperor, he sent more than 20 sons and nephews to various places, and he also had the military power. He did this for two reasons. The first point is to resist foreign enemies. Although the Yuan Dynasty was overthrown at that time, the Mongols still had some influence, and there were also forces such as Chen Youliang and Zhang Shicheng in China. Those governors who have been fighting with themselves for a long time have certain operational experience and can resist foreign enemies.

Second, in order to stabilize the state affairs, Zhu Yuanzhang was afraid of the change of Xuanwu Gate, so he dispersed them and kept them away from the political center.

At the same time, the captaincy developed like dandelion and became an important branch of imperial power. /kloc-in 0/644, Li Zicheng rebels captured Beijing. After Emperor Chongzhen hanged himself in Jingshan Park, Wang Pan came from all over the country, such as Zhu Yousong, Zhu Youlang of the Tang Dynasty, Zhu Shugui of Wang Gui, which lasted for 40 years.

If all the governors of the Ming Dynasty stayed in Beijing, I'm afraid they would be caught by Li Zicheng and the Qing Dynasty.

Of course, this also has obvious disadvantages: it is easy to cause excessive local power and undermine centralization. Judy also noticed this shortcoming and took further measures to weaken the power of the princes, giving them generous treatment and depriving them of administrative power, financial power and military power. The vassal stopped this time and had a good time.

Look at the Qing Dynasty. Princes were not allowed to leave Beijing.

In the Qing dynasty, the life of governors was much more "bitter" than that of the Ming dynasty. Not only are they strictly confined to the capital, but their titles are downgraded from generation to generation. Future generations did not contribute to the imperial court and eventually became civilians. Only 12 iron hat king is unlimited hereditary. In this case, the court does not have to worry about the report making waves in other places, nor does it have to spend a lot of money to raise the report.