I am a detective or a star detective, which is better?

On March 24th, the first issue of the variety "I am a Detective" was broadcast on Mango Taiwan. Officially claimed to be the companion of Detective Star. Will it be good without Sa Beining's Detective?

Let's talk about the advantages first. The guests are really serious. It can be seen that everyone is playing with their hearts and not paddling. The real layout is also very realistic, easily killing the first season of "Star Detective".

Cecilia Han and Crystal were really beautiful, and they also took part in the discussion seriously. When it was time to take over, they also participated in the performance. After the performance, they left a vivid impression, which is much better than Nana Ou-yang in the fourth case of Detective Star in the first season.

However, none of the above advantages has become an advantage. Sometimes, instead of making the program wonderful, it becomes a burden.

For example, where should the advantages of real-life layout be reflected? Reflected in the realism of space and the creation of atmosphere, as well as meticulous and rigorous techniques. However, none of this has been done. On the contrary, (new) guests can't start because of the layout of real life, lose their sense of reasoning, and can't take into account variety and plot. Originally, because the reality of shooting in the shed was not so heavy, some temporary guests would be very aware of the boundaries between variety and plot and focus on finding clues. It's really not possible to paddle on the vast sand. However, after changing the real scene, some guests with actor background, such as Cecilia Han Crystal, will involuntarily go to the plot and enter the drama, ignoring the essence of this reasoning program.

Second, both Crystal and Crystal are beautiful and moving, and both of them are in the play, which is the responsibility of Sister Ou, and it is inevitable that there will be repetition, and because the plot is too weak, it is inevitable that the audience will feel a little embarrassed after deeply entering the play. Of course, this is only the first question, but it can also reveal that the role-playing of the guests is not in place. Why is the original configuration of Hosa Gull so good? Analyzed many answers. I won't go into details here. If the guest setting can't give consideration to variety, plot and reasoning, the program effect will undoubtedly be vague and mediocre.

Third, editing is too slow compared with detective stars. The rhythm of the whole program is inexplicable, the reasoning part is too weak to be ignored, the plot and reasoning are in a mess, the main line is not clear, and the sub-line is not wonderful. Considering that the platform synthesis is much more limited than the network synthesis, it is understandable that it is not suitable for the time being, but the program group should bear in mind that the reason why "Star Detective" shines is because it is a reasoning program, and the essence of reasoning cannot be lost.

Fourth, the trouble of implantation should be reduced a little. If Detective Star has many highlights, the audience will turn a blind eye. If "I am a Detective" is all of this quality, it will inevitably make people impatient.

Fifthly, the plot and conception of "Star Detective" in the later period are brilliant, and the independent soul of the program is cultivated because of the long-term running-in between the guests and the ambition and ability of the program group. Looking back at the first season, there is not so much gaudy content, but honestly looking for clues about the reasons. The evidence chain of plastic surgery hospital has even reached an insurmountable peak in this case reasoning since the third season. Plot and conception are important, but you can't sacrifice the reasoning part. Reasoning is always the basis of I am a Detective and Star Detective. In the case of insufficient reasoning and weak plot, don't add ideas at will, so it won't make people feel forced chicken soup.

Finally, I am a Detective and Detective Star are two programs after all. If I am a Detective wants to get a good reputation, it is impossible to repeat the success of Star Detective. The content restrictions and guest configurations of these two programs are completely different. It is impossible to make "I am a detective" by copying the highlights of "Star Detective". The best situation is that I am a detective has been walking in the shadow of Star Detective. It's like having a first child and a second child. The external environment and internal personality are completely different. You can't educate the second child in the old way of educating the boss.