Is the breakthrough a realistic picture of state-owned enterprises, or is it too melodramatic?

How much I expect, how disappointed I am now. This is my full evaluation of the TV series Breakthrough. Douban score is 5.7, which is terrible, indicating that the eyes of the masses are discerning.

I have always liked Zhou's works, from My Lord's Ups and Downs, My Hero, Absolute Power and in the name of people. He created too many classics. It's a pity that the late festival is not guaranteed, and the breakthrough has become his Waterloo, losing all the accumulated reputation.

The theme of this play is very good. The entanglement of the reform and transformation of state-owned enterprises and the pain of fighting corruption and promoting honesty are the hot spots of current social concern. It is very promising and can become a classic after being made into a movie. Unfortunately, flashy, superficial, neither fish nor fowl. In fact, "in the name of people" has exposed Zhou He's fatigue, and this drama is just another confirmation.

Zhou, who once worked in the system, really shouldn't have logical confusion, unreasonable role setting and poor understanding of the bureaucracy of state-owned enterprises.

Qi Beinan's resignation was magically passed without the approval of Lin, the head of Zhongfu Group. Is it logical? You don't say! From the beginning, the play went further and further on the false and empty road.

Ding fled and became a dishwasher. Although this setting is positive enough, it is certainly unrealistic, and it was criticized at that time. Unexpectedly, this drama is even more hateful. The boss of Tang Tang Securities Company escaped and went to dig coal. That's hilarious.

It is too much for an ordinary female worker to train the children of four executives or a company.

In a state-owned enterprise as big as Zhongfu, the whole drama didn't get to the point. Either in a meeting, ready to celebrate, or fighting with brothers and sisters. Although the efficiency of state-owned enterprises is low, it is not so.

In a word, there are too many slots in this play to watch.

The exposure is not deep enough, it is darker than this.

Personally, I think reality or reality is more terrible than works.

I am a central enterprise. After reading more than ten levels, it's a bit too much. On the bright side, this is an absolute theme. If they are all in TV dramas, how have so many central enterprises developed and grown in recent years?

Breakthrough is a TV series and a literary work. It comes from life, but it is higher than life, so it is normal to have a certain gap with the actual state-owned enterprises, but the difference is a bit too big. I worked in grass-roots units and organs of central enterprises for 40 years until I retired. The leaders I came into contact with were not so overbearing and arbitrary as Lin, so blatantly rejecting dissidents and reusing cronies; There is no standing or sitting like Shi Hongxing, and his facial expressions are too rich, and it is even more impossible to hang portraits of leaders in the office. There is no situation that Niu Jie Jun contradicts the leaders at the meeting regardless of the occasion; However, there are also some slaves like Pidan Lin Manjiang. One more thing, during the breakthrough, it is common for leading cadres of Zhongfu Group and Jingzhou Zhongfu to discuss at home. Lin, Qi Bennan, Shi Hongxing, Lu Jianshe and Pi Dan all discuss the company's affairs at home or at the dinner table, and even the confidential issues of personnel arrangements. This is ok for individuals in state-owned enterprises, but it is not practical! In short, although it is not empty, it is also divorced from reality.

Even so, the TV series "Break Through" is still a good anti-corruption drama. Why else do so many people gossip about the drama? I will continue to follow the drama, but I just hope that Dragon TV and Zhejiang TV will not change the program preview at will.

Provincial super-large state-owned enterprises. Our business management process is very standardized, and the shocking corruption in the play is unimaginable and impossible. First of all, all businesses must have a request report, and all official documents must go through OA and be unconditionally traceable. There is no so-called "pitiao" (on the other hand, which leader will be so confused as to give the handle to others now), and it is even more impossible to "take it back"; Secondly, there are laws to follow in asset disposal and capital operation, and relevant national laws are sound. Enterprises also need to hold a professional meeting to demonstrate, the manager's office will discuss, and finally report to the higher authorities for approval, and then take the process of bidding, auctioning and hanging. The instructions of the whole process are complete, and no one can decide; Last but not least, the anti-corruption bureau of the local procuratorate pays close attention to large enterprises. If someone reports it, the department will quickly investigate and verify it until it is brought to justice. A well-known corruption case like this in the play, even if the enterprise wants to protect it, it is impossible for no one to care! So I think the content of TV series should be an extreme individual phenomenon or "artistic treatment".

Maybe it's to cater to some needs. It is the foundation of some state-owned enterprises, but it is not true. Works are just higher than life.

From the creation of works, it truly reflects many problems existing in state-owned enterprises, such as the unruly faction of the top leaders. What about private enterprises? Obviously, private enterprises do not enjoy the resources of state-owned enterprises, but they do all their own. Even if they violated some party discipline and state laws, such as taking care of the interests of small groups, ignoring labor laws, establishing a mercenary life orientation, taking revenge by using their power and establishing their own kingdom, they turned a deaf ear. What will be left, wealth? Right? Is it status? It's everyone's choice to live a normal life.

Art comes from life! ! !

The crew wanted to be real, but they deleted everything that was too real. As a result, a specious play was staged before our eyes.