Who has better medical skills, Bian Que or Hua Tuo?

In today's medical field, in order to praise a promising doctor, people will say: You are really a "great Bian Que doctor"! Or: You are really Hua Tuo! These two words of praise are directed at two imperial doctors in China, one is Bian Que in the Spring and Autumn Period and the Warring States Period, and the other is Hua Tuo in the Three Kingdoms Period at the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty. People will think, if you compare, who will be better?

Who is better, Bian Que or Hua Tuo? Bian Que was a famous doctor in the Spring and Autumn Period and the Warring States Period, and Hua Tuo was a famous doctor in the late Eastern Han Dynasty. Bian Que is known as "Bian Que" and Hua Tuo has the reputation of "near-re-embodiment Hua Tuo", which can be said to be equal, so who is better than Bian Que and Hua Tuo? I think both should be superb, there is no comparability, and there is no need to compare them.

Bian Que was honored as the first of the five famous doctors in ancient times by later generations, and he was a famous imperial doctor during the Spring and Autumn Period and the Warring States Period. Coincidentally, Bian Que met the famous doctor Sang Jun at that time, worshipped him as a teacher, and made a long biography of Sang Jun ... There are many short stories about Bian Que, the most famous of which is about Bian Que's medical skills.

On one occasion, Bian Que went to the state of Wei to see King Wen of Wei. King Wen of Wei asked him, "I know you have two brothers, and all three of you are medical practitioners. So can you tell me which of you has the best medical skills and who has the worst?" Without thinking, Bian Que replied, "My eldest brother has the best medical skills, followed by my second brother, and my medical skills rank last." King Wen of Wei was very surprised, so he asked Bian Que to talk about it in detail.

Bian Que thought for a moment and told King Wen of Wei, "Big Brother has the best medical skills because he can cure patients before they get sick. The patient didn't know that my eldest brother cured him before he got sick, so he thought he had been in good health and there was nothing wrong with him. At the same time, he also thinks that my eldest brother's medical skills are not brilliant.

My second brother's medical skill ranks second, and he can see the early symptoms of the disease. At that time, these were only minor illnesses, and he cured them easily. So those patients will think that my second brother is good at treating some minor illnesses, but his medical skills are average. And the patients I have treated, their symptoms are already very serious, and I need to use various methods to cure them. When people see that my treatment process is so troublesome and I have cured the patients through a lot of efforts, they will think that my medical skills are superb, far exceeding my two brothers. "After hearing this, King Wen of Wei felt deeply.

This story tells us that it is good to solve things as soon as possible after they happen, and it is better to solve them before they happen, so as not to let them happen.

Bian Que and Hua Tuo are both five famous doctors in ancient times, and they both have extremely high attainments in medicine. Bian Que and Hua Tuo were both ancient imperial doctors with superb medical skills. They are good at treating various intractable diseases and enjoy a high reputation among the people. In this way, some people may wonder who has better medical skills, Bian Que or Hua Tuo.

According to historical records, Hua Tuo was born in 145, that is, the first year of Yongjia in Han Dynasty and the last year of Eastern Han Dynasty. Hua tuo specialized in medical skills since he was a child. In order to pursue the highest level of medical skills, Hua Tuo even went out to study, learning while walking. Hua tuo once passed a county, and the sheriff of that county was seriously ill. Hua tuo was invited to treat him. After seeing the sheriff, Hua Tuo called the sheriff's son and told him, "Your father is ill because he has blood stasis in his stomach. Just spit out the blood in his stomach and your father will be fine. "

So, can you tell me what your father usually does wrong? I can stimulate your father with something wrong and make him spit out the congestion. The chief's son listened and told Hua Tuo what his father usually did wrong. Therefore, Hua Tuo wrote a letter to him, denouncing the leader, who was furious after reading it. Unexpectedly, in a rage, the chief vomited all the blood in his stomach, and he was all right at once. From this story, we can see Hua Tuo's superb medical skills. At the same time, Hua Tuo should be the first surgeon in history. He invented and used hemp boiling powder, which was later called anesthetic.

Born in 407 BC, Bian Que was a famous doctor during the Spring and Autumn Period and the Warring States Period. Bian Que studied under the famous doctor Sang Jun at that time, and made a biography, which perfectly inherited Sang Jun's medical skills ... After finishing his studies, Bian Que began to travel around the world to solve intractable diseases for people. Because of his superb medical skills, Bian Que soon became famous all over the world. When Bian Que passed by the State of Guo, he helped the dead prince of Guo to come back to life, and later helped Qin Wuwang, the monarch of Qin, to treat his waist injury. Bian Que's skillful hands and kindness make him more and more popular with people.

Fundamentally speaking, Bian Que and Hua Tuo lived in different dynasties and were good at different treatments, so their medical skills could not be compared. But one thing is certain, both of them were imperial doctors at that time and treated countless people.