Guan Yu lost Jingzhou not because of "carelessness": three major injuries made him cry Zhuge Liang.

Guan Yu lost Jingzhou, and the three fatal injuries hidden in his character made Zhuge Liang helpless.

There is an idiom in China: "Careless lost Jingzhou". Many heroes use this phrase to explain their mistakes in work, saying: I was able to do it originally, but only because I was careless for a moment and didn't notice this tiny detail problem, my work was passive and even failed. Or because of a decimal point, or because of a poor memory of a word, or occasionally using someone wrong, and so on, it is really an eternal regret! The final result of the explanation is nothing more than to explain that heroes can't be judged by success or failure, and the tone of self-blame contains a little: "I used to be much richer."

Actually, Guan Yu didn't lose Jingzhou because of carelessness.

It is said that personality determines fate. The story of the Three Kingdoms is familiar. It is generally believed that Guan Yu lost Jingzhou because of carelessness, but it was not. The loss of Jingzhou was not caused by Guan Yu's momentary negligence, but by his "arrogant" character. Guan Yu is so arrogant that he almost ignores everyone's existence, whether to the enemy or to the "comrades". Naturally, such a self-centered attitude will not have a good result.

Guan Yu is a great hero and a radiant god in the eyes of China people. Kill Yan Liang and punish Wen Chou; After five passes, six generals will be killed; Go to the meeting alone; Flooded the seventh army; Scraping bones to cure poison, not playing anesthetic, not changing color, and chatting happily with Go, and so on, these heroic deeds through time and space are enough for China people to worship to this day. Master Guan has given us China people a long face. In recent years, tourism has been developed in various places, and temples have been built in fashion. Of course, Master Guan was invited out again. I went to several places, and the temples of Guan Lao were all over the world, and they were filled with incense. One of my friends named Guan has also increased his vanity year by year: You see, our ancestors named Guan really make future generations look proud.

But after all, Master Guan is a human being, not a god. People make mistakes and problems. Guan Yu did make a big mistake for Liu Bei, and he lost Jingzhou.

The loss of Jingzhou has nothing to do with others, but Guan Yu did not listen to the advice, went his own way and lost it. This Jingzhou is hard to come by. At that time, Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang cheated, lied and importuned others in Soochow, and they did everything shameless to get them, which took a lot of effort. Well, it was lost by Guan Yu. This has caused great passivity to the newly established Shu State. That's Guan Yu. If someone else tries, you'll lose Jingzhou, and you won't be able to destroy your nine families.

According to the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, when Zhuge Liang went to Sichuan, he told Guan Yu eight words, namely, East and Sun Quan, and refused Cao Cao in the north. This is tantamount to leadership instructions. It can be called the eight-character policy. This is not just Zhuge Liang's personal decision, it should be the unified understanding of the upper managers of the newly developed Liu Bei Group, and it is a major decision made by collective research. However, it depends on who listens to important instructions and who carries out the correct policy. Think about it, if Zhao Yun is left behind in Jingzhou, will Zhao Yun dare not listen?

Zhuge Liang said what he said, but Guan Yu may not be able to hear it. Don't talk back to Zhuge Liang face to face, that's polite, that's to give you Zhuge Liang's face. What's in Guan Yu's bones? Readers can guess, which pot of vinegar are you Zhuge Liang? We hired you. This company belongs to my eldest brother. There is still a copy of me in it. We are all major shareholders. You Zhuge Liang is a part-time worker, and senior white-collar workers are also wage earners. How clever Zhuge Liang is. Of course he understands this.

Liu Bei feels relieved to leave Jingzhou in the care of Guan Yu, my brother. Good. But why didn't Liu Bei think about it carefully? You Guan Yu brothers are not reassuring cadres, but he is headstrong.

Guan Yu has several problems here. Let's analyze them.

one: Guan Yu has never been right since his subordinates obey his superiors. It is the major policy of Shu State to make peace with Sun Quan in the east and reject Cao Cao in the north. But Guan Yu dared to disobey. Foreign policy, start a new stove. You, Mr. Guan, took the liberty of falling out with Soochow. Did you ask your superiors for instructions? No. Do you know what the superior thinks of what you are doing now? I don't know What if I know? I did it. The mountain is high and the emperor is far away, which is beyond Liu Bei's reach.

two: bullying others. Have a bad relationship with colleagues. As you can imagine, how fierce Guan Yu is? Who can afford to provoke subordinates? Not to be taunted is not to be taunted, but people hate Shangguan leaders in their hearts. Finally, when Guan Yu had an accident, he sent Liao Hua to ask for help. Liu Feng Meng Da, Liao Hua's head was bleeding. The two brothers just stayed away from sending troops to rescue and watched the fire from the other side while watching Guan Yu's jokes.

three: I am not qualified to defend Jingzhou. Guan Yu is not an independent leader. It's okay to take the lead and have the courage to be improper. However, it's almost meaningless for him to be independent and manage a full-cost accounting enterprise alone. After a day and a half, nothing can be shown. After a long time, it is strange that enterprises do not lose money in an all-round way. Will he have this kind of mentality when he accepts Jingzhou's defense? You, Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang, are gone. I'll take Jingzhou this time, but I'm in charge. Let me live with the addiction of being the number one. Your brother Liu is the emperor in Chengdu, and I am the emperor in Jingzhou.

It's very emotional to write here. The personnel work in China has had a fatal wound since ancient times. Cronyism. This kind of thing has been opposed by all dynasties, and they all clamored for no. But everyone who comes to power does this, and it is difficult to correct it. You don't have to mention such a thing, so it's no use mentioning it. A friend of mine, who is an official, argued with me. He said that people are opposed to this kind of cronyism, but you have to do it to get you on stage. Why? He said, you have to promote familiar people. I know him. I need him to rest assured. Does it still make you "cronyism"? Jokes.

Guan Yu's responsibility for losing Jingzhou is due to his personal qualities, more to Liu Bei, who should pay the bill. This is a mistake caused by Liu Bei's cronyism.