Why do many people hack Captain America?

The changes to the comics in the movie made people turn black on Captain America. If the core conflict between Captain America and Iron Man in comics is the difference between freedom and security; Then in the movie, Captain America is more like a wayward person who ignores the sovereignty of other countries and only wants to rescue his good friends. Iron man is more responsible and more responsible.

1, the dispute between freedom and security became personal.

Captain America's cartoon was born in 194 1, while Republican Pictures filmed 15 episodes of the comic series Captain America on 1944, which is regarded as the first show of the cartoon character Captain America on the big screen. Today, "Captain America: Civil War" swept the world again, detonating the movie-watching frenzy of global audiences. Seventy-five years later, the audience at this time is no longer the audience at that time. Can Captain America still be the "Captain America" of that year?

If you watch online reviews, most Chinese and American audiences pay attention to Captain America: Civil War (referred to as Team America 3) because of the love triangle among Captain America, Winter Soldier and Iron Man. It seems that a mighty heroic civil war has finally evolved into a family ethics dog blood drama in which the husband occupies the first room and plays the mistress.

At the end of the movie, Iron Man watched Captain America leave with Winter Soldier, and shouted jealously, "If you want to go with him, give me back the shield that Dad gave you!" Captain America really threw the shield back to Iron Man. At that moment, I'm afraid many viewers will suspect that they have entered the wrong cinema and are watching Aunt Qiong Yao's romantic drama.

Can't blame the audience for thinking too much. In fact, in Team USA 3, the reason why Captain America stands firmly on the opposite side of Iron Man is no longer to protect his belief in the American spirit, but mainly to protect his buddy Dong Bing from harm. As a result, the dispute about the concepts of freedom and security in the original comics turned into personal grievances in the film.

Captain America is partial to his old friend, and Iron Man avenges himself. In the end, poor Spider-Man didn't know why he had to fight such a team battle. What about the audience? Just be lively and gay. As for the meaning of fighting, who cares?

2, superheroes scuffle, but the political attitude is gone.

Team USA 3 is adapted from the comic book Civil War serialized by Marvel Comics Company in 2006-2007. In the original comic book, both the registered faction headed by Iron Man and the anti-registered faction headed by Captain America knew why they were fighting and would die.

Spider-Man chose to support Iron Man at first, but when he realized that the registered faction began to interfere with individual freedom in the name of protecting public safety, he also resolutely left Iron Man and joined Captain America's camp. In this civil war, every superhero has to face up to his profound political stance and make his own answer in a dilemma.

All this is gone in the film, and the audience can't see the political attitude of the superheroes in the film, only knowing that their actions are either out of personal feelings or out of personal anger. Panther is to avenge his father. Spider-Man is threatened by Iron Man. Hawkeye thinks he is just doing an old friend a favor. The scarlet witch is dragged away by Hawkeye in a fog. The illusion of joining the battle is more like to recover the scarlet witch.

Due to the lack of collision of political positions, the most gorgeous visual effect of the film, the airport melee, lost the seriousness of the battle and became an exhibition game of "friendship first, competition second". The black widow and Hawkeye flirted while fighting, while the scarlet witch and the illusion simply hugged each other in the middle and began to tell each other their true feelings. No one seems to really take this battle seriously. The tragic feeling of the hero's civil war in the cartoon was replaced by the relaxed and humorous teasing gesture in the movie.

3. Comics criticize American government movies but point to the United Nations.

There is another detail change in the film, which is very intriguing. In the original comic book, the trigger of the civil war between superheroes is the Ghost Registration Act passed by the US Congress, which directly alludes to the American Patriot Act promulgated by the Bush administration after the September 1 1 incident.

Both bills infringe on citizens' privacy and restrict individual freedom in the name of safeguarding national and public security. The cartoonist expressed his doubts about the bill and the US government in the words of Captain America: Are we really safer when the government can violate citizens' privacy and freedom at will?

In the movie Team USA 3, the organization that proposed to supervise superheroes changed from the US Congress to the United Nations, and the Ghosts Registration Act became the Sokovia Agreement signed by many countries around the world. According to this agreement, the Avengers are not allowed to enter the territory of sovereign countries at will, and their actions must be approved by the regulatory authorities every time.

Such a small change immediately dispelled the criticism of the original comic book to the American government and pointed the finger at the alarmist of the United Nations. In the movie, "The Avengers" is called "Volunteer Police"; In reality, the United States is called the "world policeman". Both of them like to fight bravely in the territories of all countries in the world, and it is meddling to abandon the constraints of the United Nations.

It is these changes that make many viewers turn black into Captain America and Iron Man after watching the movie. If the core conflict between Captain America and Iron Man in comics is the difference between freedom and security; Then in the movie, Captain America is more like a wayward person who ignores the sovereignty of other countries and only wants to rescue his good friends. Iron man is more responsible and more responsible.

The American captain is a product of Facebook.

This is not the real captain America, at least not the captain America who insisted on justice and believed in the American spirit 75 years ago. Marvel Comics, controlled by Disney, has been pursuing the entertainment of movies, simplification of plots and characterization.

This mature narrative technique on the industrial assembly line was dubbed "Marvel Comics Dafa" by the audience. It abandons the complicated characters' motives, gives up the thinking and criticism of real problems, and only pursues the smooth plot and wonderful story. It must be admitted that this narrative technique is very effective and popular all over the world, but the audience will not leave anything behind after watching such a movie.

In the cartoon Civil War, at least the question of who is more important, freedom or security, is raised. There may never be an answer to this question, but in the process of argument, people can know and understand it more clearly and finally get the possibility of solving it. Therefore, it is often important to show the process, not to seek the result. The film Team USA 3 even avoided the presentation of the process, leaving only a series of extremely smooth but empty entertainment and fighting. Isn't this the sorrow of the audience?

Captain America is a superhero of American Marvel comics;

Captain America 1, co-written by joe simon and Jack Kirby, made its debut and was regarded as a symbol of American spirit.

Captain America was originally a thin recruit who was transformed by the American government into a super soldier. He has a shield made of real gold, and then fights with the red skull. He fell into the sea and was frozen for nearly 70 years until he was discovered and thawed by SHIELD and joined The Avengers.