Joke Collection Website - Joke collection - Tell two different stories in Romance of the Three Kingdoms and History of the Three Kingdoms.

Tell two different stories in Romance of the Three Kingdoms and History of the Three Kingdoms.

I can list ten ~ in fact, it already contains stories ~

Romance of the Three Kingdoms is a novel adapted from the historical work The History of the Three Kingdoms, which is quite different from history.

A Textual Research on the Differences between Romance of the Three Kingdoms and History of the Three Kingdoms

Guan Yu:

There is no record of the relationship between Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei in the history of the Three Kingdoms, only that they are brothers.

Dragon crescent moon blade-Guan Yu's weapon is a spear, in fact, Lu Bu's weapon is also a spear, and Zhang Fei's weapon is not a snake spear, but a general spear;

Lu Bu-Gongsun Zan did not participate in Dong Meng, so Liu, Guan and Zhang did not participate, so there would be no Lu Bu in Hulao Pass's Three British Wars, and Lu Bu was defeated by Sun Jian;

Warm wine to chop Hua Xiong-this was done by Sun Jian, a tiger in Jiangdong;

Xuzhou crossed Che Zhou-this is what Liu Bei did;

Cut Yan Liang, Wen Chou-cut Yan Liang, Wen Chou is Cao;

The three things of heaped-up mountains-Guan Yu's defeat and capture-are not such grand things as "the three things of heaped-up mountains";

After five passes and six generals, Guan Yu left Cao Cao and went directly from Xuchang south to Runan to Liu Bei. There is no such thing as going through five customs and cutting six generals;

The ancient city of Cai Yang-this is also done by Liu Bei;

Interpretation of Cao Cao-Liu Bei stopped Cao Cao in Huarong Road, but in order to contain Sun Quan and let himself enter Jingzhou and Yizhou, he did not pursue it with all his strength, so he let Cao Cao Run go;

The Battle of Changsha-Liu Beinan conquered four counties in Jingnan, and the four county governors surrendered. Huang Zhong and Changsha satrap Han Xuan surrendered, and there was no war. By the way, Wei Yan joined Liu Fang, not after killing Han Xuan;

Going to the meeting with a single knife-putting the cart before the horse is actually Lu Su going to the meeting with a single knife, and "single knife" is the sword of the sergeant;

Flooding the seventh army-this is a natural and man-made disaster, not a man-made plan;

Scraping bones and healing-at this time, Hua Tuo had died for two years, so it was not Hua Tuo who did it, but it seemed that it was ordinary military doctors;

Maicheng was not afraid to surrender-Sun Quan persuaded him to surrender, Guan Yu pretended to surrender, planted a flag at the head of the city, retreated from another door, was calculated by Monroe, and was stopped halfway;

Guan Yu and women-Tsao Gong and Liu Bei surrounded Lu Bu and Yu Fan, Guan Yuhe, sent Qin for help and begged his wife, and promised him. On the verge of breaking, it has repeatedly opened the public. There are different colors of public doubt, so I welcome in advance. Because I keep it for myself, I feel uneasy. In this way, Guan Sheng also had secular desires;

The story of Duke Guan beheading Diusim under the moon-there is no record of the story of Diusim in the official history. After the death of Lu Bu, The Romance of the Three Kingdoms did not explain the story of Diusim. Most historians think that the story of Guan Gong beheading under the moon is fiction. If it is true, Guan Yu is too unworthy to be a man.

Guan Yu's son-Guan Ping is Guan Yu's own eldest son; Guan Xing was a civil servant and died when he was young. Guan Suo is a fictional character; Guan Yu also had a daughter, said to be Silverscreen, who married Li Hui's son. By the way, Zhang Bao died before he was a teenager;

Red hare and Zhou Cang-Red hare was indeed ridden by Lu Bu, but after Lu Bu's defeat, he disappeared; There is no record of Zhou Cang in the History of the Three Kingdoms, and there are many inconsistencies in unofficial history with the records in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms. He seems to be a fictional character.

As for Monroe and Yuquan, etc. It goes without saying that they are all false, so I won't say more. Looking at Guan Yu's feat in Romance of the Three Kingdoms, it is a historical fact that Yan Liang was beheaded, and the others are all body double or fiction.

Zhuge Liang:

Using soldiers as gods-Zhuge Liang in history was good at internal affairs management, but he used soldiers slightly worse. The following facts can be explained;

Burn Bowangpo-this is played by Liu Bei. The battle took place in 202 AD, five years before Kong Ming came out of the mountain, and there was no direct fire attack. It was Liu Bei who set fire to the houses of the people, so that Xia Houdun could not get the spoils, and then set an ambush to repel the people;

The straw boat borrowed an arrow-this was done by Sun Jian and Sun Quan's father and son, respectively, in the battle of crossing the river to attack Liu Biao and Su Xu;

Borrow the east wind-there are many southeast winds on the solstice in winter, which Cao Cao and Zhou Yu know, but Cao Cao didn't expect Zhou Yu to attack at that time;

Battle of Red Cliffs-Only Sun Quan is a historical fact, and others, such as the debate of Confucianism, Zhou Yu, heroes, risks and serial stratagems, are all fictitious. By the way, Sun Quan has the idea of sending troops. If Zhuge Liang hadn't dared him, he would have fought Cao Cao.

During the two years from the end of Battle of Red Cliffs to Zhou Yu's death, Zhuge Liang was engaged in logistics work in Lingling area and had never seen Zhou Yu. As for the death of Zhou Yu, it was Pang Tong, not Zhuge Liang, who expressed condolences on behalf of Shu.

Hanzhong-Liu Bei was the commander-in-chief of the front line when he was in Hanzhong, and Zhuge Liang stayed in Chengdu to do logistics work;

Seven capture Meng Huo-there is indeed a matter of Zhuge Liang's expedition to the south in history, and there is indeed a man named Meng Huo. However, Meng Huo's seven inscriptions are not recorded in the History of the Three Kingdoms (Chen Shou himself has doubts about this matter), but Pei Songzhi said "seven captures and seven verticals" when quoting Hanshu Chunqiu, but the specific process is not recorded. After Meng Huo, he served as a civil servant in the Shu Empire.

Six out of Qishan-only two out of Qishan, Zhuge Liang cut Wei five times, only went to Qishan for the first time and the fourth time, and was beaten once;

Empty city plan-empty city plan-Sima Yi didn't play against Kong Ming at that time, so it wasn't true. The prototype of the empty city plan came from Zhao Yun's beating Cao Bing in Hanzhong.

"After the model"-is the false trust of future generations, not by Zhuge Liang;

Cattle herding Liu Ma-Actually, cattle herding is a unicycle, and Liu Ma is a common four-wheeled vehicle today. The wooden ox is a four-wheeled vehicle, and the flowing horse is a pointed boat.

Burning rattan armor-this is true, but fire attack is not Kong Ming's own idea;

The death of Zhuge scared away the living Zhong Da-it did happen, but it was not Zhuge Liang's legacy, but Sima Yi's guilty conscience;

Looking at Zhuge Liang's deeds in Romance of the Three Kingdoms, it is a historical fact that only three visits to the thatched cottage were made, and all others were body double or fiction (including the Battle of Hanshui and the burning of Hulu Valley). But we can't deny Zhuge Liang's great achievements because of this. Zhuge Liang is a great statesman and strategist in the history of China (Chen Shou wrote a book about Zhuge Liang in addition to the History of the Three Kingdoms).

Cao Cao:

Borrowing a piece of paper to calm the soldiers' anger-it's fiction;

Killing people in their dreams to protect themselves is also fictional;

Cao Cao killed the Lv Boshe family-it really happened, because Lv Boshe's son wanted to rob property before he died and reported it to the official for reward;

A bloody battle in Wancheng-Zhang Xiu and Jia Xu used the rumors of Cao Cao and Zou;

Hua Tuo's death-Because he helped Cao Chong heal slowly, Cao Cao felt that he was deliberately trying to kill Cao Chong and put him to death. He died in 208 AD, and it was certainly impossible to help Guan Yu scrape bones and heal wounds (AD 2 19).

Yang Xiuzhi's death-he was 45 when he died, not 34;

Cao Song is dead-Tao Qian sent someone to kill him;

About Liu Cong-After he gave it to Jingzhou, he was appointed as Qingzhou secretariat by Cao Cao, and he was named Hou, but he was not killed. Later, in recognition of his achievements, Cao Cao moved the suggestion of being a doctor;

Xu Shu entered Cao Cao's camp-Cao Cao went south, Liu Bei fled south with Zhuge Liang and Xu Shu, and Xu Mu was captured in the disorderly army, so Xu Shu bid farewell to Liu Bei and entered the camp without false letter;

Others:

As for age-the age of several main figures, the order from big to small is Cao Cao → Lu Bu → Zhao Yun → Guan Yu → Liu Bei → Zhang Fei → Lu Su → Zhou Yu → Zhuge Liang → Sun Quan → Lu Xun. Sun Shangxiang researched some materials, and Zhao Yun was at least two years older than Liu Bei. Battle of Red Cliffs that year, zhaoyun has more than 50 years old. Zhang Zhao is one year younger than Sun Jian; Guan Yu is one year older than Liu Bei.

Jiang Gan got the recruit-Jiang Gan in history didn't convince Zhou Yu, so he came back to praise Zhou Yu for his generosity, but he didn't get the recruit, and it happened in Battle of Red Cliffs a few years ago.

Seventy-two suspected graves-Cao Cao was buried in Gaoling, and there is no such thing as seventy-two suspected graves;

Whip Du You-this is Liu Beigan, not Zhang Fei;

Zhang Fei-Zhang Fei is a noble family. He is not only good at painting and calligraphy, but also likes to make friends with the scribes. He is also a handsome man with both civil and military skills.

About the figure-Liu Bei 172CM, Zhang Fei 184CM, Guan Yu 203CM, Cao Cao 16 1CM, Zhang Song10 cm, Zhuge Liang180 cm.

Zhou Yu, who was narrow-minded, was evaluated as "magnanimous" by Liu Bei; Cheng Pu said: "Make friends with Gong Jin and you won't get drunk"; Chen Shou commented on Zhou Yu's Sexual Recovery; In addition, Hong Mai, Su Dongpo and other ancients also spoke highly of Zhou Yu's character.

Zhang Song presented a map-after Liu Bei entered Shu, he wooed Fa Zheng and Zhang Song, and asked about the salary of military forces in Shu, so Zhang Song drew a topographic map of West Shu.

About Marten-Marten and Dong Zhuo are both on the same team. Not only did they not participate in Dong Meng, but they also helped Dong Zhuo defend Chang 'an. As for Marten's death, it was not Marten who killed Cao and avenged Ma Chao, but Ma Chao rebelled against Cao Cao, so Marten was killed because Ma Chao deeply felt that Cao Cao's army would invade his home's territory, so he attacked Cao Cao first. Anyway, Ma Chao was the first to get up.

Regarding the battle of Yiling, Liu Bei sent troops-there are many sayings, some say it is 40,000, some say it is100,000, and some think it is 60,000 or 80,000, but it is not 700,000 in the romance;

Lu Xun's strategy-not insisting from the beginning, but tracing the cause sent troops to explore the actual situation first, and decided not to insist after being defeated by the Shu army;

Gan ning's death-he died of illness, not by Shamoko;

Huang Zhong's death-he also died of illness, not war;

Ma Su Street Pavilion-Sima Yi didn't confront Kong Ming at that time, but Zhang He broke the street pavilion;

Zhang's death-was indeed shot by Kong Ming's troops, but Sima Yi had not confronted Kong Ming at that time, and his death was certainly not caused by Sima Yi's miscalculation and ambush.

Risk-Huang Gai's false surrender is not recorded in the history books;

Zhang Fei of Changban Bridge scared Cao Jun away-this was Liu Bei's order, and later Liu Bei ran away by himself. Zhang Fei didn't frighten Xiahou Jie to death with imposing manner, but just fooled Cao Chun with the plan of suspected soldiers and then retreated;

Zhao Yun saved A Dou with a million troops-there were not so many enemies, but 5,000. Liu Bei told him to "break the rear" instead of voluntarily. He killed not 50 military commanders, but only 9, but he was still brave.

Change towels to escape-Sun Jian told Zu Mao to wear a headscarf to escape and distract the enemy's attention. Zu Mao did not die;

Lu Bu killed Dong Zhuo-they broke up for a maid-in-waiting and the position of "The Story of Dixin", which was unexpected by Wang Yun, but the contradiction between Lu Bu and Dong Zhuo had already formed, and "The Story of Dixin" was just a catalyst;

Battle of Red Cliffs-Cao Cao is known as 800 million people in the romance and 800,000 people in the history.

The Battle of Hefei-Sun Quan besieged the city for many days, withdrawing troops and implementing other strategies. In the romance, Zhang Liao's 800 troops wiped out 10 army, which was greatly exaggerated. Of course, the children of Wu did not dare to cry after hearing Zhang Liao's name, and the soldiers of Wei did not frighten to death when they heard that Leitian robbed Gan Ning of Wei Ying. In fact, the battle of Hefei was 165438.

Battle of Taishi Ci-He died in 206. Of course, he was not shot by Zhang Liao troops in the battle of Hefei.

Wei Yan kicked over the life-prolonging lamp-of course there is no such thing;

About Xu Shu, whose real name is Fu Shan and alias is Xu Shu, it is just the opposite in Romance.