Who wins, Ning Guan Iron Rider with 1, Ming Dynasty or Eight Banners with 1, Qing Dynasty? With the same advantages and status.

Guan ning fighters can defeat the Qing army in the same quantity and condition!

Because although the overall fighting capacity of the Qing army was higher than that of the Ming army in the late Ming Dynasty, Ning Guan Tieqi was equivalent to the special forces of the Ming Dynasty. You can take a look at the record of Ning Guan Tieqi. They basically never lost the battle with the Qing army (I haven't read the record of their defeat), and the most classic one was that the Qing army entered Shanhaiguan, outside Beijing. More than 1, Qing troops (pay attention to the fact that the Qing army can fight at this time) met with thousands of Guanning fighters in Yuan Chonghuan after repeatedly robbing the suburbs of Beijing. The Eighth Cavalry used superior forces to attack Guanning fighters. From morning till night, more than 1, cavalry troops still did not destroy these thousands of Guanning fighters! These records I suggest you look at "Those Things in the Ming Dynasty", which is quite wonderful!

Ning Guan fighters were not destroyed in the end, but surrendered under the leadership of Wu Sangui! When they were guarding the gate of the Central Plains, the Qing army didn't have a chance to break through the defense line of Ning Guan fighters directly! And no matter which leader leads them, they are equally brave!

When Wu Sangui, the king of Pingnan rebelled, his troops were just formed on the basis of the original Ning Guan fighters (many Ning Guan fighters died when the Qing government was established, and now their fighting capacity is not as good as when he surrendered). However, it was with this army that he occupied the area south of the Yangtze River and defeated the Qing army. If he hadn't dreamed of ruling the river with the Qing government, he might have been a son of heaven instead of a thief!

As for who is stronger, I think Ning Guan Tieqi is stronger! The Qing army only had more advantages in number, but at that time, the Ming Dynasty was at home and abroad, and the Qing army was lucky to be the master!

Of course, I'm just a person who likes history, and my views are inevitably one-sided. I hope it will be of some reference value to you …