Is Qing too strong? Or is Nanming too weak?

There is nothing worth exploring in the late Ming Dynasty. The national army is in the north and the economy is in the south, but the national army has no economic support. In the south, without the support of the army, only the economy of Shilin has leapt faster. Nanming is just a story. That's because the Qing people needed the Han people to complete the integration and unification of the whole north, and merged the northern troops into green camp in the Qing Dynasty. These reductions in the Ming dynasty became the main force in the future. Moreover, Manchu needs to adapt from a robber to the basic setting of establishing an empire ~ ~ ~ and the only thing left in the south is that the peasant rebels took off their clothes and changed into the clothes of Nanming, becoming the defenders of Nanming ~ ~ ~ The officials of the Ming Dynasty argued with the emperor that there was no money for soldiers, and the wonderful tax system of the Ming Dynasty only collected farmers' taxes, while the local rich people did not pay taxes. These are all jokes about the demise of the Ming Dynasty. In fact, Wanli has completely destroyed the Ming Dynasty. The back was just swept away by the Manchu army and got the chance to be the last traitor ~ ~ ~ Without the Manchu, the Ming Dynasty was actually finished, because everyone knows that Chongzhen died in front of Li Zicheng, not at the hands of Manchu Tatars ~ ~ See the history of the Ming Dynasty in more detail.