Why is Li Zicheng controversial?

Why did Li Zicheng cause controversy

Why wasn't Li Zicheng the first champion in history? Why the mysterious plan of Meridian Valley has always been controversial.

Li Zicheng was the second king, and the first king was Gao Yingxiang. He was ambushed by Sun Chuanting on the Meridian Road, and was completely annihilated. He was taken to Beijing to be executed in Lingchi (yes, the Meridian Road was the route that Wei Yan gave Zhuge Liang to surprise Chang 'an). Li Zicheng didn't claim to be a champion, but he was always a champion before he was called the Grand Marshal of Fengtian, which was caused by the fact that the title of a champion was not loud enough for Henan people.

The background is that Cao Pi just died, and Sun Liu conspired to attack Cao Wei. Wei Yan's trip to Tongguan in Chang 'an at noon will shock Cao Wei's turbulent ruling and opposition.

the political impact of seizing the old capital is immeasurable. Third, cutting off the connection and supply between Cao Wei's Kansai and Kanto is likely to make the whole Longyou pass (Wuhou was able to surrender the three counties when he attacked Longyou, which shows that Cao Wei's dominance in Liangzhou is low). Fourth, Wei Yan felt that as long as Chang' an and Tongguan were captured, it would be enough to stop the reinforcements of Kanto with this easy-to-defend and difficult-to-attack Xiongguan.

when the marquis of Wu said that attacking Longyou was a foolproof strategy, he was unwilling to make a coup. When the results have been explained, Wuhou's eye for people is far worse than that of his predecessor. Wei Yan's plan is just to mention it. What if he takes thousands of people to raid Chang 'an? How to resist the next counterattack? Is it true that hundreds of thousands of Wei troops are vegetarians? Those people repeatedly talk about the meridian valley, just trying to prove Zhuge Liang's dishes and then spray Zhuge Liang.

The historical environment at the end of Ming Dynasty and the Three Kingdoms at the end of Han Dynasty can be mentioned in the same breath, and the fantastic plan of Ziwu Valley only existed in the Northern Expedition of Ji and Han Dynasties.

Has the strange plan been recorded in the official history by historians, or is it a strange plan? Wei Yan was the satrap of Hanzhong for nine years, and he deployed the method of "Re-guarding the Gate" to protect the northern gate of Jihan for decades. Even after his ruin, his successors still used his defense system. Do you really think that you can be smarter and understand the situation better than Wei Yan who guarded Hanzhong for nine years and prepared for the Northern Expedition for nine years?

If Wei Yan is standing on the watchtower, you are basically hiding at the bottom of the well. It is estimated that the Ziwu Valley is regarded as a village, and Chang 'an is casually hit and hit. But as I said, there's only a slim chance of the Meridian Valley. Do you really think you can be smarter and understand the situation better than Zhuge Liang? This plan is not good at all. If Wei Yan was put forward, Zhuge Liang was the one who didn't.

Military affairs is an extension of politics, instead of taking some military technological innovation, military fortress or some tactical possibility as the ultimate principle, burning, killing, looting and running. In the future, Wei will divide his forces to defend, and the capture of Chang 'an Wei Jun will definitely lead to chaos. At that time, Wei Yan only needs to hold on for a while and rely on Zhuge Liang to lead the real main army to attack from the front. In fact, Wei Yan also knew that this scheme was unreliable, but at that time, Shu was the weakest and Wei was the strongest, so it was too difficult to fight, so he put forward the Ziwu Valley trick.

The commander of Chang 'an at that time was really a very incompetent and timid person, so Wei Yan suggested this possible tactic. However, even if Chang 'an was captured, it would not be able to withstand Wei Jun's counterattack. Zhuge Liang's support had to come around Tianshui, and there was no time to support it. The most important thing is that Zhuge Liang's strategy at that time was to capture Gansu's generation and get war horses. Otherwise, it would be difficult to compete with butch on the plains.

Wei Yan is naturally inferior to the Prime Minister in the overall view, so I don't think that the mysterious plan of the Meridian Valley will definitely succeed. Moreover, the records of Wei Yan's biography of the Three Kingdoms and Wei Lue are different, and the specific details of Wei Yan's strategy are actually unknown. It is of little significance to discuss the possibility of realization. The Prime Minister's failure to adopt it does not mean that the mysterious plan of the Meridian Valley is worthless like some people, otherwise it will not entrust Wei Yan with an important task even when Cao Zhen is in danger of cutting Shu.

Moreover, the Ziwu Valley Trail is a difficult mountain road. The Shu army can't bring heavy equipment and little food. Whether it can capture Chang 'an depends not on the bravery of the Shu army, but on whether Wei will abandon the city. Reply @ 京京京京京 Zuo Changxiu: Wei Yan never said that the Meridian Valley is a strange plot, which was pulled by Wei slightly. The Three Kingdoms originally meant to go hand in hand in two ways.

Meeting in Tongguan, without mentioning the Meridian Valley. There is a paradox, if it will be very weak, won't it be more defensive? He's incompetent. Does he still like to fight with others? If he is strong, how can Wei Yan hit it? Many people like to brag about what Wei Yan is. Isn't Hanzhong a general guarding Hanzhong?

it's like flooding the seventh army. Guan Yu didn't have the ability to lay down Xiangfan. Wei Yan led 5, military horses and didn't leave a backward road. The other side had the support of the whole country. This ingenious idea actually didn't exist. At the same time, Cao Wei also wanted to take this road to the Northern Expedition, which already proved that the ingenious idea of gastritis had long gone bankrupt. Actually, Zhuge Liang had already anticipated the attack on Wargo. The problem was that the building would dump everyone against thieves.

So people removed that man, and it is impossible for him to succeed. The ingenious plan of Meridian Valley has always been controversial, and this ingenious plan came from Wei Lue.

That is, Wei Lue was written by Wei people. Why did Wei people know so clearly about the ingenious plan that Shu Han had never implemented? Moreover, Wei Lue himself used the rumors of Wei at that time. Now most people think this statement is not credible. Although the plan is strange, they don't consider whether the Prime Minister can keep up with it quickly. Besides, thousands of people simply can't support Wei Jun's counterattack in Chang 'an. If they can't wait for the Prime Minister, Wei Yan will die.

Cao Zhen said that whoever walks in the Meridian Valley is a fool, or Wei Yan can fly, otherwise it will waste time like Cao Zhen, or worse, it will be as cold as Cao Zhen. The success of the plan to sneak attack on Chang 'an is not how magical your plan is, but that Wei's defenders should abandon the city and flee. You really don't treat the other side as a person. At that time, what strength did Ji Han have, and what strength did Cao Wei have? Zhuge Liang was able to make Cao Wei defend with all his strength. Okay.

Besides, let's not talk about whether Wei Yan can take Chang 'an by pure infantry. Even if he does, what will he defend? Anyone who has seen the map at that time will not think that Wei Yan can hold on to it, and Zhuge Liang is even more afraid to meet Wei Yan directly, because Zhuge Liang must first lay a cold front, or he will be cut off. The nearest big city to Chang 'an is Luoyang, which is less than 4 kilometers apart. Luoyang is the capital of Cao Wei. Guess what the strength of Cao Wei will be?

does Zhuge Liang dare to go directly to Chang' an with his main force? When the time comes, they will be locked up in Chang 'an, Bao jiaozi, and the Three Kingdoms will end here directly? Sun Quan1, people can't take Hefei without logistics, and thousands of you don't have heavy armor and heavy axes. There is no subsidy, no support, no small town mutual assistance, and there is still a line, not a trace.

the loyalty of the noble people in Guanzhong is not the same as that of the noble people in Northwest China, not to mention how 5 people can fight Chang 'an.

Wei Yan's Ziwu Valley will persist until Zhuge has digested the northwest. The problem is that Cao Wei can transfer troops from other places, so how can he defend it? Wei Yan is a joke unless the Guanzhong Haozu also voted for Shu as much as the Northwest Haozu at that time. The question is, will the Guanzhong Haozu still vote for Shu after the Jiupin Zhengzhi system?