If Wen Jian in the Ming Dynasty didn't behead the princes, wouldn't Judy rebel?

As long as Emperor Wen Jian does not die, Judy has no possibility of rebellion and chips.

Even if he is not angry and thinks that his eldest brother Zhu Biao is dead, it is useless for him to give up the throne to himself, a man who has made great achievements in the army. Because anger belongs to anger, injustice belongs to injustice, and resentment belongs to resentment, he dare not rashly do it even if he dares to think. Dare to think because his personal ability is really outstanding, dare not do or should not do it, because the world is not a person can be immune, and public opinion is not a person's will can be changed. If he can't even see this, but just shows courage, then he must win the world. This means that Judy is just a brave champion of the three armies, and Lu Bu is just one of them. He is typically short of wisdom and knowledge. And such people are simply not enough for Jianwen Emperor, so there is no need for any cutting.

And just because of outstanding military exploits, I want to support the army to rebel, and I can't do this. I don't have to look back at the rebellion of the Seven Kingdoms in the Western Han Dynasty or the rebellion of the Eight Kings in the Western Jin Dynasty. Even more than twenty years after his death, his son Zhu rose to revolt. As a result, he was crushed twice Equally young and promising, outstanding in military exploits and extraordinary in ability; As the eldest brother, he died young, and his sons and nephews succeeded to the throne, angry and ill-intentioned. Judy is in her forties and her son is in his early forties. Both of them also went out with their father and were highly valued. Combat capability is tempered and tested in war. The former and Zhu Yuanzhang were under siege, chasing death and journey to the south, while the latter fought side by side with Judy, overcoming many difficulties and winning the crown of the three armed forces. They all have high prestige in the military and outstanding personal ability. They only said that they attacked the city and plundered the land, persevered and took the head of the enemy generals in the chaotic army. I dare not say that no one can beat me in this world, but I will never be willing to be my enemy.

But the outcome of the rebellion was completely different, not because Zhu was not as good as his father, nor because he planned it so well. No one rebelled for fun, but they all thought about it in advance and were ready. Even Zhu was much earlier than prepared. Zhu actually has much better resources than his father. Don't forget, when Zhu Dijing was trapped in the mouth of Jinling Baozi, Zhu arrived in time. However, Judy caressed his back and said, Work hard. The prince is ill. This is not a hint at all. This is a clear message to him. If your brother dies, you are a prince.

Personally, I think Judy's heart has always been unfair to him, and there are personal emotions in it. So he must have had the idea of disrespecting the new emperor because of resentment, and even made a move beyond etiquette. But on this basis, it is said that he planned rebellion, which will be chaotic for a long time. What's the difference between this and those Confucian ministers who advised Wen Jian to reduce Buddhism, but later could not count on any counter-rebellion? It is also for this reason that in fact, when Zhu emerged, it was more likely that someone responded, whether it was inside or outside the palace or the imperial military camp. After all, at that time, there were many people who made contributions and held real power because of Jing Nan, and these people, in a sense, compared with the relationship between Ming Xuanzong and Zhu Zhanji. They are closer to Zhu in interests, hobbies, past experiences and personal friendship. With Zhu Di-jing's experience of titles, it is obvious that they are more likely to accept and follow this kind of infighting of the Zhu family and then use their servants. In fact, even his father, Emperor Renzong, was under great pressure in the face of Zhu, who had followed his father all the year round and made outstanding achievements. He can only comfort and prevent, and it is difficult to destroy the grass quickly and thoroughly at a time.

During his stay in southern Beijing, he mainly stayed in Beijing, so his relationship with the advisers and generals he followed was inevitably not as familiar as Zhu's. Sometimes men just push the cup for a change and have the connection and convergence of interests. Therefore, even if he becomes famous and starts a business, Zhu has more advantages than his father, not to mention other available resources.

But the father and son are so similar to each other, why did a Jingnan force the new emperor to die and rule the world? One was defeated when he got up, surrendered and died, and was killed? If Zhu Diqiang and his son are weak, then Judy went from August of the first year of Wenjian 1399 to July of the fourth year of Wenjian 1402, which lasted for four years, from the periphery of Beijing to Shanhaiguan in Liaodong, and then to Datong in Shanxi, Baoding in Hebei and Jinan in Shandong. Strictly speaking, it lasted until the first three years of 1402. It was not until 1402 that Judy changed her strategic goal that she stopped the Northern War and decided to go all the way south, go straight to Huanglong and attack Nanjing. After that, he crossed the Yellow River without hesitation, entered Xuzhou, attacked Suzhou, occupied Huai 'an, won Yangzhou, crossed the Yangtze River from Guazhou Ferry, entered Zhenjiang, and arrived at the gates of Nanjing. In the process of going south, Judy basically marched quickly in a short time and attacked all the way, without hesitation and regardless of the consequences. In most cases, the city is strong and the pool is deep, and the tenacious resistance will give up and continue to go south. If you are weak in fighting will, you can concentrate on supplying what you can easily occupy, and then leave again without nostalgia. Therefore, it took only six months to achieve the strategic goal, approaching Nanjing and shocking the young and ignorant Emperor Jianwen. In these four years, Judy was defeated by Wen Jian's army almost many times, and suffered heavy losses, hovering between life and death several times. Even in April of his fourth year, it was less than 100 days before the end of the entire Jingnan campaign. Today, in Qimeishan, near Lingbi on the north bank of Huaihe River, Judy's army is still defeated by his army, and his department has won a great victory. At the same time, due to the summer heat, Judy's troops are in a dilemma. Yan asked to return to the north and choose a place to rest. Judy disagreed and said, "Those who want to cross the river are left, and those who don't want to cross the river are right." Most people stood on the left, and Judy was very annoyed to see such a soldier, because it showed that most people didn't want to fight anymore, but wanted to go back. The war has been going on for nearly four years. In fact, Judy's troops took advantage of Li Jinglong's magical operation from the beginning, and they have been struggling ever since. It is very hard to compete with a corner of Peiping for the garrison and logistical support of the whole country, which is almost a desperate afterlife, and this afterlife is so difficult and dangerous. The military commanders under Emperor Wen Jian were not defeated stragglers, nor were they the old, the weak and the sick. In fact, there are Sheng Yong, Tie Xuan, Guo Ying, Wu Jie, Qu Neng and his son, and Xu Huizu, the eldest son of general Xu Da in the early Ming Dynasty. Are strategists who have retired well. Which of these people Judy met was kicking the steel plate. In fact, when Judy faced these people's stationed areas, they were not worth the loss, especially Sheng Yong's stationed in Shandong, which was Judy's nemesis. Later, Judy gave up attacking Shandong directly, bypassed Jinan and went straight to Xuzhou, and went south to attack Nanjing.

Judy's forced death is not unrelated to his personal military ability, but more caused by his nephew and his Confucian scholars who advised him to cut Tibet. The process of Judy going south is simply a process of picking up mistakes and fighting for luck. If you carefully look at the history of the Jingnan War, you will cry for the stupidity of Emperor Wen Jian and the incompetence of those Confucian scholars. How can there be such a big fool in this world to hand over a great country so easily?

Here you can briefly describe how Emperor Wen Jian lost his country. After Judy was forced to rebel, there were actually no soldiers in his hands. On the contrary, he quickly seized control of the city, while the envoys of Emperor Jianwen who stayed in Beijing were not ready to be cheated and killed. Later, he led the army to counter-insurgency and sent Geng Bingwen, a veteran with Zhu Yuanzhang, who was already in his sixties. Geng Bingwen was repelled by Judy, but the troops were not damaged. He really retreated to the city and could not hold on. When Judy couldn't capture the city, he withdrew and left. But this is where his magical operation began. First he got cold feet, and then he was replaced by General Li Jinglong. Li Jinglong is his cousin. Who recommended this person? Huang Zicheng, a Confucian scholar, worked with Qi Tai to plan for Emperor Jianwen, and then you can see how unreliable the Confucian scholar's opinion is. Under the wise leadership of Li Jinglong, hundreds of thousands of troops sent by Emperor Jianwen for counterinsurgency were completely annihilated, and all kinds of purple heavy artillery weapons and horses were discarded, and they also entered Texas and got a lot of hay. When Judy ran to Daning to lure the relieving of Wang Ning, Li Jinglong led the troops into Beijing, and Qu Neng, the commander-in-chief, led thousands of fine riders to attack Zhangye Gate, but because of lack of backup, he could only stop attacking. Li Jinglong, who was greedy for work, asked Qu and other big troops to attack together, delaying the fighter plane and turning the rebellion that should have ended quickly into a protracted and arduous task. Li Jinglong failed to end the war as soon as possible because of his improper command, greedy for merits and mistaken for the army, which resulted in the serious consequences of the final rout of hundreds of thousands of troops, and should take full responsibility. Huang Zicheng, who strongly recommended Li Jinglong, and others also asked Xie Sanjun to kill Li Jinglong, but that was his cousin, and he could not bear to part with it, and then it went away. Personally, I think that if I were Huang Zicheng, I should make a recommendation for myself, but it is difficult for a scholar to have the courage to commit suicide, especially a Confucian scholar who only talks about military affairs. Therefore, Emperor Wen Jian's indecision, good Confucianism, loneliness and weakness were vividly demonstrated here. Should he kill or not, should he stay or not. Hundreds of thousands of troops are not distressed without it, but he is reluctant to kill two guilty ministers. Such people really deserve to lose the world.

In the subsequent war, his personal performance as a loser was even more staggering. Even in the heat of the war, he announced that he was ordered not to hurt his uncle Judy when his troops attacked. As a result, because of the fear of post-war liquidation, the troops didn't dare to let go. Even Judy's handsome flag was shot as a hedgehog, but Judy swaggered through the disorderly army unscathed. Finally, when Judy's army was defeated, Judy even dared to ride behind the house alone, because of this Zhao Ming. It is really ridiculous that the war has reached this point. But even the emperor of Nanjing and his Confucian scholars have been absurd to this extent. Soldiers stationed in the local and front lines are still doing their best to curb Judy's ambition and the pace of attack.

It's really helpless not to allow his uncle to get hurt alone. When he forced the Bai Zhu family to die, why didn't he remember that it was his uncle? According to historical records, in April of the first year (1399), the imperial court cut off three princes, Qi, Xiang and Dai, which were abolished. Bai Zhu, the king of Hunan, was humiliated and set himself on fire for Glory Day. Zhu Chu, King of Qi, was placed under house arrest in Nanjing. Zhu Gui, the acting king, was placed under house arrest in Datong, a fief. Two months later, the Ming court cut off Zhu Kun, the king of Fujian, abandoned him as Shu Ren and moved to Zhangzhou. I don't feel guilty for killing so many innocent uncles. Speaking of opposing you, I'm going to cut you to pieces, dig your father's grave and dig your grandmother's ancestral grave. Here you begin to be merciful, don't want to bear the blame, and let me have the name of killing my uncle without asking for anything in return. When King Xiang made up his mind to jump into the fire on a white horse and set himself on fire, the sentence that Emperor Wen Jian didn't give me the name of killing my uncle had already become a joke in advance. And Wang Xiang smiled back before entering the fire, as if satirizing his hypocrisy and cowardice, and he would bring about his own destruction sooner or later. Later, Emperor Wen Jian also set himself on fire by burning a temple and disappeared into the fog of history.

Even after Li Jinglong was removed from office, Judy did not completely eliminate corruption. Instead, he fell into the anxiety of repeated defeats and wars, and almost died at the hands of his own troops several times. It is also common to lose troops and be powerless. The war-weariness of soldiers and their families has gradually become superficial with the passage of time. From Beijing to Shanxi, Hebei, Shandong and Henan, until the Jianghuai area, Judy's battle of Jingnan was a bleak process of continuous attack and frustration and continuous survival. For his side, although the situation is not good, it has never been worse, so the emperors and Confucian scholars in Nanjing can still talk about enjoying peace there. The brutal fighting in the north didn't affect the beauty of Jinling City at all.

But Judy's side is different. The war was a matter of life and death in the end, so although Judy was depressed, she never gave up. It is not that he doesn't want to, but that he can't. Rebellion is a matter of physical death and extinction. Wen Jian was mean and ungrateful, and showed no mercy to his people. Surrender is definitely a dead end. Continue to struggle, no matter how hard it is, there will be opportunities. This is Judy's motivation to persist in the four-year Jingnan War. It is not that he has outstanding military ability and is full of confidence. In the protracted battle, Judy's advantage in personal combat ability has almost been exhausted, and the initial indignation and impulse should have disappeared long ago. He had no choice then, and he has no choice now. Can only crustily skin of head to go on, want to cry without tears, the tragic situation of a strong man's broken wrist, it is estimated that Judy is sighing and crying in her dream. At that time, King Ning was also a good soldier in Mazhuang, and his personal ingenuity was outstanding, but he never ran counter to it. It is estimated that he is also smart enough to realize that if it were not for God's help, this rebellion under the general trend would be impossible.

As for why Judy still entered Nanjing and forced him to death, on the one hand, he changed his strategy and began to give up the struggle in the north, directly attacking the Jianghuai area and taking Huanglong. On the one hand, this young man in his early twenties is really incompetent, and those Confucian scholars under him are even more wrong about the country and the people. Even though Sheng Yong, Tie Xuan, Xu Huizu and others fought to the death in the front, even Qu Neng and his son died in battle and failed to save his world. It can even be said that in these four years of fighting, Judy's persistence is greater than his ability, and his most important contribution should be his own assists. As for Fang Xiaoru and other Confucian scholars, they can only use "Hehe" to express their sarcasm. Everyone can say good things, but it's disgusting to pretend to be dead if you can't rejuvenate the country and benefit the people.

In the four years of Jingnan, the war in the north continued, and many people died. The soldiers of the Quartet struggled to fight Margo and wrapped his body, causing numerous casualties. Which of these people died less heroically than you boastful Confucian scholars, but future generations will remember that it was these useless waste people who neglected the affairs of state, but none of the heroes buried in the ground and the innocent people in Qian Qian remembered. Don't say Judy tried to kill them in order to consolidate the throne and vent her anger, killing nine families and ten households. It was Qu Neng and his son who figured it out underground. If they don't cut these people to pieces, they will feel sorry for the injustice they suffered when they finally died after years of hard work.

So if we don't cut the vassal, there will probably be a rebellion, but not necessarily Judy. It depends on the necessity and the possibility of success. You can't always use conspiracy theories to assume how things will happen. Many things are not necessarily inevitable in themselves, but are forced by the situation, or will be better. As far as Judy's difficult process is concerned, we know that Judy was lucky enough to meet a doll emperor who grew up in a deep palace and was not frustrated. Therefore, we can still seize the throne under the circumstances of being besieged on all sides and struggling. His son Zhu planned for a longer time than he did. From the years when Judy became emperor, he had an idea, and it was not until Judy died that it began to cause a sensation. A year later, his eldest brother, Zhu Gaochi, had just died. Once his nephew succeeded to the throne, he would immediately rise up and resist. Unfortunately, he met Zhu Zhanji, a successor who grew up with his grandfather Judy and was specially trained by Judy, not only because of his martial arts, but also because of his psychological quality and strategic vision. The anti-creation of people like Zhu is simply suicidal and has no chance of winning. So with a wave of his hand, Zhu Daqi took the arrow stone and led the army to the gate. Such a fearless and confident king is not stupid enough to rebel, not to mention Zhu, who is not only unlucky, but also inferior in ability. Sure enough, it was destroyed in an instant, and finally I committed suicide in the jar.

As for the forces of the captaincy at that time, I personally think that Wang Ning's soldiers were better than Judy's. Zhu Quan, the king of Ning, has 80,000 armored soldiers and 6,000 chariots. The cavalry of Duo Yan Sanwei are all brave and good at fighting. Zhu Quan fought against the Wang Huishi Fortress many times, and was famous for his good strategy. It can be said that young and promising, both wise and brave. He is a little younger than Zhu Yunwen. In the late Qing Dynasty, Cai Dongfan called him a prince who was good at fighting and good at planning. It shows that everyone thinks Judy is second to none in attacking the city and plundering the land, but it is obviously better to win the battle with proper strategy. Personally, I think that even if there is rebellion against the captaincy, it should be done by a young man with foresight like Wang Ning, not a middle-aged man in his late forties like Judy. Judy's objection was largely due to his inner injustice, but the situation at that time just gave him the illusion that he had to do it, so he went forward and did what he wanted to do but shouldn't. It doesn't mean that he will rebel when he comes to power. If Wen Jian is wise and decisive enough, he will soon order Wang Ning to lead an army to attack Peking. With Wang Ning's ingenuity, holding a good soldier, and a number of Yan Sanwei who are good at riding and shooting, even if they confront Judy head-on, they may not be able to annihilate in one fell swoop. However, it is more than enough to trap Judy and wait for him to send veteran soldiers such as Geng Bingwen to camp.

Wang Ning never took the initiative to participate in Judy's rebellion from beginning to end, but was deceived and held hostage by Judy to participate in this imperial clan struggle that should not have happened. Judy took Daning as the first step to cheat Wang Ning's military power because he understood his own shortcomings and sought foreign aid. This also shows that the combat effectiveness of Wang Ning's troops is not inferior to that of Judy's troops stationed in Yanjing and his subordinates. When Judy rose, there were also prisoners who responded to Judy. For example, Zhu Gui, the acting king stationed in Datong, thought of soldiers. As a result, he was controlled by Datong general Chen Zhi. After Chen Zhi, he recovered the city that belonged to the prince. Later, Chen Zhi was killed by Judy after he succeeded to the throne. According to historical records, the king has to raise soldiers, swallow them, and hold them, but he can't send them. Yuzhou and Guangchang are attached to Yan, and the quality is recovered. Cheng Zu acceded to the throne, replaced the king with the hostage-taking system, and died by seizing possession. This also shows that Judy's army is not invincible in many places. In fact, only Yanjing, which was originally under the jurisdiction of the prince, fell with the wind and quickly attached itself. This is the area under the jurisdiction of his own subordinate officials. Out of Beijing, attacking Zhangjiakou in the north, Baoding in the south and Jinan in the east are all arduous battles. For example, when attacking Jinan, he kicked the steel plate like Sheng Yong and Tie Xuan. As a result, Judy has not been to Jinan for four years. It was not until the fall of the emperor that Sheng surrendered, and soon he hanged himself and died. Judy's troops in other areas are also difficult to conquer and occupy quickly, so it is difficult to make achievements in the first few years of Judy's four-year struggle. It was not until the last six months that I decided to send troops south to match Jinling. And then it worked magically. Here, a small red flower was given to Jedi Knight Li Jinglong. As soon as Trudy rode into Beijing, he immediately opened the door and surrendered. His head was buzzing with anger. However, the goods did not come to a good end and soon died of depression.

Therefore, if Emperor Wen Jian of the Ming Dynasty didn't cut back on Buddhism, wouldn't Judy rebel? It can't be said that no one will rebel, but in the short term, no one will be stupid enough to rebel. As far as Judy is concerned, as long as he is not carried away by ambition, there is no reason to rebel.

First of all, Judy is not the heaviest and strongest of the princes, at least not the only one with a strong soldier. On the one hand, Zhu Quan, the king of Ning in Daning, is under the jurisdiction of East Liaoning, West Fu Xuan and North Yao Zhen. He controlled 90 cities, with 80,000 pieces of armor and 6,000 leather wagons. Zhu Hu is brave and good at fighting on horseback. He is wise and profound, and he is elegant. After several meetings, the kings of the border town set out to capture Lu, eliminate the desert and threaten the town of Kitano. Having such a powerful and wise person on its side is absolutely enough to curb ambitious Judy. In fact, according to the system designed by Zhu Yuanzhang, the family system composed of emperor, vassal, consorts and Ma Xu, under the joint action of power, etiquette and affection, should be able to firmly support the Ming Dynasty. However, the weak nephew emperor and the scholars around him failed to master the method of restricting the unruly uncle king, and the system originally designed by Zhu Yuanzhang eventually led to great disaster.

Therefore, Wen Jian's personal ignorance and the incompetence of the Confucian scholars around him are the direct reasons for Judy's success. Zhu Yuanzhang once worried about Zhu Yunwen and considered making Judy a prince. It is recorded in the History of Ming Dynasty that after the death of the Crown Prince in the twenty-fifth year of Hongwu in Ming Taizu, Zhu Yuanzhang called a group of ministers in Donggemen to discuss the establishment of the Crown Prince, saying, "The Prince of Yan is as brave as me, so what is his status?" At that time, most royal kings had a large number of troops, especially Judy, the prince of Yan, who "controlled horses on the border" ... gained great reputation "and stayed on the throne for a long time. No one dares to say anything more about this important matter. At this time, Liu Sanwu stood up and remonstrated and said, "The grandson of the emperor is rich, the son of the official position in the world, and the son of Sun Cheng, who died, is suitable for the ceremony." That is to say, where is the prince and the second king of Qin Jin? "Zhu Yuanzhang after listen to don't answer, burst into tears. Later, the son of Prince Yi was awarded the title of the great-grandson of the emperor. Liu Sanwu's "ambition" was too great, and he was once again reduced from a bachelor's degree in Hanlin to Dr. imperial academy. Zhu Yuanzhang was also very helpless. If he doesn't hit Zhu Yunwen, he won't give up in his heart. If he does this, he will be afraid of disaster. But many things are difficult to do, and often, no matter how you choose, you can't be perfect.

Secondly, it is not easy for Judy to fight so hard and see the rebellion. If it weren't for luck, he might have been beheaded by Qu Neng and his son as early as six months ago. At least Zhu Gaochi and other Judy family officials in Beijing will be captured. After that, there will be a high probability of mutiny, and then Judy will be tied up in the capital or spread around the world to warn the world.

Third, the world is the beginning, and the will of the people is peace and stability. If you do something, it must be against the people's will, and you will be attacked by groups. Moreover, the world is at peace, and there are not a few people who hope to gain honor and meritorious service quickly through military service. A single warlord rising to revolt is simply a sheep entering the tiger's mouth and will be torn to pieces. Even if you are a soldier like Judy, you will die sooner or later, and it will not be too late. The situation does not allow, and manpower is difficult. In this way, if we don't chop down the peasants, at least we don't worry about chopping them down, there will certainly be no rebellion by the captaincy. Wen Jian is still young, and has been waiting for 20 years, making good relations with Wang Jianli, a clever Francisco like Wang Ning, and curbing the ambitious Francisco like Rebecca. The family and Meimei passed a generation first, and when people like Zhu succeeded to the throne, even if they wanted to send troops, it would be difficult to achieve great things. At that time, I was honest, mature, sensitive and cautious, and said that it was no joke to press these young people.

It has been criticized by later generations for being too hasty, too cruel and too unrealistic. Rather than whether or not to cut Tibet, I think Zhu Yuanzhang has long believed that cutting Tibet must be cut, but Wen Jian must not be cut. It is more urgent to prevent the powerful ministers from guarding the clan, stabilize the people's hearts and consolidate the rivers and mountains than to clear the land of the vassal king. But Wen Jian didn't understand grandpa's meaning, and the Confucian scholars around him were too noisy, so young people were easily influenced by their thoughts and did something unrealistic and out of line. Not to mention a little emperor trained in a deep palace, that is, when we were about twenty years old, ordinary people still had overly idealistic things to do for love and loyalty. At his age, Emperor Wen Jian's impulse is understandable as a young and ignorant ordinary person, but as an emperor, he is bound to pay the price for his reckless behavior. This history has given the answer for future generations to comment on.

It just backfired. Let's give it up for future generations.