In Leonardo's Shutter Island, it's just a gesture to write "run" and drink water. Who can explain the plot?

When the bt resources of Shutter Island-to Shutter Island, a friend who doesn't understand, were compressed in March 18, many people were downloading and watching this thriller starring Leonardo as soon as possible, but it hasn't made the American list yet. With the feeling of plot, online film critics began to talk about the film. I wanted to find a very literary article about the accident, but I found that there were still people arguing about the plot on the Internet. What are they arguing about? Because some people think that Ted, the protagonist of this movie, is not mentally ill. They think the story is written like this: Story 1: It is a thriller full of conspiracy, and Teddy explores step by step with a strong and persistent agent image. The climax of the story takes place in the questioning of that profound question: When all rational analysis and evidence drive you crazy, do you trust your own memory or the evidence of "reality"? What is memory? Should we rely on our own memories to judge the evidence? Story 2: It is a story full of compassion and warmth. The deep love for his wife and the cruel fact of killing his wife made Ted struggle between illusion and reality. The beauty of the second story lies in the deep analysis and expression of Ted's heart with carefully designed dreams, and the interpretation of Freud's theories on defense mechanism, dreams, hallucinations and trauma.

Here, I want to tell those friends who think it is the first story. You may only have a superficial understanding of movies. Think of yourself as a friend of story one. Maybe you just like watching movies, or maybe you don't know much about the history of movies, the cultures of various countries, and the movies contained in them. Friends who think that story one is a story always think that their reasoning is strong and they can understand movies. Maybe you think that a good suspense movie can only be inferred by your "smart mind", so please read the following details for those who don't know: the protagonist Ted is actually a mental derangement. His wife killed the child because of depression, and he killed his wife. But I can't accept that he has been immersed in his own illusory world. In order to make him accept the facts, all the doctors and nurses accompanied him in a play, playing the role of his imaginary world, in order to let him discover himself, accept the facts and return to the real world. His companion is actually his attending doctor. In the past nine months, he has been wandering repeatedly between reality and fantasy. Every time he got better, he returned to his imaginary world after a night. Let's take a look at the plot again. I believe it can completely solve your problem: 1. When the protagonist disembarked from the ship, the prison guards around him stood guard with guns, and the protagonist frowned in confusion-because the prison guards all knew that this guy was a dangerous mental illness, his assistant was his attending physician, and the prison guards only pretended to meet him in order to cooperate with his treatment, but they were very wary of him, so they looked at him with unfriendly eyes.

When the protagonist walked into the manor from the dock, many patients who were sweeping the floor and pruning the garden greeted him. The protagonist's eyes are strange-because those people are his patients and have seen him many times, but the protagonist thinks it is the first time to see him. When the protagonist asked about the case, the staff was completely absent-minded and a woman was filing her nails. A doctor said that when Mrs. Rachel complained about the food, she was still smiling. Instead, Dean Cowley carefully recorded Ted's illness.

4. When the protagonist asked the old lady, the old lady avoided her partner and wrote "Run" in her notebook-the protagonist didn't know that he was a patient on the island because he had been addicted to fantasy, but all the onlookers knew that the protagonist's partner was his attending physician, so I hope the protagonist will run quickly and stop playing real-life cosplay. Note that when the power system was down, it was Chuck who suggested that the protagonist visit Ward C. If Chuck wanted to frame him, he wouldn't suggest the protagonist go to Ward C, because then the protagonist might know Shutter Island better. So the reason why Chuck suggested the protagonist go is to let him meet George Noyce and help him get to know himself again. 6. the neurotic strong man coming out of area c should be a policeman with better acting skills. Note that he deliberately led the protagonist closer to George Noyce. 7. Dr. Cowley does not advocate lobotomy to treat mental illness, but advocates that the treatment of mental patients should respect them and let them find their own problems. So after a series of events, when the protagonist's partner and attending doctor Dr. Cowley asked him questions, they just wanted to know whether the protagonist had woken up from his fantasy. Tell him that there was a breakthrough in their treatment nine months ago-it means that the protagonist's illness has recurred. He woke up once nine months ago, but later he returned to fantasy. The doctors had to accompany the protagonist to play the detective game again, so that the protagonist could find himself again.

Finally, when the protagonist woke up the next morning, he was sitting on the stone steps, thinking deeply. When his attending doctor came over and handed him a cigarette, the protagonist shouted "Chuck", which is the name of the attending doctor who pretended to be his partner. The doctor realized that the protagonist had returned to his fantasy after a night, and all his efforts were in vain, so he had to shake his head to Dr. Cowley and the warden in the distance. They learned yesterday that the protagonist woke up. Looks like Cowley's self-discovery therapy worked. They plan to take the protagonist to the board of directors off the island to show them the evidence that therapy can also cure mental patients. But when they shook their heads, they were also depressed. They know that this evidence cannot be displayed because it has returned to a state of mind.

9. At this moment, several workers dressed in white came over. The white cloth in the close-up contains metal objects such as awls, which means that the protagonist will be removed because of the failure of self-discovery therapy. 10. In the background of the film, there is a place in Shutter Island where the authorities hold the mentally ill, and there is no need for people in Shutter Island to plot against the so-called detective to make him lose his memory, which undoubtedly proves that the protagonist Ted is really mentally ill. 1 1. In the middle of the movie, Ted, the protagonist, has recalled his experience of participating in World War II many times, and sometimes the horror scene of the massacre in the concentration camp of World War II appears in his mind. To be sure, the protagonist Ted did participate in World War II before, and the shadow of World War II had a deep influence on him, which was inseparable from the cause of his amnesia and psychosis.

12. The last sentence of the protagonist: "It is better to die like a good man than to live like a devil." His doctor's words tell us that the protagonist is actually completely awake this time. But I can't face the cruel reality that my wife killed three children and my beloved wife. I would rather have an operation to forget the painful reality than be tortured by the spirit every day. So the protagonist pretends to return to fantasy, and then goes to surgery to destroy the corresponding nerves and forget the past. This is the explanation of the most heated part in the cave: the part in the cave is really a bit difficult to explain.

But there are two explanations:

First, I think Rachel in the cave is actually the protagonist's fantasy, because after the protagonist broke up with Chuck, he began to hallucinate. First, Chuck's body was under the cliff. When he went down, he didn't find the body. Secondly, there are many mice, which are actually the illusion of the protagonist. Then it was dark when I entered the cave, and a fire rose in the cave. This is a short time, suggesting that this Rachel is also imaginary. Besides, how did Rachel live in the cave? What do you do for a living?

Here is a detail: 1. Rachel didn't wear shoes when the protagonist entered the cave, but Rachel wore shoes the next day. The second is: (this truth should be very shallow, of course, considering what Rachel lives on) This Rachel is not imaginary. It's Rachel, a patient in a mental hospital (Rachel in the hospital is played by a nurse). The real Rachel can't recover from schizophrenia, so according to the regulations of building a mental hospital in Shutter Island, she must have an operation. Rachel is afraid that she will only run away. The hospital is really looking for Rachel. At this time, the hospital is also treating the protagonist, and the hospital just uses this to help the protagonist treat.

Here's another detail: the protagonist asks Rachel what happened at the lighthouse. Rachel panicked at that time, and then said it was brain surgery, just like the Nazis, and that they were doing something. It implies that he is actually a patient and is very afraid of surgery, so he made up a terrible story about the hospital. The story is actually very simple: Ted is number 67. In fact, (Leonardo) plays (Ted Daniel), and Bunsen is a patient on that island. In fact, his real name is arsonist Andrew Ladis (of course, he was a general in World War II before he went crazy). Andrew, played by Leonardo DiCaprio, suffered a psychological breakdown after the massacre in the war. After returning home, because the social reconstruction after World War II was not so bright, and Ted and his family had a great influence, because Ted's mind often flashed terrible pictures of World War II concentration camps, and so on, Ted drank wine every day to drown his sorrows. More unfortunately, this state of life has seriously affected the relationship between him and his wife, so his wife has a mental problem of hating Ted. As a result, she finally couldn't stand real life. His wife killed three children, and Andrew shot and killed his wife and set fire to the bodies of his wife and children and the house. So under this sad result, Ted was extremely depressed and developed symptoms of amnesia and schizophrenia (only sent to Shutter Island, of course). This film reveals the truth step by step around this split personality. His wife killed the child, and so did his wife. The whole process is not the process of his imprisonment, but the arrangement of his attending doctor (that is, his fake partner) and another attending doctor. In order to make him realize the reality, the attending physician Cowley was actually a very kind person at first, and he was very opposed to using surgery and drug therapy to treat mental patients. The hero actually recovered once and then relapsed. This treatment is his last chance. If we say that all kinds of thrillers and suspense in this film are just a coat, it ultimately reflects human nature (the protagonist's understanding of the war and his wife's attitude towards life) and the pain of the war (because all the tragedies on Teddy are basically the sequelae left by the war).