Is sung river wooing right or wrong?

There are two views on whether Song Jiang's kindness is right or wrong: one is right and the other is wrong.

First of all, about the correct statement.

The wooing route advocated by Song Jiang is undoubtedly the most correct move. He works in the government office, knowing the strength of DaSong and knowing that what his gang did would never be allowed by the court. Now that the border is tight, the army has to resist foreigners and has no leisure to crusade against itself.

Moreover, although his gang was well-known, the court of the Song Dynasty did not attach importance to it. If you continue to look forward to it, the imperial court will send troops to crusade, and then you can resist this puddle. Don't say you beat Gao Qiu, it was just a narrow victory. Gao Qiu is not a man who leads troops to fight, and his failure is understandable.

However, there were not a few generals who were used to fighting in the Song Dynasty. If Zhao's butler is really furious and sends an able man to lead the mountain soldiers, Liangshan Water Pool will be destroyed in an instant.

Sung river harness reason:

1, the first is the food problem. Assuming that each person is half a catty of rice every day, the rice in Dan Liang alone will consume 50,000 jins every day. If we consider daily necessities such as rice, oil, salt, cloth and iron, Liangshan needs it more.

For example, Lu Junyi, Mars and others will be taken up the mountain, and their family assets will also be taken up the mountain; Attacking Zhujiazhuang and other places will also take away their money and food. Zhujiazhuang, in particular, not only distributed food to the local people, but also transported 500 thousand stones of food. In fact, Zhujiazhuang is just a tiny place. How can there be so much money and food? It's just the author's exaggeration, and this exaggeration is just to satisfy Liangshan.

There is also the problem of strength. Although Liangshan has hundreds of thousands of troops and has defeated the imperial army many times, there is still a big gap between Liangshan and the imperial court. Just planting a home army in the northwest, which is forbidden by the court, is enough to deter Liangshan heroes. When recruiting Fang La, the strength gap can be reflected. Liangshan heroes still lost their troops under the condition that the imperial court kept supplies; If we can't guarantee the logistics, we can imagine how miserable the result is. The most important thing is that the court can lose ten times, twenty times, and can afford to lose. It's different when Liangshan heroes lose once. They can't afford to lose.

2. Seeing Zhao 'an from the appeasement of Song Dynasty.

There were many rebels in the Song Dynasty, but pleasing the court was always an important means to appease the court. Of course, even if the strength of Liangshan was unparalleled at that time, there was no need to worry about food and other issues. Song Jiang will still lead all the heroes to win over and work for the court. Because this is not only Song Jiang's personal belief, but also the attitude expressed by the author many times.

In the early years of the Northern Song Dynasty, thieves such as Jiao Si and Jiao Ba near Tokyo often made trouble. Later, Zhao Kuangyin said that as long as they surrendered, they would not only not be killed, but also prosper. After these people surrendered, Zhao Kuangyin didn't break his word. "Give a brocade robe, a silver belt, clothes and money to each one, and make him the Dragon Ambassador." .

3, the hero's point of view to woo.

In fact, from the protagonist's own point of view, wooing is also the only way. Because at least half of the generals in Liangshan 108 were originally generals or officials of the imperial court, Song Jiang dragged them up the mountain and promised to "win over and work for the imperial court in the future". These people want to win over. After all, no one wants to be a thief all his life, especially a man with a family. So, Song Jiang first proposed to woo, and only a few people, such as Song Wu and Li Kui jy, opposed it. The overwhelming majority of people support Wu. No matter how good the cottage is, it is not as good as the outside world after all.

As for Song Jiang, he has always been eager to work for the imperial court and make contributions instead of being a small company. Yasi can't realize his ambition at all. He was drunk and said that he was like a tiger lying on a barren hill, and his hidden minions endured it. I mean, I have a skill, but just like a tiger can only lie on a hill, the benefits of minions have to be put away and endured silently. In his poem, he said, "Dare to laugh that Huang Chao is not her husband", and he did not want to rebel, but laughed at Huang Chao's disloyalty to the country.

When Song Jiang was sent to Jiangzhou, his father taught him: If you pass by Liangshanbo, they must not allow you to become an outlaw. Otherwise, you are disloyal and unfilial. It can be said that Song Jiang's tutor is also to make Song Jiang a loyal person. Since you are loyal, how can you rebel?

Second, about the wrong statement.

1, the basic condition of woo is to forgive the crime, without which it is not called woo. But in addition to pardoning the crime, the embraced party can also ask the court to agree to other conditions according to its own strength, such as sealing the official and maintaining independence. Zhang knew this well in the late Ming Dynasty.

2. With the strength of Liangshan, Song Jiang could have forced the court to agree to more conditions, such as sealing officials for the main leaders, dividing Liangshan into independent defense zones and punishing some treacherous officials. But Song Jiang's condition is only to pardon the crime, which is Song Jiang's first big mistake on the issue of Zhao 'an.

3. I underestimated the darkness of the imperial court and the energy of the traitor, so that I imagined that Liangshan would blend in and change the imperial court. Because of this, Sung River and Liangshan made a serious mistake in treating treacherous court officials represented by Gao Qiu, that is, they repeatedly jumped and made repeated mistakes.

If you don't want to go along with the treacherous court official, Sung River should guard against the persecution of the treacherous court official. For example, you should try to kill the golf ball (you can take slow medicine) or detain it in the mountains. Liangshan is either in cahoots with the treacherous court official, or will never compromise, so as to resolutely strive for self-protection.

Song Jiang, also known as Hu, Timely Rain and Xiaoyi Kursaburo, is a character in the classic novel Water Margin, one of the generals of Liangshan 108, ranking first.

Song Jiang was originally an escort in Yuncheng County, Shandong Province. Yan Poxi discovered his communication with classical music, so he angered Yan Poxi and fled home to hide. Later, he went to Qingfeng Village to take refuge in Huarong Road, but when he was watching lanterns in Qingfeng Village, he was framed and imprisoned by Liu Gao's wife in Zhizhai. On the way to Qingzhou, he was rescued by Yan Shun and others. On the way to Liangshan, I learned that my father had passed away, but I was caught on my way home to attend the funeral and sent to Jiangzhou. He was sentenced to death in Xunyanglou, Jiangzhou, but was rescued by Liangshan army on the day of execution and defected to Liangshan. After the attack on Classical City was shot in the head, Song Jiangba won the first prize, followed by two wins in Tong Guan and three wins in Gao Qiu. After accepting the harness, he led the Liangshan army to attack Liao, and pacified Wang Qing and Fang La. After being sealed by the imperial court, he was framed by Cai Jing, Tong Guan and Gao Qiu, poisoned and buried in Liaoerwa.