Should the old man who fell down be helped?

1. It should be supported. First of all, the person who fell was an old man, not a young man, let alone a young man. Since ancient times, the elderly have been respected. In ancient times, elderly people over 80 years old could enter and exit the court freely. In the eyes of the emperor, there were two types of people who must be treated with respect, one is his own parents, and the other is the elderly in the world. The respect for the elderly in ancient times can be seen. Nowadays, old people don’t help them when they fall. Compared with ancient times, what is this if not a loss of morality?

2. Secondly, there is an old saying: Cultivate oneself, manage one's family, govern the country, and bring peace to the world. Those who achieved great things in ancient times were not only extraordinary talents, but also had the virtue of helping the elderly. If a person has talent but no virtue, he will be cultivated and used. If he has talent, he will be promoted and used. If he has talent but no virtue, he will never be hired! How can a person govern a country and bring peace to the world if he doesn't even have the most basic moral cultivation?

3. Thirdly, parents and teachers teach us to respect the old and love the young from an early age. In reality, there are countless examples of children helping the elderly. Children are like this, let alone us adults? If an old man falls and does not help him, he is violating the instructions of his parents and his teacher. The yellow sky is above, the thick soil is below, and the universe is clear. If you are not respectful and filial, how can you have the face to live in this world? Finally, the reason why we are discussing this issue here is because there is a crisis of trust in the current society. The emergence of a crisis of confidence directly affects the rejuvenation of our Chinese nation. At such a juncture, what should we do? Is the crisis of confidence growing and turning a deaf ear? Every man is responsible for the rise and fall of a country. For the prosperity of the Chinese nation, everyone has an unshirkable mission. In the face of such national justice, who dares to continue to look on with indifference and indifference?

4. We say that Chinese virtues have been spread for a long time. Isn’t there a phenomenon of disrespecting the elderly and caring for the young in history? The answer is yes, so in today's highly developed world of information, we cannot stop and talk about it just because of such a small stumbling block on the way forward. Constructing a harmonious society requires mutual trust among each of us. Thank you all!

5. Opposition: The elderly should not be helped when they fall.

6. Our country is a country that advocates morality, justice, and civilization. When an elderly person falls, we must help immediately. There should not even be questions such as "should it", "should it be", "can it" can't" argument. However, nowadays, such issues have aroused heated discussions in our society. However, today, in this land with a history of five thousand years of civilization, there have been many incidents in which justice and evil, kindness and ugliness have been reversed. event. When promoting morality becomes a kind of adventure, we hesitate, hesitate, and decide that we should not help the old man when he falls. Are we standing on the opposite side of morality? No! The elderly should not be supported after they fall. This is the rational thinking we have come to today!

7. First: First of all, we support that the elderly should not be supported when they fall. This does not mean that the elderly should turn a blind eye when they fall. Fuzai is explained in Cihai as "to help, to support a person or object with one's hand so that it does not fall." (Friends on the other side should not change the concept and understand it as "holding up our traditional morality." Moreover, morality is not simple. Just say "help" to get up). Lifting up a fallen old man is just a form of help, but this form is not the best way. Why I say this, I will explain in the following statement. We support providing more appropriate help to the elderly after they fall, such as calling 120, contacting their family members, and waiting for professional rescue.

8. Second: There are many reasons for elderly people to fall. The following common reasons are: high blood pressure accompanied by sclerosis of arterioles in the brain, stroke caused by sudden rupture and bleeding; cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases and dizziness caused by cervical spondylosis; temporary severe hypoxia and ischemia of the brain, leading to transient loss of consciousness; acute attacks of angina pectoris, and epileptic seizures. At the same time, the bones of the elderly are relatively porous, which can easily lead to bone damage if they fall, and improper moving can easily cause secondary injuries. The opposing debater believes that the elderly should be supported when they fall, which would be too emotional and disrespectful of medicine. The opposing debater should not do bad things out of kindness and harm the old man!

9. Third: At the same time, we should not help the elderly when they fall. It’s not that we don’t want to help or that we don’t dare. It’s not that we have moral regression, but it is inseparable from the social system. ! Not daring to help an elderly person who has fallen is a "social disease" that has accumulated for a long time.

Doesn’t the opposing counsel know about the Peng Yu case in Nanjing, Jiangsu, the Xu Yunhe case in Tianjin, the Lin Chunxu case in Meizhou, Guangzhou, and the Yin Hongbing case in Nantong, Jiangsu? Along with the courage to repay kindness with hatred and the joy of helping others when getting into trouble, traditional virtues have fallen into an inexplicable embarrassment; the legal judgments of "Peng Yu Case" and "Xu Yunhe Case" even chilled the public! We don’t want to stop eating because of choking, but we look forward to a more complete legal system and more complete guarantees to protect the exercise of justice. Before that, we should protect ourselves.