How do you evaluate Yang Ying’s commentary?

"The flowing table tennis match is narrated by the iron-clad Yang Ying." Table tennis is a national sport, and there are too many people who like to watch it, but this CCTV table tennis commentator is really a bit puzzling!

It stands to reason that China’s table tennis world is full of talents. If you look for a few famous players, they will all be eloquent, eloquent and calm. But I don’t know why? CCTV has determined that only Yang Ying is a unique commentator, and she must be the commentator for every game.

But Yang Ying is really not suitable for commentating on table tennis games! Her biggest problem is her leaping thinking, and her words are quite inconsistent, which is what we often call "confused logical thinking"!

For example, when the two sides of the game are playing a crucial game, she will suddenly change the topic and talk about how hard it is to lead? How difficult it is to hold such a competition! For another example, when explaining the technical characteristics of a certain athlete, she will inexplicably bring up gossip about another athlete's recent poor performance, which is probably due to some reason..., all of this, It makes normal people unable to keep up with her thinking and confused.

I wonder how long this situation will last? With so much criticism in society, it is indeed a strange phenomenon that Yang Ying can still stand firm for so many years.

The preface does not match the follow-up, so forget about jumping thinking. The most important thing is that Yang Ying’s explanation is not fair and impartial, and is too biased.

I once watched a match between Ding Ning and Hirano Miu. Ding Ning played really well and defeated Hirano 4-1. Yang Ying explained that Ding Ning only used 70% of his power to avenge Hirano Miu. At that time, I thought of a commentator from a big country. His speech was too low, and he neither respected Ping Ye nor Ding Ning. (Ding Ning does not need to go all out to explain that Ding Ning does not respect his opponent. How can an excellent top player despise the opponent so much, not to mention that Ding Ning just lost to Pingye in the Asian Championships.) Yang Ying often uses confusing words and poor logical thinking. He mostly uses revenge, killing, and suppression. Words such as beat and cripple. There are some languages ????that fans can speak, audiences can speak, children can speak, but commentators cannot.

A good commentator must be fair and impartial, must respect foreign athletes more, be tolerant, and have a broad vision. Only a big pen can write big words. A narrow-minded and petty person is like a pencil, and it is impossible to write big slogans on a big wall.

I am not a fan of Yang Ying, and I also like table tennis. When evaluating Yang Ying realistically, you can find the Beijing team that Yang Ying explained and compete with other teams, and you can clearly see that you are leaning toward the Beijing team.

Liu Guoliang also said too much as a coach to cheer up the players, but when Liu Guoliang was commentating in front of thousands of viewers, Liu Guoliang evaluated his opponents very rationally. For example, Liu Guoliang commented on Zhang Benzhi and shouted loudly. Many fans scolded Zhang Ben for not raising him up, called Zhang Ben a devil, and said Zhang Ben had treason and surrendered to the enemy. Liu Guoliang said objectively and impartially that Zhang Ben yelled no matter who he competed with, not against China. Zhang Ben yelled to cheer himself up, to make himself more excited and forget about timidity. Liu Guoliang said that as long as you have good skills and a strong heart, you won't be afraid of him yelling. From this point of view, it can be seen that Liu Guoliang's evaluation does not please the fans at all. Liu always sees the problem correctly.

Yang Ying explained that sometimes in order to please the fans, saying things that go against one's will is also a big mistake. Maybe some people say that Yang Ying can correct his mistakes, but who can be perfect. I think it's impossible, because Yang Ying's mistake is insufficient cultural accomplishment. Occasional mistakes can be learned and corrected, but deep-rooted mistakes are difficult to correct.

A national table tennis referee, I like to analyze and study sports. I look forward to following the interaction and let's discuss and communicate together!

In China, if there is a sport that makes fans proud and makes ordinary people give a thumbs up when it is mentioned, whether they like it or not, then it is table tennis. Nothing else.

In addition to competition results, this sports project known as the "national football" has made great progress in all other aspects of development. In terms of table tennis equipment, we have successively launched "Double Happiness" and "Pisces". We have our country's own core products in all aspects of blades, floor rubber, tables and even table tennis, gradually catching up with and surpassing foreign countries.

In the field of refereeing, our international-level and even international-level blue-card referees have grown from scratch, from few to many. More and more Chinese referees are appearing in international competitions such as the World Table Tennis Championships, the Olympic Games, and the World Cup. In the past, the Chinese referees’ voice has gradually increased, which makes people happy and gratified.

But there is still one thing that makes countless fans very depressed but helpless, and that is table tennis commentary!

Let’s not mention the commentary on local sports channels. CCTV, which is supposed to be the highest level, not only failed to add excitement to the game, but also affected the interest in watching the game. Many fans said " "I would rather turn off the sound" than listen to the annoying commentary...

Why are the fans so disappointed in the commentary? Why can't we produce some passionate, professional and emotional commentators like football, basketball and other sports? !

Some fans said that if this person is not good, then someone else will be enough. Could it be that China Central Television, a big table tennis country, can’t find a commentator?

Unfortunately, in terms of commentary, there is really no one available! It’s so embarrassing!

Among CCTV’s table tennis commentators, there are only two “full-time” commentators, Cai Meng and Yang Ying. Cai Meng has retired in 2018, so looking around, the only one who can be counted is Yang Ying.

Our favorite ones sometimes appear as commentators, such as Liu Guoliang, Zhang Yining, Liu Wei, etc. They are not full-time commentators, they are just temporary guests and guests. That is to say, at least for now, when it comes to table tennis commentary, you, me and all our fans and friends don’t have much choice yet.

(1) Yang Ying is a lesbian

The evaluation must still be objective, and a basic understanding is the minimum requirement.

In her table tennis career, she had a professional background and used a fast-break style of right-hand pen-hold shooting. She entered the national team in 1993 and ranked as high as fourth in the ITTF. She was once called "Deng Yaping" Nemesis" and achieved excellent results many times.

After retiring from the national team in 2001, he studied hard for four years and graduated from Communication University of China in 2006, and then entered the CCTV5 sports channel.

(2) Outstanding advantages: strong professionalism, good empathy, and perfect cooperation

It must be said that Yang Ying’s explanation has its own characteristics and also has advantages that others cannot match.

First, it has strong professionalism. She is a table tennis major and has been immersed in table tennis. She has a very accurate grasp of the characteristics of table tennis, various institutional rules, and even the project operation model. Athletes from various countries have a very accurate understanding of table tennis. Far beyond ordinary people. If you pay close attention to her explanation, you will hear a lot of "why" content.

The second is better empathy. As someone who has experienced fierce competition on and off the court and participated in a large number of domestic and international competitions, he is very familiar with and understands the on-site atmosphere, especially the psychology of athletes during competitions. In this way, her explanations are not just about watching the ball, but more in-depth and thorough, which is of great help to us in understanding why athletes handle the ball in this way.

The third is to cooperate with the guests in place. Yang Ying's commentary often invites guests, such as Liu Guoliang, Zhang Yining, Ma Lin, etc. It should be said that no matter who he is with, Yang Ying's cooperation is still good. Just like a compliment in a cross talk, when the guests speak and comment, Yang Ying will not lose focus, but will connect it very well. In this way, the effect of the program is actually far better than when Yang Ying narrates it alone. I think this is one of the important reasons why CCTV insisted on letting her be the commentator.

(3) The shortcomings are more prominent: obvious tendencies, confusing expressions, unprofessional wording, etc.

As a full-time table tennis commentator, it should be said that achieving the above three points is still just Base. The same is true for Yang Ying. If you want to be an excellent commentator, you still need to overcome the following problems. This is also the biggest shortcoming of her explanation.

First, the tendency is too obvious. Unlike referees, commentators are not required to be completely neutral. They can also express certain preferences in the program, such as Huang Jianxiang. This kind of individual expression is sometimes more attractive to the audience. But it's not enough. Yang Ying's explanation is just to belittle one and praise the other. He praises the good ones to the heavens and drags down the ones who don't like them. The audience can say this, but as a commentator, he is a bit casual. The tendency is too obvious.

For example, I like Ma Lin very much. During the commentary, I kept commenting on "she has aura", etc., and didn't even mention a word about other athletes. From a personal analysis, it may be similar to her own playing style and thoughts, and there is a sense of like-mindedness. Second, the language expression is confusing. I don’t know if Yang Ying has received professional training in commentary, but Yang Ying’s language expression skills are not very good. Sometimes it feels like he is rambling a sentence here and there, and I don’t know what it means. Sometimes her speaking speed is relatively fast, illogical, and her words do not convey the meaning. The audience cannot grasp what she wants to say, and she herself is also quite confused. Of course, let alone humor, wit, and appeal. Third, the wording is unprofessional. Yang Ying is relatively professional in playing golf, but he is really unflattering in using professional terminology and often uses some self-created words and phrases. It may not matter in other countries, but in China, table tennis has a broad foundation, and some professional terms are not so high-level in the eyes of ordinary people. Once these conventional terms are used indiscriminately, they will make the audience feel awkward and affect the viewing of the game. .

4. It is recommended to learn from video games and let the fans commentate.

It should be said that under the current circumstances, we have not seen CCTV adding full-time table tennis commentators. .

As a referee and a table tennis fan, I suggest that you can learn from video games and discover good commentary from fans. There are many masters among the people, and there are many great gods among fans. As long as he is given a chance and a platform, he will quickly stand out.

You know, a charming explanation will make many people discover the beauty of sports and fall in love with table tennis!

I am Neo-Confucianism 117, welcome to follow and interact! I especially want to hear your opinions and suggestions!

Yang Ying is a table tennis commentator for CCTV. A former national table tennis player, he should be more professional in table tennis commentary. However, Yang Ying's commentary has been criticized by many fans, and they even bluntly said that Yang Ying Equal to silent. The main reasons why Yang Ying's explanations were criticized by the audience are as follows:

First, the basic language skills are poor, and the logic is often confusing and the words do not convey the meaning. Because many athletes in China have received professional sports training since childhood and their educational level is relatively low. Although they can enter colleges and universities for further study after retirement, the foundation is too poor after all, and the degree of improvement is limited. Yang Ying is an example. Her explanations are eloquent on the surface, but she always misses the point, leaving the audience confused about what she wants to express. In other words, it is a lot of nonsense.

Then another thing is that you think too highly of yourself and don’t know how to be humble. Yang Ying, who has a background as an athlete, may think that she is more professional than other guests in table tennis, so she always ignores the opinions of the guests and keeps interrupting their speeches. This also made the majority of fans very dissatisfied, thinking that Yang Ying was rude and ignorant of humility.

In fact, as many fans said, Yang Ying is suitable for the job of guest, so it is a bit reluctant to let him serve as a commentator.

Compared with Yang Ying, national table tennis head coach Liu Guoliang’s commentary when he was a guest was even better. Liu Guoliang's explanation is not only professional and thorough, but also has concise language, frequent golden sentences, and a sense of humor, which is deeply loved by the audience.

Yang Ying can learn more from Liu Guoliang to make his commentary more exciting.

Yang Ying’s main problem is that the interpretation bias is too obvious. The clearest impression is when Zhang Jike rose to prominence, at the 2011 World Table Tennis Championships in Rotterdam, then the World Cup, and then the Olympics. During this period, there were many small champions and they were very lucky. Well, in large competitions, Wang Hao often eliminates Ma Long, and Zhang Jike defeats Wang Hao to win the championship. In several finals, Yang Ying was the commentator, and every game was biased towards the disadvantaged Wang Hao. In fact, at that time, Wang Hao had no upper hand in any aspect, and was suppressed throughout the game, but Yang Ying's explanation was incomprehensible. , completely biased towards Wang Hao. The most obvious sentence should be the game when Zhang Jike won the World Cup for the first time. Zhang Jike played a normal exchange, and Wang Hao returned the ball to the net. Yang Ying's explanation was: Zhang Jike's ball is very strong (this word is not very sure) , very cold.

What is cold food? ! When I heard this explanation, I was dumbfounded. What the hell is this?

Segmentation

Let me just say a few words. In the recent World Table Tennis Championships, the topic of Yang Ying and Liu Wei commentating on Liu Shiwen and Chen Meng’s finals has become a hot topic. In competitive sports, fairness is the most basic. principle, then the objectiveness and impartiality of the commentary is the basic ethics of a commentator. If the commentator cannot do it, then there is no need to set up a commentator for the competitive sports live broadcast. After all, the audience's tendency is personal behavior, and the commentator's views are It is a public act for the public. Yang Ying obviously does not meet the standards of a commentator, and this has been the case all year round.

It’s not just Yang Ying’s problem, the current CCTV Sports hosts are a mixed bag, and their image and level are really hard to compliment. He has an unkempt beard, rolls up his sleeves and trouser legs, and rambles on. He has no idea what rules sports commentary needs to follow, what kind of temperament, what kind of passion and clear sound quality are required. Yang Ying is indeed a broadcasting and hosting major. Although we know how she was admitted to the Beijing Broadcasting Institute, her commentary level is really poor. Her commentary is like talking to herself, amusing herself, and talking endlessly. It was like she was chanting sutras and not paying attention to the progress of the game at all. Didn't she listen to the explanations of Zhang Zhi, Song Shixiong, and Sun Zhengping? Not all world champions are suitable to be hosts, and Yang Ying is very unsuitable.

Chinese sports commentary began in the 1950s, pioneered by the famous sports commentator Zhang Zhi. He performed extremely well at the 26th World Table Tennis Championships in Beijing in 1961, especially in his commentary In a game between the Chinese team Xu Yinsheng and the Japanese team's Hoshino, Zhang Zhi was full of emotion and excitement. He explained Xu Yinsheng's wonderful performance of dunking 12 big boards in a row. The first board, the second board, and the radio were next to each other. The audience (at that time, only Beijing, Shanghai, Nanjing, Shenyang, and Guangzhou in the country, and a few big cities had just had TV sets) and TV viewers were as if they were brought to the game. The eighth and ninth boards were extremely nervous, and everyone was watching the game. Hold your breath, concentrate on the 11th board, 12th board...Athletes fight hard, commentators are emotional... Later, many outstanding sports commentators such as Song Shixiong emerged, and today's young hosts and commentators , are all very good!

No matter how good your shoes are, they will smell bad after being worn for a long time. No matter how beautiful the music is, your ears will become noisy after listening to it for a long time. The same goes for TV show hosts, who always have a style and an accent. No matter how good he is or how friendly he is, it's all in vain, besides, Yang Ying is just average!

The rule of commentators is to be fair and objective, to be impartial and not biased. Yang Ying is biased. He praises those he is familiar with and likes, such as Zhang Jike, Ma Long, etc., and pours cold water on those he does not like. He treats foreign athletes like rape. The Japanese team was criticized more than they were praised, and they talked up to the Beijing athletes, while the athletes from other provinces were picky and picky. This was against the professional ethics of commentators and they were trying to protect themselves.

Cultural skills are a flaw. It is inevitable for athletes to have a weak foundation. The technical terminology of table tennis is all right. Fans and audiences may welcome it, but TV commentators are facing the public group and are as dry as coaches. It's boring to be like an athlete. We should increase the history, characteristics and background knowledge of the sport, the customs and customs of the competing countries, and the feelings of the fans. We should enhance the appeal and humor of the language so that men, women and children can listen, remember and remember it. Come to think of it, instead of just firing up a machine gun and blasting it endlessly, one frequency and one tone will sooner or later become a noisy noise that disturbs the people!

"No gold is pure, no man is perfect"

No matter how good the narrator is, he will have shortcomings. No matter how shortcomings Yang Ying has, he can't be completely useless. CCTV Channel can hire Yang Ying for a long time because both parties have long-term contracts. It is not like broadcasting weather forecasts, where a different person will host it every day.

Thousands of people have thousands of thoughts, and thousands of people have different appearances. Everyone thinks differently and looks at problems from different angles. We feel that Yang Ying’s explanation is not good and useless. As long as the leaders of CCTV recognize his explanation, Yang Ying will still be the unbeatable commentator in table tennis.

As people who eat melons, we should endure it if we can, not to mention that we have endured it for so many years. Now we have not reached the point where we can no longer tolerate it and there is no need to endure it anymore. Yang Ying is also a table tennis player herself. It is not easy for her to be able to participate in table tennis-related work after retiring.

Everyone looks at the problem with a tolerant attitude. The whole world is vast and boundless.

Life is short, do it and cherish it. Don't be picky, picky, or look for trouble. That will offend others and make yourself angry, right?

Some people hate others so much. You may not be able to explain someone else's performance if you were to take the role. Ask yourself, if I were to take the role, I wouldn't be able to explain Yang Ying's level, so I don't dare to say what she explained. No, it’s not that I’m timid, it’s that I’m unworthy and not qualified at all to point fingers at retired athletes with a professional table tennis background.

If everyone is still accommodating to CCTV, why not hire a few more commentators to take turns as guest hosts? Can table tennis games be held every day? Isn’t there any expense to host so many professional guests? Because Yang Ying's explanation is not good, if we blame CCTV, then we really can't sleep because the bed is crooked!

Everyone should watch the game with an understanding and peaceful attitude. If you really don’t like listening to her explanations, and you really think her level is average, you can just mute the TV and just watch the players’ matches.

As the saying goes, there is no way to get over the mountain, so let’s run over it. The living person must not be choked by urine! @Table Tennis Video @Table Tennis Teaching Video @Table Tennis Grand Slam

Yang Ying’s explanation has nothing to do with her being a table tennis player herself. Why do she say that? Because she is an outsider. What she often says is contrary to the results on the court, and she is very doubtful about her table tennis level. It is estimated that the overall level in the last century was very weak, and she cannot understand and understand the current table tennis style. Take a look at Fatty Liu's commentary on the two games between Ma Long and Liu Shiwen, what they were thinking about during the key ball, how to play it, and what the players' problems were. With such commentary, the audience will be able to watch the ball better and become more knowledgeable. As for Yang's nonsense, with no preface and follow-up, and a poor explanation without professionalism, it would be better not to say it at all. Liu Wei's commentary was way ahead of her. Suddenly I discovered that as a spectator of the national table tennis game, many of them know the game well and cannot be fooled. Don’t go on stage before you wait. Suggestion: The commentator must be a national-level coach! The coach of the second team is also good, Yang Ying is a hundred times better, but Yang just doesn't have real things in his stomach. If he can't talk well, the coach will be different.