Tianjin people went to Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou, how did they feel when they came back?

I, a pure Tianjin native, often fly across the country. Let me do a few comparisons. I hope the examiners will be merciful [praying]

Beijing VS Tianjin: Positioning Beijing is China’s political culture center. The city's various hardware and software constructions are perfect. This is unparalleled in any province or prefecture-level city in China. It is the only one in the country. It has the highest proportion of floating population (high quality) in the country and the highest consumption power. This is incomparable. It's a highly political issue. The only thing that can compare Tianjin with Beijing is that it has such a leisurely life regardless of the income of Tianjin residents. I will briefly analyze Tianjin below.

Shanghai VS Tianjin: Economic and infrastructure construction surpassed Tianjin in seconds. From this mixed mixed reform, it can be seen that Tianjin has basically been absorbed by Shanghai. Moreover, Shanghai and its surrounding areas (Jiangsu and Zhejiang) are both high-income areas with a large (high-quality) floating population. This kind of demographic dividend is incomparable to Tianjin.

Guangzhou: a southern coastal city and a front-line reform area. The economic environment of the South (the demographic dividend is also indispensable). And he has excellent economic acumen! Policies are marginal, the government is highly efficient, and it is even more affected by the climate. The night-time economy is extremely developed (those who have been to the south should agree). The surrounding Hong Kong and Macao have long enjoyed the unparalleled openness dividends of the mainland. Southerners are willing to endure hardship, and working two or three jobs a day is a living condition that is acceptable to most people. Tianjin is also incomparable.

A summary of Tianjin is just a few simple points. It cannot be comprehensive. It is not something that we ordinary people can relate to.

One: Tianjin lacks positioning. It is originally the back garden of Beijing, and it should work hard to reap the demographic dividend (increase of high-quality, high-consumption people). Design is the key, starting from the service industry, urban ecology, comfort, and leisure.

Two: Tianjin is located in the north and cannot have the seasons south of the Yangtze River. The overall service industry cannot compare with that in the south. The main line is to truly combine Tianjin's local culture with the culture of the times to create Tianjin's Internet celebrity economy, including services from practitioners in various service industries, regional Internet celebrity check-in attractions, and increasing the number of people coming to Tianjin (migrant population dividend). I believe that people who often travel for business can feel this, especially the high-speed rail (the ratio of the number of people arriving in Tianjin to the number of people arriving in other provinces).

Three: Economy is the first factor in urban development. I don’t want to say more about it, so I’ll leave it at that.

Four: Strengthen the leadership’s service awareness for small and medium-sized enterprises! Don’t stop at studying, meetings and documents! ! ! It is recommended that we change from looking for relevant departments to work in various regions and visit small and medium-sized enterprises to solve problems. (This is the biggest gap with southern cities)

Five: There are too many things I want to say about Tianjin, and I won’t say anything that can be said but cannot be said [a flash of inspiration]. I am a pure Tianjin person. I hope Tianjin will be good and I hope Tianjin will become another magical city. As for increasing revenue and reducing expenditure, I advocate increasing revenue. It is the hope for cities to expand revenue, and I won’t say the opposite.

As the back garden of Beijing, Tianjin can still provide food and clothing (no matter what level) and will do its best to ensure it. I sincerely hope that the people of Tianjin will get better and better!

I saw this title by accident, and I really like to tell my story [laughing][laughing][laughing]

I happen to have been to all of these places. , I went to Shanghai and Hangzhou with my children before, and the last stop was Guangzhou. We went back and forth for more than ten days. I vaguely remember that it was 2015. I went there a few days later in the year when it was a very cold season for us. It felt like it was late spring. The first stop I went to was Shanghai. I got off the plane and sent my things to the hotel. I made reservations online in advance. Then the first stop was the City God Temple. The sights I saw there were really beautiful. It's beautiful. The land and water support the people. We also went to the Bund. There were so many people. I even took a trip to Nanjing Road. I can't remember the name of the movie I saw when I was a kid. Anyway, I just went to Nanjing to see it. After checking it out, I also went to the department store to do some shopping, bought some gifts, clothes and so on. Then I went to buy a suit and watched a large-scale epic. It was similar to Dongfanghong. Well, what about Hangzhou love? Or what? Oops, I was very touched and excited when I saw it. I can’t even describe that feeling. I even got on the wrong bus when I got back. Fortunately, they seemed to have a night bus there. It was really It's very good, better than here. We don't have night shifts here. We take the bus from Shanghai, Hangzhou, and then take the train to Guangzhou. I stayed in Guangzhou for another two days, just to see the local customs, and took a walk. After having morning tea, I didn’t understand at first. Morning tea is like this, which means having breakfast. Haha, northerners don’t understand the eating habits of the south. They serve small bowls one by one, which is quite delicate... …

I went to Beijing once in my early 20s. It was when I accompanied my grandma and mother to Beijing to visit my great-uncle. I remember that my great-uncle lived next to CCTV. He was tall and big. My great-uncle is thin and small. My great-uncle is an old revolutionary from the old age. He should have been working at the Ministry of Railways when he retired. I heard what my mother said at that time. My great-uncle is over 100 years old and has long since passed away. [Prayer] [Prayer] [Prayer] said This is a long story. I don’t want to say it anymore. My grandma and mother have also passed away. Everyone goes there [crying] [crying] [crying]

The last time I went to Beijing in recent years was probably 2019, 19 I went there with my kids in 2018. It was just in time for the National Day. Beijing’s Tiananmen Square was under martial law, so I took a car to see Tiananmen Square. I didn’t take any close-up photos or contact. I felt a little regretful... I took the EMU in the morning and again in the evening. Just came back. I had to go back and forth in one day to feel the streets and houses of Beijing! The maintenance is better than ours. The old buildings in ours have been renovated, demolished, and turned into high-rise buildings. It feels a bit strange, but one layer cannot remain the same. This means that progress is not humming. Anyway, it is. A place where water and soil support a person, wherever you live, habits will grow over time

I also love my hometown, I also love my motherland, I hope that our motherland will be prosperous, the country will be prosperous and the people will be safe, and I hope that we will soon After this epidemic, we can go out for a walk and see the great country of the motherland

This is the farthest city I have traveled to. I have taken a lot of videos and pictures back and forth. It has been many years now. I can’t find it, so I’ll keep it in my mind

I was born and raised in Tianjin, and I went to college in Tianjin. There happened to be a guy from Beijing in the dormitory, who was my best buddy, so during college and after graduation After that, I visited Beijing many times, and he took me to visit almost all the places of interest and interesting places in Beijing. That will be concentrated from 2003 to 2008. Beijing gives me the feeling that it is indeed cleaner than Tianjin. There are many buildings and many more buildings than Tianjin. There are even more places of interest (except for the former residences of famous people, Tianjin has almost no places of interest). At that time, Happy Valley already existed in Beijing, but not in Tianjin. However, the gap is not as big as described on the Internet. It does not make people think that Tianjin is a large rural area. This statement is really an exaggeration.

I graduated from college in 2007 and joined a Fortune 500 foreign company. In the first two years, I went to the Asia-Pacific headquarters (in Shanghai) to work as a management trainee, so I stayed there for more than a year (Tianjin People Love Home , I came back early). In 2007, Shanghai already felt like an international metropolis. If you admire the night view on the Bund, you will definitely have the illusion that this is Paris! At that time, there were large shopping malls on both sides of Nanjing Road Commercial Street, while Binjiang Road at that time was full of one-story shops. If I remember correctly, Shanghai already had more than 10 subway lines in 2007. Many stations served as hubs and were stacked on several levels, very much like airport halls. There was only one Line 1 in Tianjin. At that time, each district in Shanghai had its own commercial center, while Tianjin only had one commercial center, Binjiang Road. I remember that in Shanghai, a friend took me to a restaurant for dinner. According to her, it was only found in Shanghai in the whole of China. I have long forgotten the specific name of the restaurant. My only impression was that it was not very delicious and the portion was small. There was a dish called "Three Mouths of Rice" "When I brought it up, I saw that there were only three bites of rice..." During the National Day that year, I returned to Tianjin from Shanghai, and I actually didn’t feel a huge sense of gap. There is definitely a gap, but it's really not that big. Many people are exaggerating.

Tianjin’s urban construction probably started in 2007 or 2008. At the ten-year graduation party, many students from other places came to Tianjin again ten years later. Everyone felt that Tianjin has changed a lot and is very beautiful now. In fact, I don't feel anything at all. In my opinion, it seems to be about the same. It should be that I have always lived here, so I can’t feel the change!

If you look carefully, even Tianjin people can see the rapid changes in Tianjin. For example, as I mentioned above, in 2007 and 2008, Tianjin had only one center, Binjiang Road. Now almost every district has its own central area, such as Wanda in Hedong, Water City in Hongqiao, Jinwan Plaza in Hexi, Gulou Street in Nankai, etc. And now there are almost no small shops on both sides of Binjiang Road, replaced by shopping malls with large brands. From these details, we can know that Tianjin has changed a lot in the past ten years and has become more and more like an international metropolis.

I have never been to Guangzhou, and I guess it is much better than Tianjin in every aspect, but there should be no strong shock or contrast. Tianjin is a very special city. The economy is not very good, there are not many outstanding private enterprises, and variety shows are not as good as those in Hunan, Jiangsu, and Zhejiang. Although it is one of the four major municipalities directly under the Central Government, in terms of popularity, it may not be as good as Nanjing, Suzhou, and Hangzhou. But Tianjin’s livability seems to always be among the best.

Tianjin people rarely have lofty ambitions and ideals. Tianjin people are quite humorous and like to joke around. Many of them can't speak, which can easily offend friends who come to Tianjin from other places. However, most Tianjin people are actually not bad. I joined a well-known foreign company in 2007. The company originally planned to keep all of us in Shanghai for development, but I went home anyway and later resigned. From then on, I stayed away from suits and leather shoes and laptop briefcases, and never interacted with foreign companies again. Among the 13 people who joined us in the same batch, some later switched jobs to Huawei, and some were posted overseas. Most of our friends share photos of vacations or work abroad, which are far away from me. It’s not that I don’t have money to travel, it’s just that the environment is different, and I don’t have that idea.

Every decision we make now will affect the future. I just want to be here in my hometown, so I took this path and have no regrets. I am a little envious of others, but not too much. many. Tianjin natives may think that the best thing is to go home every day!

How do people from Tianjin feel about going to Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou? I am from old Tianjin. Let me talk about my feelings. I go to Beijing often. Beijing’s infrastructure is not as good as Tianjin. People are tired of living in Beijing. Buying a house in Beijing is a suburb. Working in the city is actually Beijing learning from the wrong development of foreign countries, which has brought too much helplessness to people's lives. Tianjin is not like this. We live in the city, and many people go to work in the suburbs. People live in Tianjin and live a solid life. , convenient. If there is no ambition, Tianjin is a very good city.

Most people in Tianjin will not settle in Shanghai, because the climate is hot and humid in summer, wet and cold in winter, and the too frequent rainy season is annoying. However, Tianjin has 300 sunny days a year, so The basic education, medical care, transportation and affluence of Tianjin people are no worse than those in Shanghai, so Shanghai has no nostalgia for most Tianjin people.

People from Shenzhen, Guangdong and Tianjin may go there to work, that’s all.

Some people say that Tianjin people love their families? I have also gone to other places to make a living. Putting aside the cost of food and drink, places such as Beijing and Shanghai may not necessarily make more money than Tianjin, unless you have great skills. To be honest, Tianjin’s climate, products, transportation, basic education, medical care, working environment, geographical location, ports, etc. There are too many advantages, many of which Beijing and Shanghai do not have, but we are too close to Beijing, and our development cannot be stronger than that of Beijing.

My ancestors followed the King of Yan to the north and settled in Tianjin from Shaoxing, Zhejiang. They have lived here for more than 600 years. I have relatives in Beijing and Shanghai and they move around quite frequently. When I was a child, I went to Beijing because it was relatively close. During the Peaceful Liberation of Beijing, my aunt’s family came to Beijing to work and live in Qianmen. At that time, I felt that Beijing was similar to Tianjin. The neighborhood relations in the courtyards were harmonious, and the old Beijingers were very warm and geographically close. Later, I was assigned to Beijing in 2000 and felt that Beijing was good. Big, no memories of childhood. The first time I went to Shanghai was in 1992. I stayed with relatives in Shanghai for 2 months. At that time, Pudong was still a rural area and there were not so many high-rise buildings. My relatives lived in Jing'an, Putuo, and Huangpu. It felt like they were no different from Tianjin, but Shanghainese people were very fond of it. Northerners still like to ignore people. My impression of Shanghai is not very good. After getting married, my mother-in-law is from Shanghai and lives near Zhabei Railway Station. My wife told me that when she was a child, she went to her maternal uncle's house in Shanghai to talk about her uncle's daughter. She was from the countryside in Shanghai dialect. Last year, on the first anniversary of the death of my mother-in-law, I accompanied my father-in-law. My wife went to visit her uncle's house in Shanghai. Then we swam on the Huangpu River and found that there was a huge gap between Shanghai and Tianjin. The appearance of the city can be reflected in all aspects. The management of the entire city is not on the same level. Needless to say, the capital Beijing is the heart. Speaking of Shanghai alone, this reflects the overall thinking of a city manager, taking care of the people's livelihood and taking care of it. Let’s not talk about Shanghai and Beijing for this development. I am afraid that first-tier cities and even second-tier cities will find it difficult to find a place.

I often go in and out of the imperial and magical cities, but now I dare not go to Beijing. I went to Guangzhou last year and maybe I will go there more often in the future. First of all, I live in the middle ring line of Tianjin, my colleagues in Beijing live in Tiantongyuan Xisanqi, and my colleagues in Shanghai live in Songjiang and Baoshan, Jiading. You can get there by transferring to several subway lines 10, but I think it’s far away from Tianjin after exiting the outer ring. As for food, except for roast duck, there is almost nothing that you can eat in Beijing. The pulp is like water, and you can stretch it if you bite into it. Scallion pancakes in Shanghai are a bit expensive. Wontons are made with a spoonful of lard in the soup to enhance the flavor. Small wontons cost at least 6/7 yuan, which is ahead of Tianjin’s stock wontons. Large wontons have thick skins and lots of vegetables, and the fried and steamed dumplings have thin fillings. Sweet but affordable, the moon cakes, glutinous rice balls and rice dumplings are all stuffed with meat. The noodles are very good and you can choose the fried eel kidney and large intestine alone. The price is 5/60 per serving. However, Beijing-Shanghai has developed transportation and the subway interval is short. Even Beijingers don’t go to the Tiananmen Bird’s Nest and Water Cube in the Forbidden City every day. Similarly, Shanghainese don’t go back to the Pearl Tower on the Bund, Yuyuan Disneyland. There are still many people living in hutongs in Beijing (even in courtyard houses), and there are still many people living in old houses in Shanghai. When I came out, I really wanted to eat crispy rice dumplings, flatbreads and egg dumplings. I admire Shanghai's urban management and citizen quality, and it is also what Tianjin needs to learn from. Beijing is the capital, and Tianjin is the moat.

The most obvious thing I feel is impetuousness and congestion. The pace is too fast. It’s a lot of money to make, but you have to have a life to earn it, and you have a life to spend it, right? Living in Tianjin is still comfortable. A monthly salary of 18,000 yuan is enough. Buying a home of your own will not be as tiring as in Guangshen, Northern Province.

I am from Tianjin and work in Beijing. To be honest, Tianjin is far behind, really. I go on business trips to major cities across the country every year, and the most shocking one is Chengdu. Every time I feel a huge change.

Not to mention Shanghai, Guangzhou, Shenzhen... The most ridiculous thing is that once I took a taxi from home to Tianjin Airport and was walking on the expressway. After knowing that I often travel for business, the driver asked me if there were such good viaducts in other cities across the country. , I smiled and said nothing...

The feeling is not as good as Tianjin.

Tianjin is the only city in China that has both northern and southern styles. It is the only city that has palaces in the north, green walls and green tiles in the south, as well as westernization. It is the city with the lowest prices among China's megacities.

Among the provinces and municipalities in China, Tianjin ranks first in per capita GDP and not in the top five in terms of income. However, due to low prices, the purchasing power of income ranks first in the country.

Tianjin has good social security, good educational resources, and better medical resources, and there are not so many migrant workers coming in blindly. When walking on the road, everyone around them speaks Tianjin dialect, but in nearby Beijing , it’s hard to hear Beijing dialect even if you walk on the road for an hour!

"Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou don't believe in tears, Tianjin is the beginning of life." The author is deeply moved and will tell you one by one. Beijing is so close to you, but it seems so far away from you!

The high-speed rail from Tianjin to Beijing is very convenient. In 2019, the author made the trip no less than 20 times. I worked in Beijing for more than a year before 2012. I feel that Beijing is "high-end, but it has nothing to do with you" and that Beijing is "special." It’s crowded, and I feel like I can’t breathe.” I feel that Beijing is “extremely cold in winter,” and people feel “so close yet so far away.”

You have heard the word "Beidiao", but you have never heard the word "Tiandiao". You lack a sense of belonging in Beijing, maybe because of the fast pace that you can't get used to. In Shanghai, behind the prosperity is infinite loneliness.

You can take the high-speed train from Tianjin to Shanghai. I remember taking the maglev train in 2010. I really felt how high-end Shanghai was. In 2019, I made a special trip to Shanghai for "eating".

Shanghai gives people the impression of being "prosperous". The people are very bourgeois, and the various restaurants will keep you entertained. However, the food is exquisite, but you are a bit hungry. Behind the prosperity is the incomparable reality. I feel lonely and feel that Shanghai is not suitable for ordinary people because you have nothing to do with the "prosperity". Guangzhou, the "South" where northerners cannot integrate.

I have been to Guangzhou several times and always go to the pedestrian street. Guangzhou feels like a "paradise for migrant workers", with people from all over the world here.

I can’t say that I have very deep feelings. Sometimes I even feel a bit “chaotic”. Maybe Guangzhou is more representative of southern cities. Cantonese, soup making, afternoon tea, these are “city symbols” that northerners are not used to. ”, which makes people a little uninterested.

Liking a city often comes with its attributes. Tianjin, with its slow pace, will make you very comfortable. After returning from Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou, I still like the city of Tianjin!