Lin Biao and Su Yu, who is the first tiger?

Original title: Lin Biao and Su Yu, who is the first tiger?

In fact, comparing the two generals of Surin should have more specific evaluation criteria:

First, in terms of military contribution, Lin Biao is above Su Yu.

Su Yu is an outstanding general worthy of study in China's military arena. He is an outstanding strategist and strategist. In his life, he won many battles and participated in many battles. The battles he commanded are recorded in writing: Huangqiao Campaign, Axle Campaign, Tianmu Mountain Campaign, Suzhong Campaign (that is, seven battles and seven wins), Subei Campaign, Lunan Campaign, Laiwu Campaign, Menglianggu Campaign, Shatuji Campaign, Yudong Campaign, Jinan Campaign, Huaihai Campaign and so on. Chiang Kai-shek was nervous about him, but there was nothing he could do. As early as the first counter-encirclement, he became famous in the Red Army because he wiped out the main force 18 division and captured the teacher Zhang Huizan alive!

Later, three famous battles of China's Liberation War took place. Among them, Su Yu was the initiator of the Huaihai Campaign. After several months' consideration, he suggested launching the Huaihai Campaign. From the whole process of Huaihai Campaign, including * * *, Su Yu played a leading role; From conception, launching, how to fight for aid, how to encircle, how to divide, how to chase, how to block, how to block, how to fight a decisive battle with Herry Liu Group near Xuzhou, all this is under Su Yu's control; Judging from the tasks shared by Su Yu, his task is the heaviest. The Third Field Army under his command wiped out the enemy the most, with 550,000 men. He wiped out 440,000 people, and Su Yu also paid attention to the overall situation of Huaihai Campaign. In addition to being responsible for annihilating the Yellow Corps and the Du Corps, he also sent five columns to participate in the second phase of encirclement and suppression of the Yellow Corps. In order to annihilate stevie hoang Corps in the second stage, he didn't sleep for seven days and seven nights until stevie hoang Corps was completely solved, and Su Yu breathed a sigh of relief. It seems that military contribution is really great!

Let's go back to Lin Biao: When Lin Biao took part in the Northern Expedition at Huangpu Military Academy, he was already famous for his bravery. During the Jinggangshan struggle, Lin Biao repeatedly made meritorious military service from company commander to colonel. During the Long March, Lin Biao was the head of the Red Army Corps, and he was a pioneer in seizing the village courage all the way. Dadu River, Jinsha River, Luding Bridge, Lazikou and other fierce battles failed many times. When War of Resistance against Japanese Aggression broke out, Lin Biao led the 1 15 Division to annihilate thousands of Japanese invaders in the first battle, and gained a worldwide reputation.

654.38+100000 people marched into the northeast, and defeated Chen Cheng, Du Fu and Wei successively without any rear support. The victory of Liaoshen Campaign laid the foundation for the launching of Huaihai Campaign. Then Lin Biao non-stop, with millions of troops through the righteous with the wicked, Tianjin, thoroughly find out the military strength of jiangnan * * *. The success of the war led to the Southern War in ten provinces and eight cities. The footsteps of the four fields actually traveled all over China, commanded the first sea crossing operation, and liberated Hainan Island in one fell swoop!

From this point of view, Lin Biao is still above Su Yu in military contribution.

Second, purely on military capabilities, Lin Biao and Su Yu are on a par.

Su Yu belongs to a purely military leader. Many battles he led, such as Menglianggu Campaign, Yudong Campaign, Laiwu Campaign and later Huaihai Battlefield, can be said to be flexible and changeable, with distinctive campaign characteristics. Many times, the weak beat the strong, and the few win more. He gives the impression that he is brave and resourceful, and his tactics are unexpected and very changeable.

Lin Biao also has this talent. Liaoning and Shenyang, the big battlefield, is Lin Biao's collection of DongBeiJu secretary, political commissar and many other positions in one, to provoke all the military, political and economic burdens. But tactically, there are few examples of Lin Biao's skill, and all of them are methodical and leisurely. When he fought Liaoshen World War I, he took the lead in not rushing to Changchun. When the time was right to attack Jinzhou and lock the northeast, he made an iron fist move, so Lin Biao showed the advantages of courage and strategy many times. Du fought in Liaoshen and Huaihai battlefields, and both lost to Su Yu. This is entirely because he is not as resourceful as Sue, and he is a little panicked. Lost Liaoshen, in fact, Du took over the northeast battlefield halfway, and lost to Lin Biao with courage.

Thirdly, in terms of objective factors such as history, fate is indeed biased towards Lin Biao.

Lin Biao's first battle has become famous. Later, during the War of Liberation, Su Yu faced great challenges, relying on the geographical advantages of the Soviet Union and North Korea, and at the same time being attacked on all sides. Because Lin Biao is rich in materials in Northeast China, it is easy to arrange the wounded, while Su Yu was poor in the eight-year war of resistance in East China, and even stretched to the limit. Northeast Lin Biao has a strong terrain, while Su Yu has a favorable terrain in East China. Lin Biao commanded more recruits and Su Yu commanded more prisoners; Lin Biao has no experience in commanding a large corps, and relies entirely on the initiative of his subordinates. Su Yu's large corps command is just right, and Hua Ye Nakano has done it ... These factors can't be ignored!

As Lin Biao quickly became a political rookie, he took over more political tasks than Su Yu, and fate always favored those who were always ready. Lin Biao is young and smart, and Su Yu is young and generous, which doomed them to be worlds apart in their career advancement. Later, Su Yu only became the first of the top ten generals in the founding of the People's Republic of China. Unfortunately, he was not among the handsome stars, and history was helpless!