Let's talk about our feeling about that romance of the three kingdoms.

I read the book Romance of the Three Kingdoms this holiday and benefited a lot. Romance of the Three Kingdoms is a classic novel with dynastic style, which tells a series of stories from the late Eastern Han Dynasty to the unification of the Jin Dynasty. First of all, I saw a poem as familiar as "The Yangtze River Rolling East …", and then I introduced it into the text. The first sentence is like this: "It is said that the general trend of the world will be combined for a long time, and it will be combined for a long time." This sentence is not unreasonable. At the weekend, the seven countries divided and ruled, merged into one and merged into Qin. After the Qin Dynasty was destroyed, Chu and Han contended and merged into the Han Dynasty ... There were hundreds of characters and countless military strategies in the book. The author himself expounded the truth of loyalty, teaching, benevolence, righteousness and love through historical figures, which was deeply loved by the people. It describes mediocre masters Xian Di and Liu Chan, incompetent people Lu Bu, Yuan Shu, Yuan Shao, Liu Biao and Liu Zhang, narrow-minded Zhou Yu, long and thick Lu Su, brave Zhang Fei, Xu Jun and Dian Wei, all the way to Jiang Gan, which made people laugh for generations. These characters gave me a deep education. Aside from these characters, what impressed me most was the heroes described in this book. Let's start with Guan Yu. This is one of the people who impressed me the most. He refused to send Cao into Han, took a candle to Dan, rode a thousand miles alone, passed five customs and killed six generals, and the ancient city was beheaded. Later, Huarong Road released Cao Cao. He was loyal to his old master, and because of his defeat and surrender, he made an appointment to know the news of his old master, so he didn't know how far Wan Li was. I think coming back after defeating the enemy is not only loyalty, but also a rare loyalty. The method of expressing Guan Yu in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is also very simple: "The phoenix eye, the silkworm eyebrow, the face like a heavy jujube, the dragon crescent moon knife", and later added "Red Rabbit Horse" and read Spring and Autumn Annals, making it almost invincible in the world. What he has done is worth learning. During the feudal rule, loyal ministers were needed, and loyal ministers who could do their best and die. This is Zhuge Liang. Zhuge Liang is well versed in astronomy and geography, capable of writing and martial arts, and resourceful all his life. He borrowed the east wind, the straw boat borrowed the arrow, Zhou Yu, the three souls, the wisdom of Huarong Road, the ingenious arrangement of the eight arrays, the death of Wang Lang, the empty city plan, the seven-star lamp, the return of the puppet Sima Yi, and the trick to kill Wei Yan were all unexpected. I thought this kind of person should look extraordinary, but the description in the book is simple: he is eight feet long, with a face like a jade crown, wearing a black silk scarf and a crane. What he did left a deep impression on later generations. Now speak of the devil. Cao Cao was called a traitor in Romance of the Three Kingdoms, probably because his son usurped the Han Dynasty. He said that Liu Bei and he were contemporary heroes, which made Liu Bei afraid to listen, but he didn't kill Liu Bei, although Liu Bei was just a turtle in a jar. This made me feel Cao Cao's generosity, which Zhou Yu never dreamed of. Zhou Yu only sees Zhuge Liang, not swearing. As long as Zhuge Liang is killed, the world in Soochow will be peaceful. Later, I found out that Liu Bei was not an ordinary person, so I wanted to kill Liu Bei, at least leave him in Soochow, where the world was at peace. Short-sighted, narrow-minded, not a hero. This is also in sharp contrast with Cao Cao. Cao Cao is also a doer. He once assassinated Dong Zhuo and ordered the vassals to gather against Dong Zhuo. These let me feel the greatness of Cao Cao. Generally speaking, after reading this book, I opened my eyes, and the people above also gave me deep feelings. They are worth learning.

Respondent: Zhang Yingzhi-Juren Grade 5 1- 10 15:30.

-

It's all your feelings and thoughts.

People who have never created sentences should not be out of emptiness or reality. If everything is empty, it will be absurd and will not convince the archaeological heart. Everything is actually lost in mediocrity and will not move for a while.

The first thing to make sure is that romance is a historical novel, and novels allow exaggeration and fiction. For example, in the text, Taoyuan became sworn, Nagano fought, and the grass boat borrowed an arrow. These may not exist in history, but the purpose of writing these is to highlight the author's views and positions. Of course, we critics should take the author's position as the core and analyze the author's wishes. Then put forward personal opinions for discussion.

Novels usually express their views in a direct and indirect way. Typical examples are the descriptions by Lu Bu, Guan Yu and Zhuge Liang.

Let's start with Guan Yu. In the brilliant Three Kingdoms series of games, Guan Yu ranks third after Lu Bu and Zhang Fei in terms of force, but in all the Three Kingdoms games I have played, without exception, Lu Bu is the first, and all other game developers except The Tale of the Three Kingdoms agree that Lu's force is 100, but there are some differences in the increase of weapon force. Is this what Luo Guanzhong, the author of Romance, meant? The answer is no. There are three reasons:

First of all:

Three British wars against Lu Bu and twenty wars against Ji Ling.

Argument 1: Lu Bu, the Three-Britain War, has been studied N million times, so I won't say much here.

Conclusion: Lu Bu is better than Guan Yu.

Argument 2: Ji Ling and Guan Yu, beheaded by Zhang Fei, fought twenty times without showing defeat.

Conclusion: There are off-site factors, such as Guan Yu's lack of military forces, and Guan Yu has the saying that "the base drive is quite heavy, the horse is motionless and often thin". Guan Yu agreed to Ji Ling's truce. First of all, Guan Yu is proud. Besides, Guan Yu's thin horse is exhausted. After the war, Ji Ling didn't dare to fight again, so it can't be said that Ji Ling and Guan Yu drew? Guan Yu is stronger than Ji Ling and Zhang Fei is stronger than Guan Yu. Guan Yu's phrase "My brother's wing takes the general's head to the public" is this battle (at this time, someone must say that what I said runs counter to his own argument, no, please see below).

Second:

Ma Chao and Zhang Fei fought for Lily in June and July. I can't sit still. What do you think of the old letter? "General Liang wants to part with Meng Qi. There is brightness: Meng Qi is brave, but he is also a disciple of Qing Bu and Peng Yue; When you compete with Yongde, it is not the peerless superiority of the beard. "

Argument: Guan Yu is incomparable?

Conclusion: Whether Guan Yu is superior or not. To put it simply, it doesn't matter if Guan Yu Can can't beat Zhang Fei and his brother, even strangers who have just arrived can't beat Guan Yu. Will he be satisfied? How dare Zhuge Liang mention that Ma Chao and Zhang Fei are neck and neck? Guan Yu is not under Zhang Fei (why is there such a change? See below).

Third:

Make a simple comparison.

Lu Bu tied Zhang Fei (50%), and played another game1/kloc-0-20. Zhang Feiping, Xu Chuping, Lu Bu (20%), Xu Chuping, Ma Fei, Xu Chuping (50%), lost Yan Liang, lost Wen Chou, and Guan Yu was beaten in the right arm (80%).

Argument: Kill Yan Liang with one knife and Wen Chou with four. Is it the embodiment of real force?

Conclusion: No, if there is such strength, the force should be above 150. Is that an invalid example of war? Not exactly. There are many off-site factors in these two wars. Guan Yu won the first game with a red rabbit, and Wen Chou was afraid of World War II. Then why is it not an invalid war case? Mainly in Cheng Yu and Cao Cao's trust in it, Guan Yu's trust and Yuan Shao's praise.

Cheng Yu: "People can be enemies of Yan Liang, which is related to the public." . Cao Cao was overjoyed and asked Guan Yu. Guan Yu: "I look at Yan Liang like selling pig's head" (I will know how to sell pig's head after getting along with Zhang Fei for a long time). Yuan Shao: "My cloud is ten times better than Yan Liang and Wen Chou". So Guan Yu killed them by accident, and it was inevitable to win them.

To sum up, Guan Yu fought three wars in England, Lu Bu fought more than twenty wars in Ji Ling, and Yan Liang killed Wen Chou. The only difference is Red Rabbit. Guan Yu won after the Red Rabbit (not to mention killing) and indirectly killed the generals of Zhang Fei and Lu Bu. Zhang Fei beat Ji Ling before he killed Guan Yu without a red rabbit, while Lu Bu and the first-class military commander were tied (no victory). Guan Yu won after the red rabbit, which was obviously better than Zhang Lujiang. The author deliberately staggered that there is only one red hare in the world, in order to achieve the purpose of Guan Yu's invincible in the world, and such euphemistic expression should be related to the folk rumor that Lu Bu is invincible, which will lead to criticism if it is too direct.

Since Guan Yu should be highlighted, there are rumors that Lu Bu and Zhang Fei, who are stronger than Guan Yu, will be vilified, and Lu Bu and Zhang Fei will be reckless. Lu Bu, a slave with three surnames, is just the opposite of Guan Yu's former life in the United States, making him almost useless except for his appearance and martial arts. But Lyu3 bu4 Yuanmen shot halberd in front of Chen Gong dazzled a strategy! The most unreasonable thing is that Zhang Fei, the vanguard of Changban Bridge, managed to catch Yan Yan and outwit Wakouguan. One thing in common with these three moves is that Guan Yu is not present, which is a bit like a pig in Journey to the West. With the Monkey King present, the old pig is useless. However, Guan Yu, who is well versed in the Spring and Autumn Period, has never had a decent plan. Zhang Helu is so unfair! (Three Kingdoms Eight: Lu Buwu 108 Wisdom 27 Politics 22 Charm 36; Zhang 103 Zhi 3 1 Zheng 26 Charm 43; Guan 102 Zhi 80 Zheng 69 Charm 93; Three kingdoms and nine countries: Lu Butong 94 Wu 108 Zhi 25 Zheng16; Zhang 83 Wu 103 Zhi 35 Zheng 22; Guan Yutong 93 Wu 102 Zhi 77 Zheng 64) Lu Bu finally took an extra class in No.9 Middle School, but the intelligence class was worse than before. . .

If the romance is to express that Guan Yu is the first, how can we understand that Guan Yu is behind Zhang Lu? This is first of all a folk rumor that Lu Bu is invincible, so Zhang Fei can draw with Lu Bu, which is naturally considered as the second. The author's failure to change people's views shows that the author's description is unsuccessful. In my opinion, the most important thing is to vilify Lu Bu's ability and indirectly beautify Lu Bu's martial arts. When Cao Cao was afraid of Lu Bu, his first reaction was that Lu Bu was too brave, because Lu Bu in people's hearts could do nothing but be brave. Is Lyu3 bu4 really like this in history? If Lyu3 bu4 is really brave, why are there so many followers? If Cao Cao was only brave, would he be so afraid of Lu Bu? The description in the book is not convincing enough.

In fact, Lu Bu had nothing to do with the Three Kingdoms. It was not until his death that he realized that his era was called the former Three Kingdoms era. This role has only made a little contribution to the formation of the Three Kingdoms, and its position in the Three Kingdoms is similar to that of Yuan Shu and Yuan Shao. Lyu3 bu4' s martial arts skills are superb, similar to that of Wang Zhongyang in The Condor Heroes, and Guan Yu is of course Guo Jing. Guo Jing, who is familiar with the Nine Yin True Classics, has surpassed his predecessor Wang Zhongyang. Later, people regarded Lu Bu as an example above Guan Yu, just like in a TV series "The Condor", Huashan Mountain in Wang Zhongyang won the title of the best in the world with one enemy and four enemies. Wang Zhongyang was first written by Jin Yong, and it was the first comment by five people. The battle of one against four is fictitious. Master Jin didn't say that Guo Jing could beat four old men, east, west, north and south. This is unrealistic, right? (Off topic, hehe)

Speaking of which, the Zhao family will be dissatisfied. Your boy said that the world is invincible for a long time without mentioning Zhao Yun's words? Let's talk about Zhao Yun again. According to the romance, Zhao Yun was 70 years old when he died, but he was older than Guan Yu (refer to the theory of Zhao Yun's age a few days ago), and Guan Yu also said "Zhao Yun's younger brother" when he was sworn in. Why did the author make such a mistake? Zhao Yunnian's seventieth birthday is an extraordinary achievement, which should be a popular story and more convincing. The' young general' who saved Sun Chou cannot be established. Zhaoyun at this time should be between 30 and 33. The article describes Zhao Yun as eight feet long, with thick eyebrows and a wide face and heavy weight. Zhou Cang said he was extremely magnificent. Zhao Yun should be the kind of person who is big and handsome, not Zhao Yunchuan, the little creamer in the game. The reason why the people behind will make Zhao Yun more and more neutral is actually related to the' young general' in the article. The reason why the author lowered Zhao Yun's age is to make Zhao Yun the third best in the world after Lu Bu and Guan Yu. Since he is the successor of Guan Yu, he is naturally younger. In this article, Guan Yu was tied with Lao Zhong only after beheading Yan Liang, killing Wen Chou and six generals. Going to the meeting alone is only theoretical courage. The author wants to tell us that Guo Jing is invincible, but actually Guan Yu is just waiting for when to enter the coffin. At this time, the real invincible on the battlefield is Zhao Yun, and Zhao Yun's invincible performance is after winning green gang. This is the genius of the author. Before getting green, Zhao Yun only tied with Wen Chou, and successfully staggered Zhao Yun's green to Lu Bu and Guan Yu. But Zhao Yun's age is close to Guan Yu's, or even longer. Therefore, Zhao Yun's role in this article is rather awkward. He took Guan Yu's first position in the world. When Guan Yu died, Zhao Yunnian's position in this article was similar to that of Yong Zhengdi in the prosperous period of Kanggan. Yongzheng/kloc ascended the throne in 0/6, and Zhao Yun died nine years later. Therefore, Zhao Yun should belong to a transition in the novel, and his existence is more to pass on the best in the world to the next generation.

No matter who is stronger or weaker than Jiang Wei and Wen Yang, according to the author's wishes, it is undoubtedly Jiang Wei, Jiang Wei and Lao Zhao who equalized Zhao Yun, and Zhao Yun appreciated it. The author's intention is very clear. As far as the author's position is concerned, Shu is orthodox, and the protagonist is of course Shu. That means Jiang Wei is invincible. Why not say that Jiang Wei and Zhao Yun were tied in the battle, only that the number of battles was close? This is not difficult to understand. In the end, the brave generals of the Three Kingdoms are dying. The real reason is that they have been fighting for years. As you can imagine, those lean soldiers rushed ahead, and the old, weak and disabled soldiers were generally in the second line. In the first three countries, people like Guan Yu were not prepared to join the army. If Guan Yu is also a soldier, it is unknown whether he can live to be forty years old! Then we should be glad that Liu Bei was there to help build gangs and give him a job. It is not difficult for us to find that in the later Three Kingdoms, the generals were either famous or skillful in strategy. So to say that Jiang Wei and Zhao Yun fought two or three hundred collaborators is also lacking in confidence, but we can't directly say that Jiang Wei can't beat Zhao Yun. We can only say that he played several times, and then let Lao Zhao praise him, indirectly telling us that Zhao Yun's task has been completed. And Jiang Wei didn't become the real number one until Wei Yan died!

Jiang Wei's first theory has four points:

First of all:

When Zhu died, he left an imperial edict saying that Jiang Wei was brave and good at fighting. This kind of work was done by Zhao Yun before.

Second:

The article said twice that Wargo was resourceful, but never said that he was brave, while Jiang Wei's bravery was often mentioned. This is actually extremely unfair to Wargo.

Third:

Wen Yang and Wargo are even. Wen Yang's position in the latter three countries is similar to that of Guan Yu and Zhao Yun.

Fourth:

Jiang Wei's bravery can't be compared with that of Lu Bu and Zhao Yun, but his ability to improvise is the strongest among the three countries. Yang Xin was killed by a horse fall, and Guo Huai was killed by Zhang Gong.

Tell me more about Zhuge Liang. Guo Jia, the counselor of the former Three Kingdoms, played a similar role to Lu Bu, and both contributed to the formation of the Three Kingdoms. Only Jia can be compared with Guo Jia of the former Three Kingdoms. Guo Jia's strategy is more radical, which is very suitable for Cao Cao, who has no strength at that time, while Jia Xu is more wise to protect himself, which is very similar to his character. If Jia Xu were a woman, she would do anything, but marrying a chicken or a dog can tame her husband. In romance novels, Zhuge Liang knows almost everything except martial arts. Mr. Lu Xun once said that "Zhuge Liang is wise and close to a demon", and Zhuge Liang in this article was completely deified. Let's start with the black silk scarf of the feather fan. Su Shi has a saying: "Looking back at Gong Jin, Xiao Qiao was handsome and dashing when he first got married. Some people say that the author robbed Zhou Yu's feather fan black silk scarf and gave it to Zhuge Liang. A few days ago, some netizens said that Su Shi had left the Three Kingdoms for thousands of years, which may be incorrect. Even if the analysis is original, in my opinion, Zhou Yu and Zhuge Liang are equivalent to the current chairmen of the Central Military Commission. Is it necessary to grab the broken feather fan black silk scarf? It's inconvenient for one person to have one set, so when Zhou Yu died, he said not' When will Yu be born, how can Liang be born', but' Since I bought a feather fan black scarf, why did Liang buy a feather fan black scarf? ? What do you want? What do you want to do? Loyalty? Are you kidding? Let the sleigh sugar cover the locust Tang? Where's Zhan Pangxie? Do you want to drink jiaozi? Catch mu? What happened? What about school? Are you rich in sugar? What is this? Hey? Are you thirsty? School? Are you dizzy and addicted? Hey? Now, I'm afraid I can't rely on my pen. Burning? Stop? What happened? Charm returns to crab sedan chair? Is tail wagging blue? Don't say that. Hey hey hey hey hey hey! Hey hey? Collapse? Why did you lie when you were staring at Yi Xi flying around? Mode？ Huangqiao? What's the penalty for sucking seeds? Hey hey? Ran Xi's hooked? What's with the sudden chill? Male θ? Huan is dead ∪ saying it's hard to mirror? KINOMOTO SAKURA? What's wrong with Wei Wen's trip? Hui? Reimer? Is it beautiful to raise money? A pair of sweets? Fluorene paddles and ridges? What was the invasion of Su Mo? Φ Φ Φ Φ? Sticky, colorful? What kind of snipe are you smoking? Dicha?

Besides, Pang Tong. Pang Tong, Zhou Yu, Zhuge Liang and Xu Shu are all above 95 in intelligence, all of which are superb. However, in the series of tricks of Battle of Red Cliffs, Cao Ying is the only one who knows everything, while Cheng Yu and Xun You have a little knowledge. In fact, does Xu Shu know that the serial stratagem has no influence on the war? Why did he say that he saw through Zhou Yu and others' serial schemes? In order to highlight Pang Tong, Xu Shu had to be taught by Pang Tong, which shows Pang Tong's ingenuity. But objectively speaking, with Xu Shu's cleverness, how can he not figure out a way? Pang Tong thought of a coup in a few words, that is, Xu Shu's unsuccessful plan. Is there such a big gap? Is it possible?

In short, the position of the novel is that Shu is an orthodox country, Cao Wei is a usurper country (Cao Pi usurps Liu and Hanwang is a successor country), and history cannot be changed. Shu Han was destroyed by Cao Wei, and inevitably the protagonists Guan Yu and Zhuge Liang were deified and exaggerated. It is popular to call them "artificial gods" now. God is man-made, and the Bible says that God is based on his appearance. Guan Da Lu Bu, knowing the Spring and Autumn Period, Red Rabbit can wade mountains and rivers, Wolong and Harmony can only exist in theory.

Since everything is true and lost in mediocrity, we can't listen for a while, so why should we listen to it all? Real is virtual, virtual is real, tired of listening.