Is Hongmao medicinal liquor a scam or something?

For Hongmao medicinal liquor, it is a bit untrue to say that it is a scam. Because, not through medicinal liquor fraud, nor through medicinal liquor pyramid schemes, but products approved by relevant state departments, trademark registration also meets the statutory requirements. Therefore, it can't be linked to a scam.

But it is not a scam, which does not mean that all the actions of Hongmao medicinal liquor are right and fully comply with national laws and regulations. Because, since 10, according to the situation reported by Health Times, Hongmao medicinal liquor has been punished more than 2,600 times in more than 20 provinces and cities across the country. Therefore, it is also an enterprise with many illegal problems and repeated education. Therefore, it is absolutely difficult to be called a legitimate enterprise.

It is particularly important to note that the core problem of Hongmao medicinal liquor named medicinal liquor is that it is neither a health care product nor a wine, but a medicine. Because there is the approval number of "National Medicine Zhunzi Z 15020795" issued by the State Administration of Pharmaceutical Products, it is called medicine. In other words, it is a real medicine. Since it is a medicine, it cannot be sold in the form of wine or health care products, and it must be handled by the hospital in the form of prescription. It is obviously illegal to promote and sell a drug like a health care product or an ordinary commodity. Then, after breaking the law more than 2,600 times, why can we continue to break the law and even ask the police to arrest the suspects?

Therefore, from this perspective, the harm brought by Hongmao medicinal liquor to society is not a general harm, but a relatively great harm. Because it is generally not illegal to sell medicine as wine and health care products. It's hard to understand why there are still people, especially the so-called experts, scholars and celebrities, for its platform. It can be seen that the problem of Hongmao medicinal liquor today is not an enterprise problem, but a social problem. Those experts, scholars and celebrities who are the platform should speak out at this moment, why Hongmao medicinal liquor can be sold as wine and health care products. How many interests and transactions are there? If you lie with your eyes open because of interest connection and transaction, should the relevant personnel be held accountable?

In fact, this wine is a scam, which harms ignorant consumers and has no medicinal value at all. Thanks to the advertising, I closed down three oral liquids, which were the magic drugs of that year and were well known. It's a miracle, with sales exceeding 3 billion. What is the function of Hongmao medicinal liquor? As for the medicinal value, it is all a lie. Why do we go to see a doctor when we are sick? It's all caused by advertisements. We all know about Hongmao medicinal liquor by watching advertisements. Why did the procuratorate send me back for retrial? Because unilateral evidence can't prove his guilt, he said it was toxic, and the manufacturer couldn't provide medicinal value. The manufacturer's statement couldn't prove the practical value of Hongmao medicinal liquor. Tan Qindong is a doctor himself and has rich medical knowledge. What he said about Hongmao medicinal liquor is very reasonable, and his analysis is really logical, so Hongmao medicinal liquor will not win the case. Tan Qindong was detained mainly because of local protection. Hongmao medicinal liquor has become a pillar industry in the local area, and it is a big profit and tax payer. It would be very troublesome if Tan Qindong was not strongly supported by netizens all over the country. I guess I couldn't get out and was finally convicted. Now it seems that Tan Qindong will definitely win the case. Besides, the government does not dare to mess around under the pressure of public opinion. Tan Qindong will not be convicted, and finally the appropriate compensation from the state will be over.

"Rheumatoid osteopathy, choose Hongmao medicinal liquor", TV advertisements, film and television implants are still vivid. What you think of as a "perfect tonic" health food has actually been a class A OTC drug since 2003.

Recently, the State Administration of Pharmaceutical Products issued a document saying that relevant experts have been organized to demonstrate the transformation of Hongmao medicinal liquor from over-the-counter drugs to prescription drugs. What is the story of this identity change? The medicine says that Jun will show you ~

Hongmao medicinal liquor

Expelling pathogenic wind, removing dampness, invigorating qi, dredging collaterals, relaxing muscles and tendons, promoting blood circulation, invigorating spleen and warming kidney, and can be used for treating arthralgia due to wind-cold-dampness, pain in bones and muscles, weakness of spleen and stomach, kidney deficiency and backache, and deficiency of both qi and blood in women.

abstract

Hongmao medicinal liquor incident

20 17 12 19

Tan Qindong, a doctor in Guangzhou, wrote the article "Hongmao Medicinal Liquor", which is a Chinese god wine and a poison from heaven.

20 18 1 10

Hongmao medicinal liquor claims that the loss of profit caused by the article is about 6.5438+0.42 million yuan. The investigators of Liangcheng County Public Security Bureau of Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region came to Guangzhou and arrested Tan Qindong on suspicion of damaging the reputation of commodities.

2018 April 15

The case of damage to Hongmao's commercial reputation and commodity reputation was transferred for review and prosecution.

2018 April 16

2018 April 16

The State Administration of Pharmaceutical Products announced that it had organized experts to demonstrate the transformation of Hongmao medicinal liquor from over-the-counter drugs to prescription drugs, and instructed the Food and Drug Administration of Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region to explain the safety and effectiveness of Hongmao medicinal liquor.

2018 April 17

The procuratorate of Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region believes that the facts of the case are unclear and the evidence is insufficient, so it returns the case to the public security organ for supplementary investigation and changes compulsory measures.

From beginning to end, the voice of doubt is endless.

false advertising

The advertisement of Hongmao medicinal liquor was reported illegal by the food and drug supervision departments of 25 provinces and cities such as Jiangsu, Liaoning, Shanxi and Hubei, and the number of violations reached 2630 times, and sales were suspended for dozens of times.

"Promoting the efficacy of products in the name of experts and patients", "publishing unapproved contents", "containing unscientific assertions indicating efficacy" and "tampering with approved contents without authorization", etc ... Hongmao medicinal liquor is always notified and suspended for similar reasons, which means that the description of product efficacy is untrue and unscientific.

This formula is questionable.

The formula of Hongmao medicinal liquor contains a variety of toxic and harmful ingredients, which violates the "eighteen oppositions" of traditional Chinese medicine (compatibility of Pinellia ternata and aconite), and its curative effect is still unclear, and its clinical data is extremely scarce.

(Dr. Ning Fanggang, Peking University Medical School, the famous "Burn Superman Po" in Weibo)

Medicinal materials problem

The words "musk" and "natural medicinal materials" appeared in the propaganda of using "artificial musk" in Hongmao medicinal liquor; The "leopard bone" in the formula has some problems such as illegal use of endangered animal medicinal materials and lack of special marks.

(From the official account of Dr. Chun Yu WeChat WeChat)

It must be clear that Hongmao medicinal liquor is medicine.

Hongmao medicinal liquor does have some problems such as exaggerated publicity. The State Administration of Pharmaceutical Products has instructed enterprises to explain to the society the reasons and existing problems of local regulatory authorities punishing their false advertisements in recent five years, explain the safety and effectiveness of drugs concerned by the society, and strengthen the monitoring of adverse reactions. We need to wait patiently.

As a patient, first of all, it is clear that Hongmao medicinal liquor is a medicine and an over-the-counter medicine, which may also cause serious adverse reactions in a few people. From 2004 to the end of October1July, 37 ADR reports of Hongmao medicinal liquor were retrieved in the national ADR monitoring system. The main adverse reactions were dizziness, itching, rash, vomiting and abdominal pain.

Therefore, in the final analysis, Hongmao medicinal liquor should not be used as a health care product. It should be used in strict accordance with the instructions, and the dosage or frequency of use should not be increased at will, and the course of treatment should not be extended without authorization. If there are any adverse reactions in the process of medication, the drug should be stopped in time, and serious cases should go to the hospital in time.

A feather has gone, as light as a feather. As for whether it is a scam or not, although there is no conclusion, it is an indisputable fact that it once became popular all over the country and became famous.

However, it is also a deformed product of the times. With the constant standardization of the market and the improvement of people's legal system and health concept, some problems of Hongmao medicinal liquor were exposed, and then it lost its former aura.

Even if his management team and local government care about protecting economic growth, no matter how hard they try to achieve the goal of restoring economic growth, economic growth has become a bubble that has dissipated and can never retain the illusory dreams of the past.

Although there are sixty or seventy kinds of traditional Chinese medicines in Hongmao, it is inconclusive how many precious leopard bones there are, and even if there are any, how effective they are.

When the mysterious veil no longer exists, it completely loses its value and significance. Is it necessary to entangle and question the issue of fraud?

(network picture)

The Hongmao medicinal liquor incident was in February, 20 17. After Tan Qindong, a Guangzhou medical practitioner, expressed his different views and comments on whether Hongmao medicinal liquor produced in Inner Mongolia could be treated, he was arrested by the police in Liangcheng County, Inner Mongolia for damaging the reputation of goods.

Whether Hongmao medicinal liquor is poisonous or not, Dr. Tan said that it is illegal for medicinal liquor to be poisonous as a traditional Chinese medicine, and there is a great controversy in society. In order to reflect democratic supervision, the different views on this incident in the society are listed as follows for the reference of relevant parties:

First, according to the criminal law, the crime of damaging commodity reputation mainly refers to the crime that a specific person spreads a lot of false statements to the public by fabricating false information, which damages the reputation of a specific commodity and causes great losses.

Second, Dr. Tan didn't fabricate false information from the beginning. It is a fact that Hongmao medicinal liquor was closed by more than 20 provincial drug supervision departments because it was considered to have false advertisements! There is no so-called false information fabricated by Tan. On the contrary, everyone thinks that Tan reflects the real situation.

Thirdly, as a traditional Chinese medicine medicinal liquor, it is toxic in itself, which is a three-point poison. Medicinal liquor is indeed toxic to some acute diseases, such as hepatitis, nephritis, proteinuria, lung disease, swelling poison, dysentery and other diseases, and it is not suitable for drinking. It will have a great effect after drinking.

Fourthly, it is problematic to say that Dr. Tan disseminated information to the public on a large scale. Tan only sends messages to certain acquaintances and friends. The term "large scale" in criminal law refers to unspecified people and unspecified public.

Fifth, the purpose of publishing information is different. Mr. Tan released the news for people's health, to avoid some elderly people and the above-mentioned patients taking drugs or alcohol by mistake and causing adverse consequences. After Tan vilified the medicinal liquor, he didn't have any profit motive and purpose. The criminal purpose of the crime of damaging the reputation of goods mentioned in the criminal law is that all suspects seek commercial benefits.

Sixth, the law of mediation is different. Dr. Tan and Hongmao medicinal liquor belong to the scope of civil law adjustment because of their different evaluation of the attributes and uses of the products. Does not apply to criminal law.

To sum up, in order to make the parties feel fair and just in every case, realize the correct implementation of the principles and policies of governing the country according to law put forward by the Party at the 19 Congress, and make the cases handled stand the test of history, the relevant departments are invited to accept social supervision.

Hong Mao, Zhu San, Qin Chi, Confucius, Sharpis, melatonin. The disadvantages lie in people's television and people's broadcasting station. As long as you pay, it doesn't matter who cares if he is true or not.

Hongmao medicinal liquor is not a scam, but the "marketing" of Hongmao medicinal liquor looks like a scam.

Hongmao medicinal liquor is an over-the-counter prescription of national medicine, which is well documented. Medicinal liquor itself will not be a scam. However, the operator of Hongmao medicinal liquor exaggerates the facts, violates laws and regulations, and is suspected of seriously misleading consumption.

Hongmao medicinal liquor, as a dose of traditional Chinese medicine, of course has its indications for treatment or adjuvant treatment, and also has a clear scope of application, which is suitable for people. However, the operator of Hongmao medicinal liquor has packaged Hongmao medicinal liquor into a "spirit" that can cure all diseases, which obviously violates the basic principle of "honest management".

It is common sense that drugs are not general consumer goods and cannot be sold according to the marketing model of general consumer goods. Packaging over-the-counter drugs into "health care wine", marketing according to general "health care products" and irresponsible marketing propaganda of "taking two pills a day to get rid of the disease" are all cheating consumers.

In fact, many so-called "magic drugs", "magic stickers" and "magic pills" are engaged in "unscrupulous business" of "deceiving consumers". Hongmao medicinal liquor was exposed only because it was "ignorant and fearless", and the consequences were at your own risk.

Only blame the general public in China, especially the middle-aged and elderly people, for their low comprehensive quality, and believe in a few rhetoric advertisements. Although I was cheated, I didn't know it, so Shapu Aisi, Hongmao medicinal liquor and melatonin became popular! No one with a little common sense will believe such nonsense as "false advertising". The so-called "celebrity endorsement" is worthless! From the moment I spoke, I stopped treating such people as celebrities and stars.

It's obviously a scam.

First of all, you have to understand why drugs and health care products should be managed separately. Drugs are aimed at patients with specific diseases at specific stages. Drugs can have toxic and side effects in principle, as long as the toxic and side effects are clear and far less than the benefits of treatment, they can be listed. Health products, also known as health food, are aimed at both healthy people and patients. Generally, it is not mandatory to have a statistically significant curative effect, but it is necessary to prove that it has no toxic and side effects and can be taken safely for a long time. Therefore, the management of health care products and drugs is different.

A drug with obvious toxic and side effects for short-term symptomatic treatment masks the risk of possible toxic and side effects, and is promoted to all consumers including healthy people as a health care product, and is encouraged and induced to take it frequently as a health food. This is not a scam. What else is a scam? If someone sells antibiotics as health products and lets healthy people eat them together, do you think it is a liar?

Whether it's a scam or not, I won't buy it again because of arresting people across provinces.