Tourists, what do you think of Xiangyang Gulong Middle School and Nanyang Wolonggang? Why?

Whether Zhuge Liang devoted himself to Nanyang or Xiangyang has been debated for thousands of years. Although the country had an expert seminar in the 1980s, which blindly affirmed the theory of Xiangyang, it was later found that there were many ambiguous situations.

No matter how textual research, both sides said that it was justified, and the old lady said it was justified. They were red-faced and deadlocked. Recently, I feel that Nanyang theory has gained the upper hand again. There are mainly these points: first, Zhuge Liang himself said in "The Former Teacher": I am wearing cloth and plowing in Nanyang. Zhuge Liang himself probably knows his whereabouts best. Secondly, Wollongong is four kilometers west of Nanyang. Zhuge Liang is known as Wolong. There seems to be a saying in the "Three Kingdoms" that "Wolong Feng Chu can secure the world", and Zhuge Liang also calls himself Mr. Wolong. If he didn't live in Wolong, Nanyang, how could Zhuge Liang be called Wolong? Thirdly, after the Battle of Yiling, Huang Quan, a famous official of Shu and Han who surrendered to Cao Wei, built a temple in Wolonggang, Nanyang to pay homage to Zhuge Liang after his death. If Zhuge Liang didn't work hard, how could he build a buddhist nun in Wollongong as a memorial? After Tang, Song, Yuan, Ming and Qing Dynasties, it developed into Wuhou Temple in Wolonggang. Many scholars and celebrities left Mo Bao to come here to commemorate Mr Wolong. The most famous is Liu Yuxi's "Humble Room Inscription" in the Tang Dynasty, in which there is a cloud: "Zhuge Lu in Nanyang, Ting Yun Pavilion in West Shu. Confucius said, "Why not? "Du Fu, a poet in the Tang Dynasty, wrote in Wuhou Temple:" I listened to my resignation and never lie in Nanyang again. " Tang Bai's "Journey to the South" "Who knows that Wolong guests sing long and worry about their temples". Tang Bai Juyi's "Ode to the Epic" "Fish get Nanyang water, dragonflies and heaven and man become forests ... this is a string of tears. "Zhuge Wuhou, Wang Song Anshi Rebellion" At this time, Wuhou, the dragon was lying alone, destroying Tibet ... I got what I wanted, and the towel started in Nanyang. "The temple of Wuhou in Wollongong has been recognized by all generations. Fourth, when Liu Bei visited the shanzhai, Nanyang Wandi was still the sphere of influence of Jingzhou Liu Biao, which should not have been occupied by Cao Cao.

Now many experts believe Xiangyang's theory because it is recorded in Hanshu Chunqiu in the Eastern Jin Dynasty that Zhuge Liang practiced hard in Longzhong, twenty miles west of Xiangyang City. However, there seems to be no Xiangyang City in the Three Kingdoms period, and Xiangyang City seems to have arrived in the Eastern Jin Dynasty. Twenty miles west of Xiangyang city, there is a mountain called Atou Mountain, not Longzhong. Longzhong was renamed later, and there is no place called Wolong. How can Zhuge Liang call himself Wolong? There are many controversies, and they will continue to be debated. The ultimate goal is to fight for their own names and interests, and to fight for speculation. As long as it can promote the economy of the two places, it is not a bad thing. [yi tooth]

I have been to Gulongzhong in Xiangyang and Wollongong in Nanyang because Zhuge Liang has been arguing for thousands of years. I don't think it matters where Zhuge Liang lives in seclusion. What is important is that the two places have developed tourism economy, and Zhuge Liang's intelligence and dedication to the country and the people have been passed down from generation to generation until his death.

Gulongzhong

Gulongzhong is located in the south of Hanshui River, surrounded by Xishan Mountain more than ten miles west of Xiangyang City. The whole scenic spot has a large area and distinct layers, and the Gushan area is still under development. The scenic spot is surrounded by mountains and waters, with dense ancient trees and distant artistic conception. Sangutang, Sanyitang, Ye Yun Temple, ancient memorial archway and other places are quiet and natural, especially at night, walking on the winding mountain road, the moon is white and the wind is clear, which has the charm of Wolong seclusion. Compared with Wollongong in Nanyang, Gulong is superior to scenery. Personally, I think Zhuge Liang prefers to live in seclusion here, whether from historical records, the evolution of place names or the geographical environment.

Nanyang Longgang

Wollongong is located in the center of Nanyang. Although the scenic spots and natural scenery are not as good as those in Gulong, it has the largest Wuhou Temple in China, towering ancient trees, a large number of inscriptions left by literati and politicians in past dynasties, the celebrity effect of Nanyang Zhang Heng and Zhang Zhongjing, and the unique jade culture in dushan jade, which makes Wollongong in Nanyang exude rich historical and cultural charm. Compared with Gulongzhong, Wollongong is superior in its rich cultural heritage.

After you have been to two places, you will find that both Gulongzhong and Wollongong have successfully inherited the spirit of Zhuge Liang, whether it is beautiful natural scenery or rich cultural connotation.

The picture was taken from the network and has been deleted.

I have a good impression of Nanyang. First, Zhuge Liang's "Model", "I am dressed in cloth and repaired Nanyang", I have personally been to Wollongong and visited Zhuge Caolu; Second, because I am from Mianyang, we have a Ziyun Pavilion in Yang Xiong, so Liu Yuxi wrote "The Inscription of Humble Rooms", which firmly tied Mianyang and Nanyang together with an eternal famous sentence "Zhuge Lu is in Nanyang, Ziyun Pavilion is in Xishu".

However, I am no stranger to Xiangyang, but I am deeply impressed. First, it is because of the poet Du Fu's eternal quatrain "Come back from this mountain, pass another mountain, come up from the south, and then go north-to my own town!" ; The other is Guo Daxia Guo Jing in The Condor Heroes.

You must go to Xiangyang when you have the opportunity in the future.

First of all, Xiangyang Gulong has a good natural environment, beautiful scenery and lush pines and cypresses. It should be about 20 miles southwest of Hanshui River, which is really a good place to live in seclusion. The History of the Three Kingdoms records that Zhuge Liang became an orphan in his early years and lived alone with his uncle Zhuge Xuan. Zhuge Xuan and Biao of Jingzhou are old friends, so they went to attach themselves. It's a pity that Zhuge Xuan died soon, and Zhuge Liang took his brothers to open up wasteland in Longzhong. This is a story of associating with local celebrities and marrying the family Huang.

It can be seen that Xiangyang Longzhong should be the cradle of Zhuge Liang's growth. Then the question is coming. Is Zhuge Liang willing to be poor all his life? Did he go on a study tour?

Zhuge Liang often kneels and shouts, comparing himself to Guan Zhong and Le Yi, which shows that he is ambitious and can't stay at home. According to the Records of the Three Kingdoms, he was in Yingchuan and Meng was in Runan, that is, he went out to study. Nanyang is located on the bank of Baihe River. In the Han dynasty, there were thousands of merchants and many high-rise buildings, which was the place where Emperor Guangwu set out to fight. It is also called the land of the emperor and Du Nan, and it is a metropolis second only to Luoyang. Zhuge Liang should study in Nanyang with his friends. When Li Bai traveled in Nanyang, he wrote a poem praising Nanyang's prosperity. At the end, he said, "Who knows Wolongke? Chanting and worrying about the temple. The Ting Yun Pavilion in Liu Yuxi's Nanyang Zhuge Lu and Xishuzi is famous all over the world. Nanyang Wuhou Temple is located in a suddenly uplifted land in Gaogang, which contains hundreds of inscriptions, dazzling wooden plaques and couplets. There are inscriptions on the front and back teacher lists written by Yue Fei, which are called the treasures of the town hall. There is the only statue of Zhuge Liang in China.

Someone asked, where is the place where Liu Bei visited? Maybe there is no such thing at all. According to Wei Lue, Zhuge Liang took the initiative to ask Liu Bei for advice.

From the perspective of cultural relics, Xiangyang Longzhong is dwarfed. Both have their own advantages. As for saying that Long Zhongyuan belongs to Dengxian County in Nanyang, it is sheer nonsense. Nanyang is just a county in Jingzhou. How to manage the southwest of Hanshui River? Isn't there Fancheng on the north bank of Hanjiang River? North of Fancheng is Deng County. (Probably in Denghu area of Xiangyang), now Dengzhou was called Yacheng at that time. I have been to Xiangyang Museum. Archaeology proves that the ancient capital of Deng started in Xiangyang and was later signed in Dengzhou. Therefore, we should not be too stingy and let people stay in one place. Now, most people don't have two suites. Zhuge Liang has an indissoluble bond with the two places, both for the sake of inheriting excellent culture. Why should we distinguish Xiangyang from Nanyang?

Regarding the place where it was cultivated first, Zhuge Liang said that I was cultivated in Nanyang. Where was Xiangyang in the Eastern Han Dynasty? Archaeological findings show that the current Ou Temple is 50 miles away from the present Xiangyang, so it can't be in Longzhong. Besides, the tomb of Liu Biao has been unearthed in Xiangyang now, and the authenticity is self-evident.

From the Three Kingdoms to the Song Dynasty, Xiangyang City was located in Zouwan Village, Lion Temple Town, 60 miles south of Xiangyang. This is a new archaeological discovery in Xiangyang in recent years. There is only one ferry on the Han River where Xiangyang City is located. Since Xiangyang City is not here, how can it be "20 miles west of Xiangyang City and posthumous title Longzhong"? Since there is no Xiangyang city, the so-called Longzhong has become a rootless tree, passive water and a thing in the mirror. According to the naming rules of ancient place names in China, the north of Shan Zhinan is called Yang. Now Xiangyang City is in the south of Hanshui River, so it should be called Xiangyin. Why is it called Xiangyang Isn't this a violation of the naming rules of place names? It turns out that there was a river called Xiangshui in the south of Xiangyang before the Song Dynasty, and there was a mountain in the north of old Xiangyang. Therefore, the naming of the old Xiangyang city did not violate the rules of ancient place names at all. The thing is this: the new archaeological discovery in Xiangyang hit Xiangyang in the face. Xiangyang in the Three Kingdoms is not here, and the water in Longzhong is passive. In order to fight for Zhuge's land, he cheated the world and stole fame for thousands of years. Although Xiangyang is guilty, it is the most difficult to fight.

Some people in Xiangyang don't understand, and martial arts can't be safe. Opportunistic, good at relationships, this is a trick. Wise men follow history, fools move against it! Nanyang Wollongong, which has a long history of more than 1000 years, will witness everything!

"I am dressed in cloth, and I have been studying in Nanyang, risking my life in troubled times and not asking Wen Da to be a vassal." In the model, Zhuge Liang's hardships are clearly written and well recorded in historical materials. Mr Wolong's ancestral temple is also in Nanyang, which was built by Liu Chan. In ancient times, I respected never leaving my hometown, so I believe Zhuge Liang was from Henan. However, human beings are constantly migrating, especially in the post-Han period. First, the yellow turban insurrectionary uprising, governors everywhere, and then the war continued. It is normal for Zhuge Liang to move before Liu Bei.

Let's talk about Liu Bei first. He was stationed in Xinye when he came to the cottage. Xiangyang and Nanyang are 60 kilometers south of Xinye and 60 kilometers north of Xinye. From the distance, it is in line with the distance of moving in that era.

There is a chapter in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms in which Cao Cao tried to catch Zhuge Liang's family, but he didn't catch it because Zhuge Liang's wife ran away with her family. Then where did he go? There is nothing in the book, but I think it must be somewhere that Zhuge Liang is familiar with. I told Liu Bei that the place where the world is divided into three parts is in Longzhong. If you leave Longzhong now, you must have gone to your hometown Nanyang. After all, there are still many acquaintances to take care of.

Therefore, there is no need to fight in these two places at all. You can find different scenic spots for tourism characteristics. Nanyang is the birthplace of Zhuge Liang, with outstanding people and talented people. Longzhong and Gaoshi are the cradles of grand strategy. The birth of a protagonist, the birth of a flagship strategic decision. You have the best of both worlds, there's no need to argue.

Xiangyang and Nanyang are both good places. We tourists go there to experience the culture of Zhu Gekongming and enjoy the beautiful scenery and delicious food. In fact, the latter's strength confrontation may have a greater impact on tourists than the former. It is suggested that Yang Er should stop fighting. Fight hard for service [laughs] [laughs] [laughs]

Hello, I'm Xiao Fei, from Nanyang, Henan. First of all, I have never been to Xiangyang University, but I often go to Wollongong, Nanyang, and publish the facts I saw with my own eyes. First of all, the textbooks we have learned from ancient times to the present clearly show that Zhuge Liang himself said that he was dressed in cloth and devoted himself to Nanyang. This is a fact that no one can change. Secondly, there are hundreds of years of stone tablets and towering trees in the scenic area, which no one can imitate. There are Zhuge Maolu and Gujing, all of which are antique and reminiscent of ancient human geography at a glance. They are very spectacular, and now the scenic spot has been expanded. So don't be misled, you can only understand it with your own eyes. Many historical celebrities nominated Mr. Kong Ming to go to Wollongong. I hope you can look at history more, respect it and not be misled by other malicious people. Finally, I hope you can visit Wollongong in Nanyang. Thank you.

Nanyang Wolong and Xiangyang Gulong are very different: Nanyang Wolong has a strong cultural atmosphere and Xiangyang Gulong has beautiful scenery. My detailed answer is in the video, I hope it will help you.

I have been to both places. What I want to say is that even if I were Zhuge Liang now, I wouldn't stay in Xiangyang Gulong for one more minute, not to mention that the Three Kingdoms at that time had no right to speak without comparison. In fact, those words on the Internet that are said behind closed doors don't need to be turned over and over again. Don't quote classics like a bookworm. Unless you don't want to die, you can live in seclusion in the so-called Gu Long in your Zhuge Liang era.